A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.
ISCR Case No. 24-01243
Appeal BoardDecided Oct 7, 2026 · Administrative Judge Moira D. Modzelewski · Appeal
Appeal at a glance
The appeal involved a challenge to the Administrative Judge's decision to grant the Applicant a security clearance based on financial considerations. The Government argued that the Judge made critical factual errors regarding the Applicant's tax debts and misapplied mitigating conditions. The Board found merit in the Government's arguments and reversed the Judge's decision.
Descriptive structured reading of this decided, public Appeal Board decision: what the case says, not a prediction or advice.
Full decision
Open original PDFThe complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.
Decision text, by section
Appearances
FOR GOVERNMENT Troy Nussbaum, Esq., Department Counsel Andrea M. Corrales, Deputy Chief Department Counsel
Appearances
Sean Rogers, Esq. The Department of Defense (DoD) declined to grant Applicant a security clearance. On December 27, 2024, DoD issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR) advising Applicant of the basis of that decision – security concerns raised under Guideline F (Financial Considerations) of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (AG) in Appendix A of Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (effective June 8, 2017) and DoD Directive 5220.6 (Jan. 2, 1992, as amended) (Directive). On July 23, 2026, Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals Administrative Judge Marc E. Curry granted Applicant national security eligibility. The Government appealed pursuant to Directive ¶¶ E3.1.28 and E3.1.30. Background Applicant, in his mid-50s, earned a bachelor’s degree in 1998, a master’s degree in 2024, and multiple certifications in cybersecurity and information technology. He married in 1997, separated in about 2015, and divorced in 2019. He married his second wife in 2019. He has three adult children from his first marriage and two minor children from his second marriage. He served on active duty in the U.S. military from 1990 to 1994 and as a reservist and guardsman from 2004
to 2023. He has maintained a security clearance for about 21 years, and he seeks continued national security eligibility for his employment with a government contractor, for whom he has worked since August 2018. As amended, the SOR alleges security concerns arising from delinquent federal, state, and local taxes; a vehicle lease and two vehicle loans; student loans; and credit card accounts. In his response to the original SOR (Answer), he denied the delinquent taxes and vehicle lease. In his response to the Amendment to the SOR, he admitted the delinquent student loans, credit card accounts, and two vehicle loans. On appeal, the Government challenges the Judge’s factual findings on each of the 11 allegations, to include: Applicant’s federal tax debt, state and local tax debts, delinquent car loans, long-standing student loans, and credit card debts. The Government highlights, however, that “[t]he most critical factual errors relate to the Applicant’s tax debt.” Appeal Brief at 22. We agree, and we limit our discussion of the findings of fact to this central and dispositive issue – Applicant’s federal and state tax debts and the Judge’s misunderstanding of their status. Federal Taxes (SOR ¶ 1.a) Applicant did not report any delinquent federal tax filings or tax debts on his November 2018 security clearance application (SCA) or his January 2022 SCA. In his October 2023 response to interrogatories, Applicant submitted his tax account transcripts for tax years (TYs) 2014 through 2022. Those transcripts revealed the following status as of October 13, 2023: the return for TY 2014 had been timely filed; the returns for TYs 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2019 had all been filed late; and the returns for TYs 2018, 2020, 2021, and 2022 had not yet been filed. We turn now to the specific delinquencies alleged for TYs 2014, 2017, and 2022. TY 2014. The October 2023 tax account transcript showed a balance of $42,783. It indicated that an IRS installment agreement was established in July 2015 and that four completed payments and four returned payments occurred between December 2015 and July 2016. Government Exhibit (GE) 3 at 14-15. Refunds for TYs 2015 ($11,038) and 2016 ($2,013) were applied to the 2014 tax debt in about 2018. Id. at 16. A second installment agreement was established in May 2018, followed by five completed payments and four returned payments between June 2018 and April 2019. Id. In September 2020, a third installment agreement was established, followed by no completed payments and four returned payments. Id. There is no evidence of any completed payments since January 2019, but Applicant’s balance was reduced to $42,783 by the application of a refund from TY 2019. At the hearing, Applicant testified that he did not owe any federal taxes for TY 2014. Transcript (Tr.) at 63, 67. He stated that he had made multiple payments in about 2020 or 2021 under a payment plan that allowed him to pay less than the full amount owed, that he missed one payment, that the IRS “reversed the offer” and reinstated the full amount owed, but that he has “put it back into a paid off status” because of “remodifications” that he had undertaken. Id. at 62, 64. Applicant also acknowledged that he entered into multiple IRS payment plans and missed payments. Id. at 66. 2
TY 2017. On December 1, 2018, an installment agreement was established; however, no payments were completed in accordance with the agreement. GE 3 at 20. On September 25, 2020, a second installment agreement was established, but no payments were made. Id. at 21. No payments have been made on these delinquent taxes ($896 as of October 2023) since the return was filed. Id. at 20. TY 2022. According to his updated tax account transcript, retrieved in November 2025, Applicant filed his 2022 tax return on July 8, 2024, and established an installment agreement on July 22, 2024. Applicant Exhibit (AE) B at 1. As of November 28, 2025, he had completed no payments, and he owed approximately $15,047. Id. In his October 2023 response to interrogatories, Applicant provided an indecipherable response to a query about the status of his tax filings: I have primarily always filed on time for all tax years due to being overloaded. However, my previous divorce depts [sic] included payoffs that extended to family members such as using my fathers [sic] automobile during the years of divorce (2014-2019). Such hardships included my ex-wife’s [$]4000+ garnishments, no mortgage payments for that period requiring paying off the house resulting in a short-sale. Taxes were completed while debt was prioritized. GE 3 at 4. At the hearing, Applicant submitted an undated printout of his IRS account balance for tax years 2017 through 2025, reflecting that he owed $1,040 for TY 2017 and $15,013 for TY 2022. AE C. There is no balance information for TYs 2018, 2020, 2021, 2023, 2024, and 2025, which suggests that returns were still not filed for those years. The printout contains no information at all for TYs 2014, 2015, or 2016. On August 28, 2025, Applicant entered into an agreement to have his federal tax return prepared for TY 2024. AE A. He testified that his tax returns for TYs 2023 and 2024 had not been filed as of the hearing. Tr. at 69. Applicant testified that he participated in an IRS payment program in about 2021 to pay off his delinquent taxes; however, he was unable to provide any specific information about the name of the program, when he participated, or the number or amounts of his payments. Id. at 29 30, 62. He claimed that, at the time he responded to the interrogatories in October 2023, he was current on an IRS payment plan, despite no reference to ongoing IRS payments in his response. Id. at 31. Though he never received any IRS correspondence to that effect, his payments “led up to [him] recently finding out that [he doesn’t] owe that money anymore.” Id. at 30. He explained, without corroboration, that he “just made a payment” to the IRS; however, he did not provide the timing or amount of the payment. Id. at 35. His testimony about his tax filings, installment agreements, and payments was muddled, vague, and uncorroborated. He claimed to have filed amended tax returns, resulting in a reduced tax debt; however, he provided no corroborating evidence. Id. at 36. Despite initially testifying that he owed nothing to the IRS, he later asserted that he owed approximately $16,000. Id. at 36-37. 3
State Taxes (SOR ¶ 1.b) In his January 2022 SCA, Applicant reported that he had failed to pay his 2021 state taxes, which he estimated at $4,000. GE 2 at 60. In his October 2023 response to interrogatories, Applicant included prepared but unsigned state returns for TYs 2014 through 2022. For TYs 2014 and 2015, Applicant owed $4,245 and $2, respectively. GE 3 at 145, 150. For TYs 2016 through 2021, his calculated refunds were $0, $0, $715, $4,600, 839, and $2,256, respectively. Id. at 117, 125, 136, 141, 162, 169. For TY 2022, Applicant owed $2,542. Id. at 189. There is no documentary evidence establishing that these returns were filed and the state taxes paid. Applicant denied this debt in his Answer, but his explanation referenced a statute of limitations and the IRS, as opposed to the state tax authority. At the hearing, Applicant testified, without any corroborating evidence, that he did not owe any state taxes. Tr. at 38. There is no documentary evidence reflecting any debt resolution efforts as to Applicant’s delinquent state taxes. Local Taxes (SOR ¶ 1.c) In his October 2023 response to interrogatories, Applicant included his local tax return for TY 2022, reflecting $2,254 due and with instructions to sign and pay the calculated amount. GE 3 at 196, 197. In his Answer, Applicant denied the allegation but admitted establishing a payment plan, making payments, and owing a remaining balance of $2,600. Answer at 2. Pursuant to an excerpt of undated correspondence, likely from the local tax authority, Applicant owed various amounts for TYs 2015 through 2023 and established a repayment contract in December 2024 to pay $886 for seven months to satisfy the $5,937 balance. These payments were to be completed by June 30, 2025. AE G; Tr. at 38. At the hearing, without corroboration, Applicant claimed that SOR ¶¶ 1.b and 1.c were the same debt, rather than distinct debts for state and local taxes. Tr. at 39. Judge’s Findings and Analysis The Judge found Applicant initially owed delinquent federal taxes for TYs 2014, 2017, and 2022 in the total amount of $43,728, as alleged in the SOR. He thereafter relied on the updated TY 2022 transcript, from which he misconstrued certain information as discussed further below, to find that Applicant reduced that total balance to $12,853. The Judge attributed Applicant’s 2014 tax debt to his divorce and the loss of certain tax deductions. The Judge also determined that the tax debts alleged in SOR ¶¶ 1.b and 1.c were duplicative and that Applicant satisfied the state tax debt in June 2025 after six or seven monthly payments initiated in December 2024. Id. The Judge did not address Applicant’s untimely tax filings or unfiled returns. On the non-tax allegations, the Judge found Applicant settled a $24,058 delinquent car lease for $6,500 in 2025 and retained a law firm to assist him in in petitioning the Department of Veterans Affairs to have his student loans discharged upon the pending determination of a 100% disability rating. Without any corroborating evidence, the Judge relied on Applicant’s testimony that he had brought his two delinquent credit cards and two vehicle loans current. An updated Personal Financial Statement reflected a net monthly remainder of $5,917. Applicant recently engaged a law firm, tax preparer, financial planner, and a financial manager to assist him in resolving his financial delinquencies and in managing his financial obligations. 4
Other than the allegation regarding Applicant’s federal tax debt, the Judge resolved all allegations (SOR ¶¶ 1.b through 1.k) in Applicant’s favor within the Guideline F mitigation analysis. Decision at 6. The Judge did not explicitly identify which mitigating conditions applied to these debts; however, his analysis centered on the settlement and payments on these accounts. Id. As to the federal tax debt, the Judge concluded that AG ¶¶ 20(c), 20(d), and 20(g)1 applied due to Applicant’s significant net monthly remainder, the satisfaction of 80% of his tax debt, and his engagement of financial and tax assistance; however, he determined that AG ¶ 20(b)2 did not apply because Applicant had not acted responsibly to timely address his delinquent taxes and instead had purchased two luxury vehicles. Within the Whole-Person analysis, the Judge concluded: Conversely, there is significant evidence of rehabilitation as Applicant is working with a tax planner, a financial planner, and a debt payment company to assist him in keeping his finances organized and keeping his payments on track. Given the amount of delinquent debt that he has resolved, the assistance of these experts is clearly working. Given Applicant’s monthly net income, he has ample money to keep up with incoming bills and satisfy his tax delinquency. Under these circumstances, I conclude that the nature and seriousness of the security concern is outweighed by the presence of reform and rehabilitation, thus rendering the possibility of recurrence minimal. In sum, I conclude Applicant has mitigated the security concerns. Decision at 7. Scope of Review On appeal, the Board does not review a case de novo, but rather addresses material issues raised by the parties to determine whether there is factual or legal error. When a judge’s factual findings are challenged, the Board must determine whether the “findings of fact are supported by such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion in light of all the contrary evidence in the same record.” Directive ¶ E3.1.32.1. When a judge’s ruling or conclusions are challenged, we must determine whether they are arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law. Directive ¶ E3.1.32.3. A judge’s decision can be arbitrary or capricious if: it does not examine relevant evidence; it fails to articulate a satisfactory 1 Although the Judge references AG ¶ 20(e) within his analysis, he quotes AG ¶ 20(g), and the context of his analysis indicates his reference to AG ¶ 20(e) was a typographical error. AG ¶¶ 20(c): the individual has received or is receiving financial counseling for the problems from a legitimate and credible source, such as a non-profit counseling service, and there are clear indications that the problem is being resolved or is under control; 20(d): the individual initiated and is adhering to a good-faith effort to repay overdue creditors or otherwise resolve debts; 20(g): the individual has made arrangements with the appropriate tax authority to file or pay the amount owed and is in compliance with those arrangements. 2 AG ¶ 20(b): the conditions that resulted in the financial problem were largely beyond the person’s control (e.g., loss of employment, a business downturn, unexpected medical emergency, a death, divorce or separation, clear victimization by predatory lending practices, or identity theft), and the individual acted responsibly under the circumstances. 5
explanation for its conclusions, including a rational connection between the facts found and the choice made; it does not consider relevant factors; it reflects a clear error of judgment; it fails to consider an important aspect of the case; it offers an explanation for the decision that runs contrary to the record evidence; or it is so implausible that it cannot be ascribed to a mere difference of opinion. See ISCR Case No. 95-0600, 1996 WL 480993 at *3 (App. Bd. May 16, 1996) (citing Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29, 43 (1983)). In deciding whether a judge’s rulings or conclusions are contrary to law, the Board will consider whether they are contrary to provisions of Executive Order 10865, the Directive, or other applicable federal law. See ISCR Case No. 03-22861 at 2 (App. Bd. Jun. 2, 2006). When an appeal issue raises a question of law, the Board’s scope of review is plenary. See DISCR OSD Case No. 87-2107, 1992 WL 388439 at *3-4 (App. Bd. Sep. 29, 1992) (citations to federal cases omitted). If an appealing party demonstrates factual or legal error, then the Board must consider the following questions: (1) Is the error harmful or harmless?; (2) Has the nonappealing party made a persuasive argument for how the judge’s decision can be affirmed on alternate grounds?; and (3) If the judge’s decision cannot be affirmed, should the case be reversed or remanded? See ISCR Case No. 02-08032 at 2 (App. Bd. May 14, 2004). Discussion On appeal, the Government argues that the Judge’s application of the mitigating conditions and analysis under the Whole-Person Concept were arbitrary, capricious, and not supported by the record evidence. We agree and reverse the Judge’s favorable decision. Critical Factual Errors Underlying all claims raised on appeal is the argument that the Judge made critical errors within the findings of fact and failed to consider significant unfavorable and conflicting record evidence. The Government’s arguments have merit. As discussed below, the harmful errors established within the Judge’s findings and analysis of Applicant’s tax debts obviate the need to discuss the findings and analysis of the remaining debts. Turning first to the critical factual errors concerning the federal tax debt, the Judge relied on Applicant’s updated TY 2022 tax account transcript, retrieved in November 2025, to make certain findings about his total federal tax balance and conclude that it was reduced from $43,728 to $12,853 for the alleged tax years and that Applicant demonstrated good-faith efforts to resolve his tax debts. These findings were materially incorrect. Most importantly, the Judge found that “a tax refund of approximately $28,600 was credited” to the total balance;3 however, the account transcript reflects that Applicant’s original 2022 tax liability of $43,467 was reduced by $28,674 in tax withholding. The Judge also found that Applicant made a payment of approximately $5,700 on the total balance in April 2025; however, the transcript reflects that was an unidentified $5,784 credit applied to the 2022 liability in April 2023, when the tax return was originally due. Finally, the Judge found that Applicant reduced his total tax liability across all three alleged tax years to $12,853; however, $12,853 was 3 Decision at 3 (emphasis added). 6
Applicant’s outstanding balance for tax year 2022 alone, before calculation of interest and penalties, which brought the total to $15,047 as of November 2025. The record reflects that Applicant’s total federal tax balance for TYs 2014, 2017, and 2022 is approximately $59,000. There is no documentary evidence of any completed tax payments on these delinquent federal taxes since January 2019. The Judge also erroneously found that the tax debts in SOR ¶¶ 1.b and 1.c were duplicative. Applicant’s denial of the state tax debt, in his Answer, inexplicably relied on an unidentified statute of limitations and actions of the IRS, the federal tax authority. At hearing, Applicant testified, without corroboration or explanation, that the two debts were duplicative. While the Judge’s finding that Applicant resolved his local tax debt (SOR ¶ 1.c) was arguably supported by the documentary evidence, there is no record evidence that Applicant resolved his self-reported $4,000 state tax debt (SOR ¶ 1.b). The Judge’s finding that SOR ¶ 1.b was resolved through payments is unsupported by the record evidence. Misapplication of AG ¶¶ 20(c), 20(d), and 20(g) The Judge concluded that AG ¶¶ 20(c), 20(d), and 20(g) applied to Applicant’s delinquent federal taxes, relying on purported tax payments, a sizable net remainder in his monthly budget, and his engagement of financial and tax professionals. As to AG ¶¶ 20(c) and 20(d), as discussed above, the Judge’s findings of fact as to the tax refund and payment were unsupported by the record evidence, which, in fact, established that Applicant has not made any successful payments on his delinquent federal taxes since January 2019. Furthermore, although Applicant recently has engaged these professionals, there is no evidence of tax payments or clear indications that Applicant’s lengthy history of financial mismanagement and tax problems is being resolved. Additionally, Applicant’s unfiled returns, discussed further below, like unresolved delinquent debts, are an ongoing security concern and undermine the Judge’s application of AG ¶ 20(c). See ISCR Case No. 19-01643, 2021 WL 2186799 at *2 (App. Bd. Mar. 17, 2021). See also ISCR Case No. 01-03695, 2002 WL 32114512 at *3 (App. Bd. Oct. 16, 2002) (evidence that Applicant was financially in a position to resolve his federal tax debt did not constitute clear indications his taxes are being resolved). Given the plain language of AG ¶ 20(g), Applicant’s engagement of tax professionals alone – absent any evidence of a payment agreement, payments, or compliance – cannot establish this mitigating condition. See ISCR Case No. 22-01236, 2023 WL 11945258 at *2 (App. Bd. Sep. 13, 2023). The Judge’s application of AG ¶¶ 20(c), 20(d), and 20(g) as to SOR ¶ 1.a was unsupported by the record evidence and contrary to the plain language of the Directive. Reliance upon Applicant’s Testimony The Judge noted Applicant’s training and role as a chaplain and his favorable character references. Although the Judge made no explicit credibility determination, his acceptance of Applicant’s uncorroborated testimony reflects a favorable assessment. The Judge’s favorable impression of Applicant’s character, however, did not insulate him from assessing Applicant’s reliability in light of the record evidence as a whole: 7
The sincerity and veracity of a witness’s testimony are separate and distinct from what weight reasonably can be given to that testimony, and what inferences and conclusions reasonably can be reached based on considering that testimony in light of the evidence as a whole. Accordingly, although the Judge found Applicant’s testimony to be credible, such a credibility determination did not relieve the Judge of the obligation to consider the substance of Applicant’s testimony in light of the record evidence as a whole and weigh it in a reasonable manner . . . . ISCR Case No. 02-14995, 2004 WL 2152787 at *4 (App. Bd. Jul. 26, 2004) (citation omitted). The Judge accepted Applicant’s testimony whole cloth, despite Applicant’s vague, confusing, and muddled explanations about his federal, state, and local taxes. By Applicant’s own admission, he repeatedly mismanaged his monthly financial obligations and missed payments. In his response to interrogatories, Applicant asserted, “I have primarily always filed on time for all tax years due to being overloaded. . . . Taxes were completed while debt was prioritized.” GE 3 at 5. In the very same document, Applicant included IRS tax transcripts establishing unfiled and untimely filed returns for several tax years; however, the Judge did not address the conflict between Applicant’s assertions and the documentary evidence. Similarly, the Judge accepted Applicant’s testimony – that he made several large payments to the IRS in 2020 and 2021 and that he owed nothing to the IRS – despite Applicant’s own submissions reflecting no completed payments after January 2019 and an outstanding balance, as of November 2025, of approximately $16,000 for TYs 2017 and 2022 alone. “A Judge is required to weigh conflicting evidence and to resolve such conflicts based upon a careful evaluation of factors such as the comparative reliability, plausibility and ultimate truthfulness of conflicting pieces of evidence.” ISCR Case No. 05-06723, 2007 WL 4379274 at *2 (App. Bd. Nov. 14, 2007). The Judge’s favorable credibility assessment need not be disturbed to conclude that the Judge’s reliance upon Applicant’s testimony in light of significant record evidence to the contrary was arbitrary and capricious. Failure to Consider an Important Aspect The Judge did not address the record evidence of Applicant’s untimely filings for TYs 2015, 2016, 2017, 2019, and 2022 or his failure to file his federal returns at all for TYs 2018, 2020, 2021, 2023, and 2024,4 nor did he reconcile this evidence with his application of AG ¶¶ 20(c), 20(d), or 20(g). Had the SOR or amended SOR explicitly alleged concerns arising from Applicant’s untimely or unfiled federal income tax returns, the Judge would have been compelled to address these issues within his disqualification and mitigation analyses. Nevertheless, given the intrinsically interconnected nature of an applicant’s tax filings and tax payments, the Judge’s failure to consider this important aspect of the case was arbitrary and capricious. Similarly, the Judge’s failure to address Applicant’s repeated unfulfilled installment agreements and the absence of any completed tax payments since January 2019 reflect deficient analysis. The Judge’s failure to address Applicant’s untimely and unfiled tax returns similarly undermines his Whole-Person analysis. The Judge determined that there was “significant evidence of rehabilitation” based upon Applicant’s tax payments – demonstrated as error – and his engagement of a financial planner, financial manager, and tax preparer. While these mechanisms 4 By his own admission, Applicant had not filed returns for tax years 2023 or 2024 as of the December 2025 hearing. 8
may, in the future, facilitate rehabilitation, the absence of record evidence of voluntary compliance with tax-filing and tax-paying obligations upends the Judge’s conclusion as to reform and rehabilitation. Here, the documentary evidence established Applicant timely filed his federal returns for TY 2014 and thereafter failed to timely file or file at all his returns through tax year 2024. Applicant’s uncorroborated and bewildering statements about his tax filings are unreliable and conflict with the IRS transcripts. The record is devoid of a track record of voluntary compliance by Applicant with his tax-filing requirements. Applicant’s favorable evidence as to his character, work performance, and promises to rectify his tax and financial issues do not overcome Applicant’s nearly decade-long non-compliance with his tax obligations. The Judge’s findings of fact and conclusions do not reflect a reasonable, plausible interpretation of the record as a whole, having failed to consider important aspects of the case and to address and reconcile evidence that runs contrary to his findings and conclusions. See ISCR Case No. 02-02892, 2004 WL 2152776 at *3 (App. Bd. Jun. 28, 2004). Conclusion When the Board finds that a judge’s decision is unsustainable, we must determine if the appropriate remedy is remand or reversal. When, even after addressing the identified errors, the Board concludes that a contrary formal finding or overall grant or denial of security clearance eligibility is the clear outcome based on the record, the decision must be reversed. See ISCR Case No. 22-01002, 2024 WL 4445514 at *3 (App. Bd. Sep. 26, 2023). Such is the case here. The Government has met its burden on appeal of demonstrating reversible error below. Considering the record, the Judge’s decision is arbitrary and capricious for all the factors as identified in ISCR Case No. 95-0600. Accordingly, the favorable decision is not sustainable under Egan and is reversed. 9
Order The decision in ISCR Case No. 24-01243 is REVERSED. Signed: Moira Modzelewski Moira Modzelewski Administrative Judge Chair, Appeal Board Signed: Allison Marie Allison Marie Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board Signed: Eric H. Borgstrom Eric H. Borgstrom Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board 10