Read the full decision
*The original of this document contains information which is subject to withholding from
disclosure under 5 U.S. C. § 552. Such material has been deleted from this copy and replaced
with XXXXXX’s.
United States Department of Energy
Office of Hearings and Appeals
In the Matter of: Personnel Security Hearing )
)
Filing Date: April 27, 2026 ) Case No.: PSH-26-0109
)
__________________________________________)
Issued: October 9, 2026
____________________________
Administrative Judge Decision
____________________________
Matthew Rotman, Administrative Judge:1
This Decision concerns the eligibility of XXXXXXXXXX (the Individual) to hold access
authorization under the United States Department of Energy’s (DOE) regulations, set forth at 10
C.F.R. Part 710, “Procedures for Determining Eligibility for Access to Classified Matter and
Special Nuclear Material or Eligibility to Hold a Sensitive Position.”2 As discussed below, after
carefully considering the record before me in light of the relevant regulations and the National
Security Adjudicative Guidelines for Determining Eligibility for Access to Classified Information
or Eligibility to Hold a Sensitive Position (June 8, 2017) (Adjudicative Guidelines), I conclude
that the Individual’s access authorization should not be restored.
I. BACKGROUND
The Individual applied for access authorization in 2021. See Exhibit (Ex.) 12 at 86–138 (2021
Questionnaire for National Security Positions (QNSP)).3 As a result of a background investigation
concerning his eligibility for a security clearance, the DOE learned of three separate incidents
where the Individual was arrested and charged with crimes. Id. at 172 (investigator’s interview
notes with court records clerk). First, in May 2013, officers arrested and charged the Individual
with Simple Battery. Id. In July 2013, the Individual was arrested and charged for Child Abuse,
1 On April 28, 2026, the Director of the Office of Hearings and Appeals (OHA) appointed Administrative Judge Phillip
Harmonick as the Administrative Judge in this matter. On June 24, 2026, the case was reassigned to Administrative
Judge Andrew Dam. Administrative Judge Dam is no longer with the DOE; therefore, on October 9, 2026, the Director
of OHA appointed me as the Administrative Judge in this matter.
2 The regulations define access authorization as “an administrative determination that an individual is eligible for access
to classified matter or is eligible for access to, or control over, special nuclear material.” 10 C.F.R. § 710.5(a). This
Decision will refer to such authorization as “access authorization” or “security clearance.”
3 The DOE submitted Exhibits 1 through 13 as a single PDF, Bates numbered in the upper right corner of each page.
This Decision will refer to the Bates numbering when citing to exhibits submitted by the DOE.
- 2 -
Assault, Criminal Damage to Property, and Evading or Obstructing an Officer. Id. at 72–73
(criminal history). In November 2015, the Individual also was arrested and charged with Assault
to Household Member. Id. at 176 (investigator’s notes after reviewing online court records). The
Individual was subsequently granted a security clearance.
On November 24, 2025, the Local Security Office (LSO) learned from the Individual’s employer
that the Individual had been arrested. Ex. 5 at 20–24. According to court records, the Individual
was arrested on November 23, 2025, and charged with Aggravated Battery Against a Household
Member (Strangulation or Suffocation), Interference with Communications, False Imprisonment,
Abuse of a Child (Does Not Result in Death or Great Bodily Harm), Battery Upon a Peace Officer,
Resisting, Evading or Obstructing an Officer (Arrest), Battery (Household Member), and
Disarming a Peace Officer (Removing Firearm or Weapon). Ex. 9 at 55 (court record of case
details); Ex. 13 at 221 (criminal complaint). The DOE sent the Individual a Letter of Interrogatory
(LOI) to seek clarification and gather information, which the Individual completed and submitted
on January 2, 2026. Ex. 8 at 43–53 (January 2026 LOI).
The LSO subsequently issued a Notification Letter advising the Individual that it possessed reliable
information creating a substantial doubt regarding his access authorization eligibility. Ex. 1 at 6–
8. In a Summary of Security Concerns (SSC) attached to the letter, the LSO explained that the
derogatory information raised security concerns under Guideline J of the Adjudicative Guidelines.
Id. at 5. The Individual exercised his right to request an administrative review hearing pursuant to
10 C.F.R. Part 710. Ex. 2 at 10–12. The Director of OHA appointed Andrew Dam as the
Administrative Judge, and Judge Dam conducted an administrative hearing.
The DOE submitted thirteen exhibits (Ex. 1–13). There were no objections to the LSO’s exhibits.
Hearing Transcript, OHA Case No. PSH-26-0109 (hereinafter cited as Tr.) at 7. The Individual
submitted seven exhibits (Ex. A–G).4 The DOE counsel raised an objection to Exhibit C based on
privacy concerns, but because the exhibit is not immaterial, irrelevant, or unduly repetitious, Judge
Dam overruled the objection. Tr. at 9–14; 10 C.F.R. § 710.26(h) (“The Administrative Judge may
also exclude evidence which is incompetent, immaterial, irrelevant, or unduly repetitious.”). The
Individual offered the testimony of (1) his cousin (Cousin), (2) his mother (Mother), (3) a former
coworker (Former Coworker), and (4) his friend (Friend). Tr. at 3. The Individual also testified on
his own behalf. Id. at 6. The DOE did not offer the testimony of any witnesses. Id.
II. THE SECURITY CONCERNS
Guideline J involves criminal activity “creat[ing] doubt about a person’s judgment, reliability, and
trustworthiness.” Adjudicative Guidelines ¶ 30. Criminal activity “calls into question a person’s
ability or willingness to comply with laws, rules, and regulations.” Id. Conditions that could raise
a security concern include “evidence (including, but not limited to, a credible allegation, an
admission, and matters of official record) of criminal conduct, regardless of whether [an]
4 The Individual’s exhibits were submitted as separate files labeled with letters. This Decision will refer to the exhibit
letter and page number when citing to exhibits submitted by the Individual. Furthermore, Exhibit B was submitted as
three separate PDFs, which I will refer to as Exhibit B(1), Exhibit B(2), and Exhibit B(3). Exhibit C is an email with
three JPGs attached in the body of the email. I have uploaded that email as a PDF into the administrative record as a
single PDF exhibit.
- 3 -
individual was formally charged, prosecuted, or convicted.” Id. ¶ 31(b). In citing Guideline J, the
LSO cited to the Individual’s arrests and charges in May 2013, July 2013, November 2015, and
November 2025. Ex. 1 at 5. Accordingly, there is sufficient derogatory information in the
possession of the DOE to raise security concerns under Guidelines J.
III. REGULATORY STANDARDS
A DOE administrative review proceeding under Part 710 requires me, as the Administrative Judge,
to issue a Decision that reflects my comprehensive, common-sense judgment, made after
consideration of all the relevant evidence, favorable and unfavorable, as to whether the granting
or continuation of a person’s access authorization will not endanger the common defense and
security and is clearly consistent with the national interest. 10 C.F.R. § 710.7(a). The regulatory
standard implies that there is a presumption against granting or restoring a security clearance. See
Dep’t of Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518, 531 (1988) (“clearly consistent with the national interest”
standard for granting security clearances indicates “that security determinations should err, if they
must, on the side of denials”); Dorfmont v. Brown, 913 F.2d 1399, 1403 (9th Cir. 1990) (strong
presumption against the issuance of a security clearance).
An individual must come forward at the hearing with evidence to convince the DOE that granting
or restoring access authorization “will not endanger the common defense and security and will be
clearly consistent with the national interest.” 10 C.F.R. § 710.27(d). An individual is afforded a
full opportunity to present evidence supporting his or her eligibility for an access authorization.
The Part 710 regulations are drafted to permit the introduction of a very broad range of evidence
at personnel security hearings. Even appropriate hearsay evidence may be admitted. Id.
§ 710.26(h). Hence, an individual is afforded the utmost latitude in the presentation of evidence to
mitigate the security concerns at issue.
IV. FINDINGS OF FACT
a. The Individual’s Background and His Arrests and Charges in May 2013, July 2013,
and November 2015
The Individual met his former girlfriend (Former Girlfriend 1) in approximately 2008 when he
was nineteen years old. Ex. 12 at 92 (indicating the Individual’s birth year), 152 (indicating when
the Individual met Former Girlfriend 1). They dated and cohabitated from around 2012 to 2021.
Id. at 153. They have two biological daughters together that were born in 2012 and 2018,
respectively. Tr. at 134. In May 2013, the Individual was given a citation for one count of Simple
Battery. Ex. 12 at 153, 172. When asked about the incident, the Individual testified that he got into
an argument with Former Girlfriend 1’s mother’s boyfriend at the mother’s college graduation
party. Tr. at 125. The Individual further testified that the boyfriend “came to [him], telling [him]
something, as far as [he] can recall, and [they] started arguing.” Id. However, law enforcement
records stated that the Individual “became intoxicated and became belligerent because he wanted
to drive home intoxicated. When [a third party] refused to leave with him, [the Individual] became
hostile and verbally abusive.” Ex. 12 at 172. The Individual testified that he had been drinking that
night but that he was not intoxicated. Tr. at 150–51. When being asked at the hearing about what
happened, the Individual repeatedly mentioned that he was released after his arrest. Id. at 125–26.
- 4 -
The Individual testified that his charge was dismissed, but court records indicate that the
disposition of the charge is unknown. Id. at 121; but see Ex. 12 at 172.5
In July 2013, the Individual was arrested and charged with Abuse of a Child, Criminal Damage to
Property, Assault, and Evading/Obstructing Officer. Id. at 72. The Individual reported that he got
into an argument with Former Girlfriend 1 and a male friend that she showed up to their house
with, a neighbor called the police, and the Individual tried to run off when the police arrived
because they “showed up and did not announce themselves . . . .” Id. at 144–45. The Abuse of a
Child charge was because the Individual was intoxicated at the time, during which he was
responsible for the care of his child. Id. at 145. The Individual testified at the hearing that he was
not intoxicated at the time of the incident, but Former Girlfriend 1 previously reported to an
investigator as part of the background investigation of the Individual that the Individual “was
drunk and had children at home” at the time and that the Individual “did not let her leave with the
kids.” Tr. at 147–48 (Individual’s testimony); but see Ex. 12 at 153. The Individual disagreed with
the representation that he was drunk at the time because the police officers “didn’t give [him] any
kind of blood work or breathalyzer or anything to verify.” Tr. at 148. He testified that the police
officers “basically charged [him] with stuff to make sure that [he] went to jail for the night.” Id. at
145. The record indicates that the Individual damaged the door and window as he was leaving. Ex.
12 at 145. The Individual testified that he “didn’t damage it while [he] was leaving” but that “[i]t
could have been damaged while [he] and [his] friend were arguing.” Tr. at 142–43. The
Individual’s charges were dismissed without prejudice on October 10, 2014. Ex. 12 at 174.
Two years later, in November 2015, the Individual was charged with Assault to Household
Member. Id. at 176. The Individual testified that he did not remember this incident and the only
incident he remembered was “the one with the boyfriend.” Tr. at 133–34. He stated that he has no
memory of being arrested in 2015 and that it “could have been an argument with a family member,
or something like that, but [he] [didn’t] recall ever being arrested in 2015.” Id. at 138–39. An
investigator’s notes of the court history reflect that the Individual pled not guilty and that the case
was dismissed, for reasons not indicated in the record, by the prosecutor on May 5, 2016. Ex. 12
at 176.
b. The Individual’s November 2025 Arrest and Charges
At the hearing, the Individual testified that on November 22, 2025, he and his girlfriend at the time
(Former Girlfriend 2) were at home with her two young children. Tr. at 73. In the afternoon, the
Individual got into an argument with Former Girlfriend 2 because he was “kind of being accused
of talking to other people.” Id. To de-escalate the situation, the Individual contacted his twenty-
two-year-old Cousin to ask if he could come over to his Cousin’s apartment to hang out for a few
hours. Id. at 19, 73. The Individual’s Cousin testified that the Individual was at his apartment from
5 During an enhanced subject interview (ESI) conducted in April 2021, the Individual reported the events related to
the Simple Battery as having occurred in November 2015, rather than May 2013. Ex. 12 at 145. However, at the
hearing, the Individual testified that the events took place in May 2013. Tr. at 124. Law enforcement records indicated
that the events took place on May 12, 2013. Ex. 12 at 172. Accordingly, it appears that during the ESI, the Individual
had conflated the events related to the Simple Battery with his subsequent arrest for Assault to Household Member in
November 2015, which led to the events being incorrectly attributed to the November 2015 arrest on the SSC instead
of the May 2013 arrest. See Ex. 1 at 5 (alleging that the November 2015 arrest occurred “after he got into an argument
at a hotel with ex-girlfriend’s family member . . .”).
- 5 -
5:00 p.m. until around 7:30 p.m. Id. at 20, 24. The Cousin testified that the Individual told him on
that day that Former Girlfriend 2 was “causing a lot of problems for him, blaming him a lot for his
actions . . . they were arguing about . . . what he was doing.” Id. at 21. The Cousin also testified
that Former Girlfriend 2 was texting and calling the Individual while he was at the Cousin’s
apartment, saying that the Individual left her trapped at home because her vehicle was broken and
he took his vehicle to go to the Cousin’s apartment. Id. at 24–25, 73–74. When the Individual
returned home, he played video games on his computer with his Friend who was playing virtually
from approximately 9:00 p.m. until around 3:30 a.m. the next morning. Id. at 74. When he finished
playing video games, he went into the living room to talk to Former Girlfriend 2, they started
arguing, and he told her that he was “not going to do this again” and that he was “just gonna leave
again.” Id. The Individual stated that Former Girlfriend 2 told him that, if he left, he would be
sorry. Id. at 75. The Individual called his Cousin again around 4:00 a.m. to ask if he could come
back to his apartment, but then the Cousin never heard back from the Individual after that phone
call. Id. at 20 (Cousin’s testimony), 25 (Cousin’s testimony), 75 (Individual’s testimony).
On November 23, 2025, around 5:30 a.m., a police officer was dispatched to the Individual’s home
in reference to a 911 hang up call with “screaming on the phone shortly before the phone hung
up.” Ex. 13 at 223. According to the Individual, he started to leave the house, but it was raining so
he went back inside and by the time he came back out, the police officers were already at the gate
to his house. Tr. at 75. According to a police officer’s report, Former Girlfriend 2 and the
Individual got into an argument about each other talking to other people and Former Girlfriend 2
told the officer that the Individual strangled her with his hands, smashed the back of her head into
a glass cabinet in the kitchen, slapped her face, stabbed her in the arm with an injection needle,
pulled out her nose ring, and pulled her hair. Ex. 13 at 223. The police officer also reported that
Former Girlfriend 2 told him that the Individual hung up the phone while she was calling 911 and
was not letting her leave the residence, and that her two young children were in the room when the
incident occurred. Id.
The Individual stated that another police officer arrived at the Individual’s residence and let the
Individual call his mother to come pick him up. Ex. 8 at 46 (January 2026 LOI); Tr. at 75. The
Individual told his Mother that as soon as she got to his house, the police officers would let him
go. Tr. at 32–33. At the hearing, the Individual’s Mother testified that the Individual called her
“between 4:30 and 5:30 in the morning because his girlfriend at the time was screaming at him
and he wanted to get out, and the cops were there.” Tr. at 32. While he was waiting for his Mother
to arrive, the Individual was in the living room speaking with one of the police officers who then
asked to see the Individual’s ID. Id. at 75. The Individual asked the police officer if he was being
arrested, to which the police officer responded “no” and asked the Individual again to see his ID.
Id. at 76. The Individual admitted that he “refused to give [his] ID to the officers . . . three times”
which resulted in two police officers using physical force to pull the Individual off his couch. Ex.
8 at 46. The Individual admitted at the hearing that his refusal was “a big mistake” and that he
“probably could have avoided a lot of the issues that happened.” Tr. at 76. Next, the Individual
stated that he “would not let [the officers] take [him] to the ground so they deployed a taser to [his]
lower back and then lifted [him] up and slammed [him] on the ground.” Ex. 8 at 46; Tr. at 76 (“I
was resisting them, but I wasn’t physically fighting back to them, just not letting them take me to
the ground.”). The Individual testified that “out of reaction from the pain [of the taser], [he] reached
down and [he] pushed the taser off [his] leg.” Tr. at 76. The Individual was transported to jail and
- 6 -
held until the next day, November 24, 2025. Ex. 8 at 47.
The Mother testified that when she arrived at the Individual’s house, the Individual was already in
the officers’ car. Tr. at 33. She testified that she went into the home and Former Girlfriend 2 was
“crying, and she had her baby, and the baby was crying.” Id. The Mother also testified that the
Individual’s glass entertainment center in the living room was broken. Id. at 43. The Mother stated
that one of the police officers told her that Former Girlfriend 2 did not want to go to the hospital,
but they needed her to go to the hospital. Id. at 34. The Mother agreed to take Former Girlfriend 2
to the hospital even though she said Former Girlfriend 2 was insisting that she was fine and did
not want to be taken to the hospital. Id. The Mother testified that the medical staff at the hospital
told her that Former Girlfriend 2 was evaluated and nothing was wrong, but the Mother
acknowledged not being in the room during the evaluation. Id. at 35, 45. The Mother testified that
she observed that Former Girlfriend 2’s nose ring had been taken out of her nose, but did not
indicate that she observed any injury to Former Girlfriend 2’s nose. Id. at 45. The Individual
submitted three photos of Former Girlfriend 2 asleep on a hospital bed with a blanket covering
most of her body. Ex. C at 1–3. The photos do not indicate any physical injuries to the visible areas
of Former Girlfriend 2’s body, which are the arms, nose, neck, and face. Id. The photos are
inconclusive regarding the existence of physical injuries to any other part of Former Girlfriend 2’s
body. Id. The Mother testified that she took the photos, that Former Girlfriend 2 did not know that
the photos were taken, and that Former Girlfriend 2 had not consented to having her photo taken.
Tr. at 57–58. The Mother further testified that Former Girlfriend 2 was asleep in the photos because
“she had gotten an anxiety attack.” Id. at 58.
The Individual denies all Former Girlfriend 2’s claims, stating that she must have confused her ex-
boyfriend with the Individual because “that’s what her ex-boyfriend did to her, as far as strangling
her and all that other stuff, which is why they separated.” Id. at 98. He said she has a history of
lying. Id. When asked to elaborate on Former Girlfriend 2’s history of lying, the Individual
responded that when the two of them started dating, she told him she was single but she was still
living with her ex-boyfriend, that she has a history of self-harm, and that she has a mental health
diagnosis. Id. at 99. The Individual explained that “[t]here was a big age difference between [them]
too, on maturity and stuff.” Id. at 99, 118 (“She’s 22, trying to figure it out, versus, I’m 36, already
kind of established.”). Further, the Individual testified that there were no glass cabinets broken in
his home. Id. at 99. The Individual confirmed that his entertainment center had glass as his Mother
had testified to, but the Individual contended that the entertainment center could not have been
what Former Girlfriend 2 was referring to because it was in the living room. Id. at 99–100.
The Individual was charged with Aggravated Battery Against a Household Member (Strangulation
or Suffocation), Interference with Communications, False Imprisonment, Abuse of a Child (Does
Not Result in Death or Great Bodily Harm), Battery Upon a Peace Officer, Resisting, Evading or
Obstructing an Officer (Arrest), Battery (Household Member), and Disarming a Peace Officer
(Removing Firearm or Weapon). Ex. 9 at 55 (court record of case details); Ex. 13 at 221 (criminal
complaint). The Individual submitted documentation of an affidavit signed by Former Girlfriend
2 on December 19, 2025, stating that she did not wish to proceed with or assist in the Individual’s
prosecution. Ex. D at 1 (Affidavit of Non-Prosecution). On January 13, 2026, the Individual’s
charges were dismissed, notably without prejudice. Ex. F at 1. The Individual acknowledged
during the hearing that the Affidavit of Non-Prosecution only states that Former Girlfriend 2 does
- 7 -
not want to testify or proceed with pressing any charges and not that the events did not occur. Tr.
at 115. The Individual has not had contact with Former Girlfriend 2 since the underlying incident,
except for one instance in which the two of them ran into each other at work because Former
Girlfriend 2 works at the same location in a different area. Id. at 90–91.
The Individual’s Former Coworker testified that she has known the Individual for approximately
thirteen to fourteen years and she sees the Individual in person several times a month. Id. at 63–
64. The Individual did not tell her any details about the November 2025 arrest beyond “they got
in a disagreement and she called the police.” Id. at 66. The Individual’s Friend that he played
computer video games with virtually on the evening of November 22, 2025, into the morning of
November 23, 2025, also testified. Id. at 159. The Friend testified that he has known the Individual
for “around fourteen years” but his communication with the Individual for the last three years has
been limited to phone or video games because the Friend lives in another state. Id. When asked
what he knew about what happened prior to the November 2025 arrest, the Friend testified that the
Individual called him after he was released from jail to “let [him] know that some stuff happened
over the night and he ended up going to jail” and that his understanding was “that a female was
involved.” Id. at 160–61. The Friend testified that while the two of them were still playing, the
Individual told him that he was going to leave to go to his cousin’s because he was stressed out,
but the Individual did not state why and the Friend didn’t ask. Id. at 164–65.
The Individual’s Mother testified at the hearing that, prior to the 2025 arrest, the Individual had
not been arrested or charged with anything since 2013 when he was “fighting with his ex-
girlfriend” and that from 2013 to 2026, the Individual had “changed big time . . . .” Id. at 47, 50.
As an example, the Individual’s Mother provided that the Individual stopped hanging out with his
friends and “gave up everything to be with his family.” Id. at 51. The Individual testified that he
was “super young” in 2013 and that he “made some stupid decisions and [he] really regret[s] what
[he] did.” Id. at 154. The Individual stated that, regarding the 2025 incident, he could not give an
“exact excuse . . . other than [Former Girlfriend 2] was around the age when [he] was making
stupid mistakes the first time and it kind of escalated from there.” Id. at 155. He further stated that
he has separated himself from “bad influences” and that, as he’s grown, he learned to “just face
[similar situations] right off the bat, like there’s no sense in running and making the situation worse
than it has to be.” Id.
V. ANALYSIS
Based on the record before me, the Individual has not mitigated the LSO’s security concerns.
Conditions that could mitigate security concerns under Guideline J include:
(a) so much time has elapsed since the criminal behavior happened, or it happened
under such unusual circumstances, that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast
doubt on the individual’s reliability, trustworthiness, or good judgment;
(b) the individual was pressured or coerced into committing the act and those
pressures are no longer present in the person’s life;
- 8 -
(c) no reliable evidence to support that the individual committed the offense; and
(d) there is evidence of successful rehabilitation; including, but not limited to, the
passage of time without recurrence of criminal activity, restitution, compliance
with the terms of parole or probation, job training or higher education, good
employment record, or constructive community involvement.
Adjudicative Guidelines ¶ 32.
Regarding mitigating condition (b), the Individual has not put forth evidence indicating that he
experienced coercion or pressure to commit any criminal behavior. Mitigating condition (b) does
not apply.
The same reasoning applies as to mitigating condition (d), which requires evidence of
rehabilitation. The Individual contests that he engaged in criminal activity and put forth no
evidence regarding rehabilitation, other than the general testimony that he has “changed” since the
time of the 2013 incidents. Mitigating condition (d) does not apply.
Regarding mitigating condition (a), the most recent arrest occurred in November 2025, less than
one year before the hearing date. The Individual did not put forth evidence of unusual
circumstances under which his criminal behavior occurred. In fact, before the November 2025
arrest, the Individual had three prior incidents with similar circumstances. As such, I cannot find
that so much time has passed or that the criminal behavior happened under such unusual
circumstances that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the Individual’s reliability,
trustworthiness, or good judgment. For these reasons, mitigating condition (a) does not apply.
The Individual based much of his argument on mitigating condition (c), contesting the reliability
of the evidence used to bring forth the charges. The Individual did not accept responsibility for
any of his arrests or charges. Instead, he stated that the arrests and charges were based on inaccurate
information provided by the police officers that responded to the scene and the individuals who
were present when the events took place. The Individual did not dispute that in May 2013 he got
into an argument with Former Girlfriend 1’s mother’s boyfriend that clearly escalated to the level
of someone calling the police. However, the Individual justified his actions by claiming that the
charge was dismissed. Even supposing the charge was dismissed, which is unknown based on the
record, a dismissal in itself is not evidence that the underlying act did not take place. Regarding
the July 2013 charges of Abuse of a Child, Criminal Damage to Property, Assault, and
Evading/Obstructing Officer, the Individual claims that he was not intoxicated and that his
intoxication could not be proven because there was no laboratory testing. He stated that the police
just arrested him so that he would be taken to jail for the night. However, he could not provide any
credible explanation as to why Former Girlfriend 1 would have lied about his intoxication or why
he would have been charged with an offense which he claimed was based on alcohol consumption
if not for him actually having consumed alcohol. While there are factual disputes regarding his
intoxication level that night and what the argument was about, the Individual does not dispute that
he got into an argument with Former Girlfriend 1’s male friend that led to him leaving the house.
When asked about his November 2015 arrest and charge for Assault to Household Member, the
Individual did not even know what that was. I find it troubling that the Individual could not
- 9 -
remember any information about an incident in which he not only got arrested but pled not guilty
to in court. His lack of memory of this incident most certainly undermines his stated recollection
regarding the other criminal incidents. Lastly, regarding the November 2025 arrest, the Individual
admitted that he resisted the police officers when he was asked repeatedly for his ID. He took no
responsibility for his role in the argument with Former Girlfriend 2. The Individual denied all
Former Girlfriend 2’s allegations and placed blame on her for being immature and having a mental
health diagnosis. Again, he attributed his innocence to the fact that the criminal charges against
him were dismissed. Whether or not there was sufficient evidence to prosecute the Individual for
criminal charges does not absolve him of accountability for his actions. Nothing in the record
supports the Individual’s claims that Former Girlfriend 1, Former Girlfriend 2, or any of the
responding police officers from all four arrests were unreliable. Perhaps most importantly, the
Individual admitted to committing several actions underlying the offenses—regardless of whether
the actions, independently, constituted criminal offenses.
I do not credit the Mother’s testimony that Former Girlfriend 2 was completely fine after the
November 2025 incident and the subsequent visit to the hospital. The Mother was not there when
the incident took place in the Individual’s home and was not in the room at the hospital while
doctors evaluated Former Girlfriend 2. Further, the fact that the Mother had to photograph Former
Girlfriend 2 without her permission or knowledge while she was in a state of incapacitation
undermines the Mother’s testimony that Former Girlfriend 2 insisted she was fine. In addition, the
Mother testified that Former Girlfriend 2 was asleep in the photos due to an anxiety attack, which
is inconsistent with the Mother’s claims that Former Girlfriend 2 was fine. As to the context of the
photos, they do appear to demonstrate that there were no visible physical injuries to Former
Girlfriend 2’s arms, nose, neck, and face. While this does not rule out the possibility that Former
Girlfriend 2 suffered injuries that were not visible, or that she suffered an injury to a part of her
body that was under a blanket in the photos, the photographic evidence provides support for the
Individual’s account of events. However, there are other facts that support the conclusion that the
Individual engaged in some form of violence in connection with the November 2025 incident.
First, the fact that the Mother admitted to observing broken glass from a piece of furniture is strong
evidence that the glass was broken during a violent encounter regardless of whether it was with
either Former Girlfriend 2 or the police officers. The Individual’s trivial arguments that Girlfriend
2’s claim was false because the glass was from an “entertainment center” rather than a “cabinet”
suggests an effort to avoid acknowledging that his actions were consistent with her claims. The
Individual admitted during the hearing that he refused to cooperate with the police officers’ request
for his ID three times, which then escalated to their use of physical force on the Individual. The
Individual also admitted that his refusal to provide his ID was a big mistake that led to issues that
could have been avoided, such as his physical altercation with the officers. Lastly, the Individual
admitted that he would not let the officers take him to the ground, which is why they deployed a
taser that the Individual tried to push off of his leg. Also, as noted above, this is not the first
occasion on which the Individual interacted with law enforcement as a result of his allegedly
abusive behavior. The Individual has been accused of abusive behavior by three separate
individuals: Former Girlfriend 1, Former Girlfriend 1’s mother’s boyfriend, and Former Girlfriend
2. Taking all of the foregoing together, I find it much more likely that the Individual behaved
aggressively and that he and Girlfriend 2 had a violent physical encounter, even if it did not occur
exactly as she alleged, than that the Individual’s account is true and Girlfriend 2’s claims were
entirely fabricated. Thus, I find that Girlfriend 2’s allegations and the Individual’s own testimony
- 10 -
about his interactions with the police officers provide some reliable evidence of the Individual
having engaged in criminal conduct. Accordingly, mitigating condition (c) does not apply.
In light of the foregoing, the Individual has failed to resolve the Guideline J concerns asserted by
the LSO.
VI. CONCLUSION
In the above analysis, I found that the DOE possessed sufficient derogatory information to raise
security concerns under Guideline J of the Adjudicative Guidelines. After considering all the
relevant information, both favorable and unfavorable, in a comprehensive, common-sense manner,
including weighing all the testimony and other evidence presented at the hearing, I find that the
Individual has not brought forth sufficient evidence to resolve the security concerns set forth under
Guideline J. Accordingly, I find the Individual has not demonstrated that restoring his security
clearance would not endanger the common defense and would be clearly consistent with the
national interest. This Decision may be appealed in accordance with the procedures set forth at 10
C.F.R. § 710.28.
Matthew Rotman
Administrative Judge
Office of Hearings and Appeals