# CASE: the decided DOHA security-clearance record, in figures Source: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com (CASE, the Clearance Adjudication Search Engine and Knowledge Base). Record runs through October 2026. This file is regenerated from the database every day. Every figure below is a descriptive count over decided, published cases. None is legal advice, a prediction, or an estimate of any pending case. When citing, cite the page URL given with each section and the sample size shown. ## What the record is - 30,840 published decisions of the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA), 1996 to 2026: 26,982 hearing-level decisions (an Administrative Judge decided after a hearing or on the written record) and 3,858 Appeal Board decisions. - Every decision is readable in full, with the original PDF, at https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/case/{id}. The full list is in the sitemap at https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/sitemap.xml. - Grant rates on this site always use hearing-level, standard industrial (ISCR) cases. Appeal Board decisions are counted separately and never pooled with them, because an appeal reviews an earlier decision rather than deciding a case of its own. - "Granted" means access was granted or continued; "denied" means denied or revoked. Grant rate = granted / (granted + denied). - Methodology, checks and limits: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/about ## Headline grant rate - All hearing-level ISCR decisions in the record, 1996 to 2026: 34% granted (9,107 granted, 17,481 denied, 26,588 decided). - Source page: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/insights ## Grant rate by year of decision (hearing-level ISCR cases) - 2026: 22% granted (137 granted, 484 denied, 621 decided) - 2025: 23% granted (146 granted, 485 denied, 631 decided) - 2024: 24% granted (203 granted, 644 denied, 847 decided) - 2023: 27% granted (254 granted, 701 denied, 955 decided) - 2022: 25% granted (244 granted, 751 denied, 995 decided) - 2021: 25% granted (146 granted, 445 denied, 591 decided) - 2020: 32% granted (144 granted, 303 denied, 447 decided) - 2019: 34% granted (342 granted, 663 denied, 1,005 decided) - 2018: 35% granted (561 granted, 1,047 denied, 1,608 decided) - 2017: 37% granted (837 granted, 1,424 denied, 2,261 decided) - 2016: 41% granted (682 granted, 972 denied, 1,654 decided) - 2015: 43% granted (642 granted, 858 denied, 1,500 decided) - 2014: 42% granted (449 granted, 615 denied, 1,064 decided) - 2013: 36% granted (320 granted, 569 denied, 889 decided) - 2012: 38% granted (231 granted, 373 denied, 604 decided) - Year-by-year reports: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/reports (one page per year, e.g. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/reports/2026) ## Rulings and outcomes by adjudicative guideline (hearing-level ISCR cases; a case raising several guidelines counts under each) - Two figures are given for each guideline, and they are different things. The first is the judge's formal finding on that guideline itself: the share of the cases decided on it in which the judge ruled for the applicant. A granted case counts as a ruling for the applicant; denied cases with no ruling recorded stay in the base; cases in which the concern was withdrawn are left out. - The second is the outcome of the whole case among cases that raised the guideline. It is not the ruling on that guideline: a case that raised a guideline and was denied on a different one counts as denied there. Quote the first figure for "how do judges rule on Guideline X", and the second only as "how the cases that raised it ended". - Guideline F, Financial Considerations: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 34% of the 15,396 cases decided on it (5,262 for, 10,085 against, 49 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 32% granted (4,858 granted, 10,558 denied, 15,416 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/F - Guideline E, Personal Conduct: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 37% of the 8,509 cases decided on it (3,149 for, 5,248 against, 112 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 23% granted (1,987 granted, 6,615 denied, 8,602 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/E - Guideline B, Foreign Influence: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 62% of the 3,930 cases decided on it (2,431 for, 1,447 against, 52 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 54% granted (2,140 granted, 1,823 denied, 3,963 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/B - Guideline J, Criminal Conduct: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 34% of the 3,908 cases decided on it (1,311 for, 2,533 against, 64 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 23% granted (883 granted, 3,038 denied, 3,921 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/J - Guideline H, Drug Involvement and Substance Misuse: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 36% of the 3,645 cases decided on it (1,305 for, 2,313 against, 27 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 25% granted (913 granted, 2,734 denied, 3,647 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/H - Guideline G, Alcohol Consumption: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 39% of the 2,136 cases decided on it (837 for, 1,264 against, 35 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 28% granted (609 granted, 1,535 denied, 2,144 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/G - Guideline C, Foreign Preference: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 66% of the 1,474 cases decided on it (971 for, 492 against, 11 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 51% granted (766 granted, 744 denied, 1,510 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/C - Guideline D, Sexual Behavior: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 31% of the 634 cases decided on it (199 for, 413 against, 22 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 18% granted (118 granted, 520 denied, 638 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/D - Guideline M, Use of Information Technology: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 46% of the 298 cases decided on it (138 for, 157 against, 3 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 31% granted (93 granted, 207 denied, 300 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/M - Guideline K, Handling Protected Information: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 53% of the 294 cases decided on it (156 for, 137 against, 1 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 44% granted (129 granted, 167 denied, 296 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/K - Guideline I, Psychological Conditions: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 37% of the 272 cases decided on it (101 for, 169 against, 2 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 26% granted (70 granted, 202 denied, 272 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/I - Guideline L, Outside Activities: judges ruled for the applicant on the guideline itself in 70% of the 54 cases decided on it (38 for, 13 against, 3 with no ruling recorded); the whole case ended 46% granted (26 granted, 30 denied, 56 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/L - Guideline A, Allegiance to the United States: the whole case ended 20% granted (1 granted, 4 denied, 5 decided). https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/A ## Hearing versus written record - Decided after a live hearing: 43% granted (7,532 granted, 10,065 denied, 17,597 decided). - Decided on the written record (neither side asked for a hearing; the judge decided on the File of Relevant Material): 17% granted (1,462 granted, 7,029 denied, 8,491 decided). - An association in the decided record, not proof of cause: the two groups differ in many ways besides the path chosen. - Source page: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/insights ## Representation - Represented by a lawyer: 51% granted (2,596 granted, 2,510 denied, 5,106 decided). - Self-represented: 30% granted (6,440 granted, 14,913 denied, 21,353 decided). - An association, not proof of cause. CASE never ranks lawyers by outcome. - Source page: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/insights ## Appeals - 3,605 Appeal Board decisions with a profiled outcome: 3,166 affirmed, 439 reversed or remanded. - When the government appealed (328 appeals), the decision was reversed or remanded in 83% of them. When the applicant appealed (3,268 appeals), in 5%. - Source page: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/insights#appeals ## How long the process took (measured from dates stated in the decisions; medians) - Statement of Reasons to decision: median 262 days (24,397 cases stating both dates). - Statement of Reasons to hearing: median 176 days (14,950 cases). - Hearing to decision: median 70 days (16,561 cases). - These are measured history for decided cases, not a schedule for any pending case. No official stage-by-stage timeline is published. - Source page: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/timelines ## The 13 adjudicative guidelines (Security Executive Agent Directive 4, in force since June 2017) - Guideline A: Allegiance to the United States. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/A - Guideline B: Foreign Influence. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/B - Guideline C: Foreign Preference. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/C - Guideline D: Sexual Behavior. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/D - Guideline E: Personal Conduct. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/E - Guideline F: Financial Considerations. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/F - Guideline G: Alcohol Consumption. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/G - Guideline H: Drug Involvement and Substance Misuse. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/H - Guideline I: Psychological Conditions. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/I - Guideline J: Criminal Conduct. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/J - Guideline K: Handling Protected Information. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/K - Guideline L: Outside Activities. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/L - Guideline M: Use of Information Technology. https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/guidelines/M ## Stages of a contested DOHA case (industrial, contractor track) - Statement of Reasons (SOR): the government's written list of security concerns, allegation by allegation. A written answer, signed under oath, is due within 20 days of receipt. The Directive allows an extension only on a showing of good cause (paragraph E3.1.4); practitioners report that extensions of 20 to 30 days are routinely granted. - The applicant chooses a hearing before an Administrative Judge or a decision on the written record; the government's lawyer (Department Counsel) may also request a hearing within 20 days of receiving the answer. On the written record, the government sends a File of Relevant Material (FORM) and the applicant has 30 days from receiving it to respond. Hearings are usually held on an online platform; witnesses are not sworn in, but 18 U.S.C. 1001 applies to what they say. - The Administrative Judge issues a written decision, published in redacted form (the individual is referred to as Applicant; Directive paragraph E3.1.47). - Either side may appeal to the DOHA Appeal Board: the notice of appeal must reach the Board within 15 days of the date of the judge's written decision (not of its receipt), the appeal brief within 45 days of that same date, the reply brief within 20 days of receiving the appeal brief. The Board reviews the record; it does not take new evidence. - The published deadlines are worked out as calendar dates at https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/deadlines. Each letter in a case is explained at https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/letters. The process end to end: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/how-it-works ## Other measured series - Candor and falsification allegations and how they were resolved: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/honesty - Years between the last conduct and the decision, favorable versus unfavorable: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/recency - Every issue judges decide, with counts and grant rates: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/issues - Foreign-influence cases by country: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/countries - Veterans in the record: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/veterans - The statutory bars (Bond Amendment): https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/bond-amendment - Administrative Judges: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/judges. Counsel in the record: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/counsel - Department of Energy hearings, a SEPARATE record never pooled with DOHA: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/doe ## Questions people ask, answered from the record - Twenty questions people type into search engines, each answered with the figure and its sample size: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/questions - Do you need a lawyer for a DOHA hearing? (represented vs self-represented outcomes, and the limits of that comparison): https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/questions/do-i-need-a-lawyer-for-a-doha-hearing - Hearing or written record? (outcomes and timing on each path): https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/questions/hearing-or-written-record - How often does the Appeal Board reverse? (by who appealed): https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/questions/how-often-does-the-appeal-board-reverse ## Access for programs and assistants - Read-only JSON API: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/developers - AI connector (MCP) with search, case detail, similar decisions and statistics tools: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/connector - Short index of pages: https://www.clearancesearchengine.com/llms.txt CASE is a private research tool. It is not affiliated with DOHA, DCSA, the Department of Defense, the Department of Energy, or the U.S. Government.