Read the full decision
*The original of this document contains information which is subject to withholding from disclosure
under 5 U.S. C. § 552. Such material has been deleted from this copy and replaced with XXXXXX’s.
United States Department of Energy
Office of Hearings and Appeals
In the Matter of: Personnel Security Hearing )
)
Filing Date: March 18, 2026 ) Case No.: PSH-26-0075
)
__________________________________________)
Issued: September 8, 2026
__________________________
Administrative Judge Decision
__________________________
Kristin L. Martin, Administrative Judge:
This Decision concerns the eligibility of XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX (hereinafter referred to as “the
Individual”) for access authorization under the Department of Energy’s (DOE) regulations set
forth at 10 C.F.R. Part 710, entitled, “Procedures for Determining Eligibility for Access to
Classified Matter and Special Nuclear Material or Eligibility to Hold a Sensitive Position.”1 For
the reasons set forth below, I conclude that the Individual’s security clearance should not be
restored.
I. BACKGROUND
The Individual is employed by a DOE Contractor in a position which requires that he hold a
security clearance. Derogatory information was discovered regarding the Individual’s alcohol
consumption. The Local Security Office (LSO) began the present administrative review
proceeding by issuing a Notification Letter to the Individual informing him that he was entitled to
a hearing before an Administrative Judge in order to resolve the substantial doubt regarding his
eligibility to continue holding a security clearance. See 10 C.F.R. § 710.21.
The Individual requested a hearing and the LSO forwarded the Individual’s request to the Office
of Hearings and Appeals (OHA). The Director of OHA appointed me as the Administrative Judge
in this matter. At the hearing I convened pursuant to 10 C.F.R. § 710.25(d), (e), and (g), the
Individual presented the testimony of one witness—his former supervisor—and testified on his
own behalf. See Transcript of Hearing, OHA Case No. PSH-26-0075 (hereinafter cited as “Tr.”).
The LSO presented the testimony of the DOE psychologist (Psychologist) who had evaluated the
Individual. See id. The LSO submitted eleven exhibits, marked as Exhibits 1 through 11
(hereinafter cited as “Ex.”). The Individual submitted two exhibits, marked as Exhibits A and B.
1 Under the regulations, “‘[a]ccess authorization’ means an administrative determination that an individual is eligible
for access to classified matter or is eligible for access to, or control over, special nuclear material.” 10 C.F.R.
§ 710.5(a). Such authorization will also be referred to in this Decision as a security clearance.
2
II. THE NOTIFICATION LETTER AND THE ASSOCIATED SECURITY
CONCERNS
As indicated above, the Notification Letter informed the Individual that information in the
possession of the DOE created a substantial doubt concerning his eligibility for a security
clearance. That information pertains to Guideline G of the National Security Adjudicative
Guidelines for Determining Eligibility for Access to Classified Information or Eligibility to Hold
a Sensitive Position, effective June 8, 2017 (Adjudicative Guidelines). These guidelines are not
inflexible rules of law. Instead, recognizing the complexities of human behavior, these guidelines
are applied in conjunction with the factors listed in the adjudicative process. 10 C.F.R. § 710.7.
Guideline G states that “excessive alcohol consumption often leads to the exercise of questionable
judgment or the failure to control impulses and can raise questions about an individual’s reliability
and trustworthiness.” Adjudicative Guidelines at ¶ 21. Conditions that could raise a security
concern include:
(a) Alcohol-related incidents away from work, such as driving while under the
influence, fighting, child or spouse abuse, disturbing the peace, or other
incidents of concern, regardless of the frequency of the individual’s alcohol
use or whether the individual has been diagnosed with alcohol use disorder;
(b) Alcohol-related incidents at work, such as reporting for work or duty in an
intoxicated or impaired condition, drinking on the job, or jeopardizing the
welfare and safety of others, regardless of whether the individual is
diagnosed with alcohol use disorder;
(c) Habitual or binge consumption of alcohol to the point of impaired judgment,
regardless of whether the individual is diagnosed with alcohol use disorder;
(d) Diagnosis by a duly qualified medical or mental health professional (e.g.,
physician, clinical psychologist, psychiatrist, or licensed clinical social
worker) of alcohol use disorder;
(e) The failure to follow treatment advice once diagnosed;
(f) Alcohol consumption, which is not in accordance with treatment
recommendations, after a diagnosis of alcohol use disorder; and
(g) Failure to follow any court order regarding alcohol education, evaluation,
treatment, or abstinence.
Id. at ¶ 22.
The LSO alleges that in January 2026, the Psychologist evaluated the Individual and, in a January
21, 2026, report, concluded that the Individual met sufficient Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-
Fifth Edition-Text Revision (DSM-5-TR) criteria for a diagnosis of Alcohol Use Disorder,
Moderate, that his pattern of alcohol use was habitual to excess, and that there was not adequate
3
evidence of rehabilitation or reformation. Ex. 1 at 5.2 These allegations fall under conditions (c)
and (d) of Guideline G. Accordingly, the LSO’s security concern under Guideline G is justified.
III. REGULATORY STANDARDS
A DOE administrative review proceeding under Part 710 requires me, as the Administrative Judge,
to issue a Decision that reflects my comprehensive, common-sense judgment, made after
consideration of all of the relevant evidence, favorable and unfavorable, as to whether the granting
or continuation of a person’s access authorization will not endanger the common defense and
security and is clearly consistent with the national interest. 10 C.F.R. § 710.7(a). The entire process
is a conscientious scrutiny of a number of variables known as the “whole person concept.”
Adjudicative Guidelines at ¶ 2(a). The protection of the national security is the paramount
consideration. The regulatory standard implies that there is a presumption against granting or
restoring a security clearance. See Department of Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518, 531 (1988) (“clearly
consistent with the national interest” standard for granting security clearances indicates “that
security determinations should err, if they must, on the side of denials”); Dorfmont v. Brown, 913
F.2d 1399, 1403 (9th Cir. 1990) (strong presumption against the issuance of a security clearance).
The Individual must come forward at the hearing with evidence to convince the DOE that granting
or restoring access authorization “will not endanger the common defense and security and will be
clearly consistent with the national interest.” 10 C.F.R. § 710.27(d). The Individual is afforded a
full opportunity to present evidence supporting his eligibility for an access authorization. The
Part 710 regulations are drafted so as to permit the introduction of a very broad range of evidence
at personnel security hearings. Even appropriate hearsay evidence may be admitted. Id. at
§ 710.26(h). Hence, an individual is afforded the utmost latitude in the presentation of evidence to
mitigate the security concerns at issue.
The discussion below reflects my application of these factors to the testimony and exhibits
presented by both sides in this case.
IV. FINDINGS OF FACT
The Individual began drinking regularly after he turned twenty-one in 2023 in order to “get away”
and experience a more relaxed state of mind. Ex. 8 at 33. He reported that he developed a pattern
of consuming two or three alcoholic beverages per day on weekdays and four or five on weekends,
usually while alone. Id. He later clarified that the beverages he had described as beers were sixteen-
ounce malt beverages containing ten percent alcohol by volume, each equivalent to approximately
2.3 standard drinks. Id. at 35. Accordingly, five of those beverages were equivalent to more than
eleven standard drinks. Id. He soon realized that he had an issue with alcohol, particularly after his
mother commented on how often she saw him consuming alcohol. Id.
In August 2024, the Individual requested an appointment with a DOE site psychologist because he
was concerned about his drinking. Ex. 8 at 33. At the appointment, he reported consuming up to
five drinks per day on weekends and one or two drinks per day during the week, but stated that he
2 DOE exhibit page numbers will be cited using the Bates stamp in the top right corner of the documents.
4
had stopped drinking and begun attending Celebrate Recovery, a peer-support program. Id. at 33.
The site psychologist did not consider the reported pattern sufficient to diagnose an alcohol use
disorder or raise a security concern and encouraged the Individual to continue attending the peer-
support program. Id. The Individual attended weekly meetings and abstained from alcohol for
about three months with the intent to eventually return to controlled, occasional drinking. Id.
After the three months of abstinence, he attempted controlled drinking, consuming one or two
drinks occasionally. Ex. 8 at 33. He was able to maintain this level of drinking for a few months
but eventually resumed daily drinking. Id. At some point, he briefly returned to the Celebrate
Recovery and resumed abstinence.3 Id. at 33–34. The Individual later told the Psychologist that he
remained abstinent for six months before resuming alcohol consumption on November 14, 2025.
Id. at 34. Contra. Ex. 5 at 19 (incident report stating typical alcohol consumption of two to three
beers per month prior to November 18, 2025, with no start date given for this pattern). However,
he later testified that during that period he had consumed “a couple” alcoholic beverages per month
and had abstained only from becoming highly intoxicated. Tr. at 61, 64–65, 75–77. He
acknowledged that he had told the Psychologist that he had been abstinent during that period and
stated that he must have mistakenly used the term “abstinent,” when he really meant that he had
not become highly intoxicated. Id. at 76–77. He also ultimately testified that he was not attending
Celebrate Recovery in November 2025 and that he had stopped attending at some point between
May and November because he believed that he “had it beat” and would be fine. Id. at 73–75. The
Individual was unable to recall when he had resumed or stopped attending Celebrate Recovery
during the earlier periods of attempted abstinence. Id. at 62–65.
During the weekend beginning November 14, 2025, the Individual invited friends to stay at his
newly purchased home and drank heavily over several days, at times consuming alcohol after
waking to relieve hangover symptoms. Ex. 8 at 34. On November 17, he called in sick to work and
continued drinking. Id. The Individual began feeling guilt and shame because of the amount of
alcohol he had recently consumed. Id. He began to feel severely depressed, experienced suicidal
thoughts, and formulated a plan to end his life involving a loaded firearm he had. Id. After speaking
with his sister, he called a suicide-prevention hotline, which prompted law enforcement to conduct
a welfare check. Id. Hospital records state that officers found him asleep with a loaded firearm on
the bed and that he was intoxicated; the Individual told the Psychologist that when the officers
arrived, he was asleep on a couch and that the firearm was not near him. Ex. 5 at 21–22; Ex. 8 at
34.
Law enforcement transported the Individual to a local hospital, where records reflected that “his
blood alcohol was 279.”4 Ex. 5 at 22; Ex. 8 at 34. He was assessed to be a danger to himself, and
at the hospital’s recommendation, he voluntarily entered inpatient behavioral-health treatment on
November 18. Ex. 5 at 21–23; Ex. 8 at 36. He was discharged on November 22, 2025. Id. The
inpatient facility diagnosed him with major depressive disorder, severe and recurrent, and mild
Alcohol Use Disorder. Ex. 5 at 22–23. The provider prescribed psychiatric medication for the
Individual and recommended outpatient mental health treatment following discharge, a
recommendation he followed. Id.; Ex. 8 at 34.
3 The Individual was unable to give even a general timeframe for this. Tr. at 63–65.
4 It is likely that this refers to a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .279.
5
After the Individual reported the hospitalization to a supervisor, his employer restricted his access
to the DOE facility. Ex. 7 at 28; Ex. 8 at 31. He was referred to the Psychologist for a substance
abuse evaluation, which occurred on January 6, 2026. Ex. 8 at 31. The Individual told the
Psychologist that he believed alcohol had exacerbated his anxiety and depressed mood and that he
had abstained from alcohol since November 18, 2025. Id. at 34. He further told her that he intended
to abstain from alcohol indefinitely. Id. As part of his evaluation, the Individual submitted to a
Phosphatidylethanol (PEth)5 test, which returned a negative result. Id. at 35. In her subsequent
report, the Psychologist diagnosed the Individual with Alcohol Use Disorder, Moderate, based on
his consumption of alcohol in greater amounts or for longer than intended, unsuccessful efforts to
control his alcohol use, craving, and use of alcohol to relieve or avoid withdrawal symptoms. Id.
at 36. She concluded that the Individual’s pattern of alcohol use was “habitually to excess (‘excess’
defined by bringing his BAC to a level of legal intoxication and ‘habitually’ in this case being
several times per week).” Id. at 38. The Psychologist also concluded that the Individual did not
have an emotional, mental, or personality condition, apart from Alcohol Use Disorder, that
impaired his judgment, stability, reliability, or trustworthiness. Id. at 37–38. She noted that the
Individual had no history of formal substance-abuse treatment, although he had attended Celebrate
Recovery on multiple occasions during the preceding two years. Id. at 35.
The Psychologist determined that the Individual had not demonstrated adequate rehabilitation or
reformation because he had stopped drinking less than two months before the evaluation and was
not then participating in a recovery program. Ex. 8 at 36, 38. To show rehabilitation, she
recommended that the Individual abstain from alcohol for at least twelve months, undergo monthly
PEth testing throughout that period, and attend at least one documented mutual-support recovery
meeting (such as Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) or Celebrate Recovery) each week while working
with a sponsor or otherwise following the program’s guidelines. Id. at 38.
In his March 5, 2026, hearing request, the Individual confirmed that he last consumed alcohol on
November 17, 2025. Ex. 2 at 10. He stated that he had attended weekly Celebrate Recovery
meetings since January 2026 and had obtained negative PEth results. Id. Prior to the hearing, the
Individual submitted into evidence negative PEth results from specimens collected on February
18, March 20, April 14, and May 22, 2026. Ex. A. He also submitted attendance records
documenting his participation in Celebrate Recovery meetings about once per week from January
8 through July 9, 2026. Ex. B.
At the hearing, the Individual testified that his last date of alcohol consumption was still November
17, 2025. Tr. at 38–39. He testified that he had continued monthly PEth testing through July and
intended to continue testing for the full twelve-month period. Id. at 39–41. Results for his June and
July tests were not in the record at the hearing; the Individual testified that he expected those results
to be negative and attributed their absence to difficulty obtaining them from the laboratory. Id. He
also testified that he had continued attending Celebrate Recovery weekly, including a meeting the
5 A PEth test measures a blood sample for levels of an alcohol byproduct. Direct Ethanol Biomarker Testing: PETH,
Mayo Clinic Laboratories, https://news.mayocliniclabs.com/2022/09/13/direct-ethanol-biomarker-testing-peth-test-
in-focus/ (last visited July 31, 2026). The test can detect alcohol consumption in the two to four weeks preceding the
test. Id.
6
day before the hearing, and intended to continue attending. Id. at 41–42. The Individual testified
that neither the PEth testing nor the recovery meetings were requirements imposed by the DOE
site’s occupational medicine provider; he continued them in response to the Psychologist’s
recommendations and voluntarily kept the site psychologist informed of his testing and attendance.
Id. at 54–55.
The Individual testified that, after several months of weekly Celebrate Recovery attendance in
2026, he also began attending a separate Wednesday 12-Step group at the same church where he
attended the Celebrate Recovery meetings. Tr. at 42–44. By the hearing, he had attended the
Wednesday group for approximately one month and spent roughly two hours per week working in
its workbook. Id. at 69–73. He was working on an inventory and did not have a formally designated
sponsor, although the group leader and several accountability partners provided support. Id. at 42–
43, 69–73. The Individual was unable to name the first three steps and acknowledged that he could
devote more effort to the workbook. Id. at 69-73.
The Individual described his current recovery as different from his earlier attempts because he had
decided that he wanted to stop drinking, whereas during his earlier attempts he still wanted and
craved alcohol. Tr. at 44–46. He testified that he had developed a support network whose members
he could contact when struggling. Id. at 46–47. When his grandfather died over the weekend prior
to the hearing, he considered calling a member of that network for help coping with the loss but
did not consider drinking. Id. at 15, 47. He kept no alcohol in his home and testified that he had
remained abstinent while on a beach trip where others were drinking and while spending an
evening with former drinking companions who became intoxicated. Id. at 48–50. The Individual
testified that he intended never to consume alcohol again. Id. at 50.
The Individual’s previous supervisor had known the Individual since about 2022. Tr. at 9–10. He
was involved in Celebrate Recovery and testified that he saw the Individual around six times per
week, including at work and at Celebrate Recovery meetings. Id. at 10. He believed the Individual
was doing well and was taking sobriety seriously. Id. at 10–14. He described himself as an
“accountability partner” for the Individual. Id. at 10, 15. He testified that the Individual would call
him when he was struggling, including with non-alcohol related issues such as grief. Id. at 15. He
attested to the Individual’s attendance and participation in weekly meetings since January 2026.
Id. at 16. He contrasted the Individual’s current participation with his earlier attendance, testifying
that this time, Individual helped set up and tear down meetings, volunteered to read before the
group, was working the 12 Steps, and reached out to other participants. Id. at 12–17. The previous
supervisor was confident that the Individual would be able to remain sober. Id. at 17–18.
After reviewing the Individual’s exhibits and listening to the testimony at the hearing, the
Psychologist updated her opinion. She acknowledged that the Individual had approximately eight
and one-half months of reported abstinence, short of the twelve months she had recommended,
and that the Individual had only submitted four post-evaluation PEth results. Tr. at 81–82. The
Psychologist nevertheless believed that the Individual had demonstrated adequate rehabilitation or
reformation and that his prognosis for continued sobriety was good. Id. at 82–87, 90. She testified,
“I feel like [the Individual] started his process of recovery before this incident actually even
happened.” Id. at 82. She cited his efforts to address his drinking before the November incident,
his current participation in Celebrate Recovery and the additional 12-Step study group, his use of
7
accountability and support resources, and his ability to cope with difficult events without alcohol.
Id. at 82–87. She considered his current participation in Celebrate Recovery adequate even though
he did not have a formal sponsor. Id. at 92–94.
The Psychologist testified that the Individual would still be considered in early remission because
he had not yet reached twelve months without meeting diagnostic criteria for Alcohol Use
Disorder, and she explained that twelve months provides greater confidence against relapse
because it encompasses holidays, anniversaries, and other potential triggers. Tr. at 87, 94. She
attributed the Individual’s difficulty answering some timeline questions at the hearing to
nervousness and a lack of memory rather than intentional deception. Id. at 83, 88–90.
V. ANALYSIS
A person who seeks access to classified information enters into a fiduciary relationship with the
government predicated upon trust and confidence. This relationship transcends normal duty hours
and endures throughout off-duty hours. The government places a high degree of trust and
confidence in individuals to whom it grants access authorization. Decisions include, by necessity,
consideration of the possible risk that the applicant may deliberately or inadvertently fail to protect
or safeguard classified information. Such decisions entail a certain degree of legally permissible
extrapolation as to potential, rather than actual, risk of compromise of classified information.
The issue before me is whether the Individual, at the time of the hearing, presents an unacceptable
risk to national security and the common defense. I must consider all the evidence, both favorable
and unfavorable, in a commonsense manner. “Any doubt concerning personnel being considered
for access for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.”
Adjudicative Guidelines at ¶ 2(b). In reaching this decision, I have drawn only those conclusions
that are reasonable, logical, and based on the evidence contained in the record. Because of the
strong presumption against granting or restoring security clearances, I must deny access
authorization if I am not convinced that the LSO’s security concerns have been mitigated such that
restoring the Individual’s clearance is not an unacceptable risk to national security.
Conditions that may mitigate Guideline G concerns include:
(a) So much time has passed, or the behavior was so infrequent, or it happened
under such unusual circumstances that it is unlikely to recur or does not cast
doubt on the individual’s current reliability, trustworthiness, or judgment;
(b) The individual acknowledges his or her pattern of maladaptive alcohol use,
provides evidence of actions taken to overcome this problem, and has
demonstrated a clear and established pattern of modified consumption or
abstinence in accordance with treatment recommendations;
(c) The individual is participating in counseling or a treatment program, has no
previous history of treatment and relapse, and is making satisfactory
progress in a treatment program; or
8
(d) The individual has successfully completed a treatment program along with
any required aftercare, and has demonstrated a clear and established pattern
of modified consumption or abstinence in accordance with treatment
recommendations.
Adjudicative Guidelines at ¶ 23. None of the mitigating factors apply.
Regarding condition (a), the Individual had a serious alcohol-involved incident in which he nearly
lost his life less than one year ago. This incident occurred after multiple attempts to abstain from
alcohol or limit himself to controlled drinking. It is recent and occurred as part of a pattern of
alcohol use in which the Individual consumed alcohol despite trying to abstain. Even the
Individual’s quotidian alcohol use often included binge drinking, so I cannot find that the
November incident was an isolated event. The Individual’s alcohol use was not far in the past,
minimal, or something that occurred under unique circumstances. It still casts doubt on his
judgment, reliability, and trustworthiness. Condition (a) does not apply.
Regarding condition (b), while the Individual acknowledges his problem with alcohol and has
taken some steps to overcome it, he has not presented evidence sufficient to demonstrate a clear
and established pattern of abstinence in accordance with treatment recommendations. The
Individual was not able to provide evidence of abstinence for several months of his claimed period
of abstinence, including the two months right before the hearing. I cannot be certain that the
Individual is not hiding alcohol use, as he has a history of relapse with slow buildups to high levels
of alcohol consumption. I am also required to take into consideration “[t]he nature, extent, and
seriousness of the conduct” at issue, which in this case involves handling a loaded firearm while
intoxicated, consuming alcohol in the morning to avoid hangover symptoms, binge drinking for
multiple consecutive days, multiple relapses despite attending Celebrate Recovery, and suicidal
ideation connected to continued alcohol use. 10 C.F.R. § 710.7(c). These behaviors are serious, in
some cases matters of life and death. The missing PEth tests are a source of unresolved doubt. The
Individual’s lack of knowledge about the 12 Steps he claims to be working is another source of
unresolved doubt. Even if I consider the months without PEth documentation as sober months, the
Individual falls short of the year it would take for him to be considered in sustained, rather than
early, remission from his Alcohol Use Disorder. The Psychologist stated that one year of
abstinence would give greater confidence in the Individual’s continued sobriety. As such, I
struggle to understand the Psychologist’s confidence in lasting change in this instance. Regardless,
the standard in these proceedings is higher than the typical medical standards of care because all
doubt must be resolved. See 10 C.F.R. § 710.7(a) (“Any doubt as to an individual’s access
authorization eligibility shall be resolved in favor of the national security.”). While I applaud the
Individual’s work in maintaining some documented sobriety and acknowledge the Psychologist’s
favorable opinion, the evidence does not support a finding the Individual has demonstrated a clear
and established pattern of abstinence at this time sufficient to mitigate the extremely serious
behaviors that led the Individual to this hearing. Condition (b) does not apply.
Regarding condition (c), the Individual has no history of formal treatment. However, the
Psychologist’s recommendations did not include formal treatment. The spirit of condition (c) is
that an individual has succeeded where they have failed in the past because they engaged with
treatment for the first time. Even if I considered Celebrate Recovery to be a treatment program—
9
which I do not, in large part due to the absence of mental health professionals and formal group or
individual counseling—the Individual is not new to Celebrate Recovery. He has a history of
relapse after attending that program. I find that condition (c) does not apply because the Individual
has not attended counseling or a treatment program, but even if I accept his 12—Step work as
“treatment,” condition (c) would still not apply because he has a history of treatment and relapse.
Regarding condition (d), as previously noted, the Individual has not completed a treatment
program and aftercare. Even if Celebrate Recovery were to be considered treatment, the Individual
has not presented sufficient evidence for me to find that he has demonstrated a clear and established
pattern of abstinence in accordance with treatment recommendations, as stated above. Condition
(d) does not apply.
For the foregoing reasons, I find that the Individual has not mitigated the Guideline G security
concerns.
VI. CONCLUSION
Upon consideration of the entire record in this case, I find that there was evidence that raised
concerns regarding the Individual’s eligibility for access authorization under Guideline G of the
Adjudicative Guidelines. I further find that the Individual has not succeeded in fully resolving
those concerns. Therefore, I cannot conclude that restoring DOE access authorization to the
Individual “will not endanger the common defense and security and is clearly consistent with the
national interest.” 10 C.F.R. § 710.7(a). Accordingly, I find that the DOE should not restore access
authorization to the Individual.
This Decision may be appealed in accordance with the procedures set forth at 10 C.F.R. § 710.28.
Kristin L. Martin
Administrative Judge
Office of Hearings and Appeals