A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.
ISCR Case No. 25-00859
Not statedDecided Oct 7, 2026 · Administrative Judge Moira D. Modzelewski · Hearing
Case headnote
Summary
The applicant, a mid-30s single male and former U.S. Navy member, faced security clearance denial due to three delinquent debts totaling approximately $44,900 under Guideline F (Financial Considerations). The appeal board found that the administrative judge failed to accurately assess the applicant's debt resolution efforts and overall financial history, leading to a reversal of the denial.
Why the applicant was denied
- The judge found that the applicant had three delinquent debts totaling approximately $45,000.
- The judge concluded that the applicant did not mitigate the established security concerns under Guideline F or the Whole-Person Concept.
Conditions referenced
Disqualifying
- F1 Financial Considerationsraised
- F2 Financial Considerationsraised
- F3 Financial Considerationsraised
Mitigating
- F2 Financial Considerationsapplied
- F3 Financial Considerationsapplied
Key rule quoted
“A judge’s decision can be arbitrary or capricious if: it does not examine relevant evidence; it fails to articulate a satisfactory explanation for its conclusions, including a rational connection between the facts found and the choice made; it does not consider relevant factors; it reflects a clear error of judgment; it fails to consider an important aspect of the case; it offers an explanation for the decision that runs contrary to the record evidence; or it is so implausible that it cannot be ascribed to a mere difference of opinion.”
Procedural posture
- SOR issued
- August 14, 2025
- Answer filed
- Hearing held
- July 28, 2026
- Decision date
- October 7, 2026
Cite for
- Evaluation of Debt Resolution Efforts Under Guideline F
- Consideration of Overall Financial History in Security Clearance Cases
- Impact of Timing on Debt Resolution Efforts in Mitigation Analysis
Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.
From the decision
Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.
- Delinquent Usd
- 44900
- Payment Plan
- yes
- Bankruptcy
- none
Allegations under Guideline F
Reading the 3 per allegation rows needs a free account.
3 rows in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.
Full decision
Open original PDFThe complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.
Decision text, by section
Appeal Board Decision
APPEARANCES FOR GOVERNMENT Andrea M. Corrales, Esq., Deputy Chief Department Counsel FOR APPLICANT Nelson Robles, Esq. The Department of Defense (DoD) declined to grant Applicant a security clearance. On August 14, 2025, DoD issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR) advising Applicant of the basis of that decision – security concerns raised under Guideline F (Financial Considerations) of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (AG) in Appendix A of Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (effective June 8, 2017) and DoD Directive 5220.6 (Jan. 2, 1992, as amended) (Directive). On July 28, 2026, Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals Administrative Judge Eric H. Borgstrom denied Applicant national security eligibility. Applicant appealed pursuant to Directive ¶¶ E3.1.28 and E3.1.30. The SOR alleged three delinquent consumer debts that totaled about $44,900, and the Judge found adversely to Applicant on all three. On appeal, Applicant argues that the Judge’s mitigation and Whole-Person Concept analyses failed to consider the alleged debts in the context of his overall financial and payment history and that his reliance on the timing of Applicant’s debt- resolution efforts runs contrary to record evidence. Finding merit, we reverse.
Judge’s Findings of Fact Applicant is in his mid-30s and single, with no children. After graduation from high school in 2009, Applicant served in the U.S. Navy from 2010 through 2021. Since his honorable discharge from active duty, Applicant has been employed as a test engineer for a federal contractor. He has been enrolled in community college since 2023. In his June 2022 security clearance application (SCA), Applicant reported two delinquent debts—the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.a and a credit card debt that is not alleged. In explanation on the SCA, Applicant cited “Stupid Financial Decisions,” explaining that he was at one point making more than he could spend, but then transferred to a location with low wages and accrued some debt. He stated that he was “slowly paying it off when I can.” Government Exhibit (GE) 1 at 32– 33. The Judge summarized the status of the three alleged debts as follows: SOR ¶ 1.a: A personal loan for $30,000, this debt was incurred in September 2015 and charged off in about December 2019 in the approximate amount of $11,010. In his 2022 SCA, Applicant reported this account and estimated its delinquency as December 2017. At hearing, Applicant testified that he was unaware of the delinquency until about September 2023, when he checked his credit report. The Judge found that, as of the hearing, Applicant “had not made any payments on this account or had any communications with the creditor,” that he contacted the creditor post-hearing and “received a settlement offer of $6,050,” but that there was no evidence of any payments towards the settlement at the close of the record. Decision at 2–3. SOR ¶ 1.b: This vehicle loan was opened in January 2018 and charged off in about August 2020 in the approximate amount of $7,704. Because of mechanical problems, Applicant voluntarily surrendered the vehicle for repossession. Although he expected to pay the creditor the deficiency balance following the auction of the vehicle, Applicant had “not had any further communication with the creditor since he surrendered the collateral” and “had taken no steps to address or resolve the delinquent debt.” Id. at 3. The Judge noted that post-hearing Applicant paid $2,732 on the account but found that “there is no further information as to whether this was a lump- sum settlement or one of multiple agreed-upon payments.” Id. SOR ¶ 1.c: Applicant testified that this credit card account has been delinquent since about 2017, with an approximate balance of $26,240. The creditor agreed to settle the debt for approximately $14,400, and Applicant provided proof that he began making regular $100 bi weekly payments on this account in November 2025 totaling $1,403 at the time of the hearing. Applicant testified that he earned approximately $98,000 in salary in 2025, with an anticipated salary for 2026 of approximately $101,600. In addition to his salary, he receives monthly disability compensation from the Department of Veterans Affairs, which increased shortly before his May 2026 hearing from $750 to approximately $2,200. The Judge found that Applicant prepared a debt repayment plan in April 2026, that he established a bi-weekly budgeting system with autopay for most recurring expenses, and that he expressed his intent to pay SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.c within the next two years. The Judge noted that Applicant attributed his financial delinquencies to some financial mismanagement, cost-of-living 2
adjustments after he relocated with the Navy, and a toxic relationship with a former girlfriend that resulted in Applicant forcing her removal from his house via foreclosure. The Judge also noted that Applicant “identified two past-due credit card accounts, totaling approximately $7,500, which he paid in August 2023 and December 2024.” Id. at 4. Judge’s Analysis The Judge found that “[t]he record evidence established Applicant’s three delinquent accounts, totaling approximately $45,000.” Id. at 5. In concluding that Applicant did not mitigate the established security concerns either under Guideline F or the Whole-Person Concept, the Judge cited the timing of Applicant’s remedial efforts and made the following findings and conclusions pertinent to the appeal: For the repossessed vehicle (SOR ¶ 1.b.), he surrendered the vehicle in about 2020 or 2022 and took no further steps to address the deficiency balance on the account. He reported two delinquent accounts on his e-QIP, including SOR ¶ 1.a., but took no further action to address these debts or to participate in credit counseling to understand how to address and resolve these debts. After the issuance of the SOR, Applicant initiated a payment plan with one creditor (SOR ¶ 1.c.), and, after the hearing, he contacted the other two creditors to negotiate repayment plans. These efforts are favorable evidence in mitigation; however, the timing of these efforts must be considered. The timing of Applicant’s debt-resolution efforts is relevant and material to the evaluation of his evidence in mitigation. (internal citation omitted.) . . . I found Applicant’s testimony to be credible and his acknowledgement of his past financial mismanagement to be sincere. In April 2026, he developed a structured and reasonable debt-resolution plan, and he has taken some steps in furtherance of this plan. Unfortunately, the timing of his debt-resolution efforts – all after the issuance of the SOR – undercuts his evidence in mitigation. Id. at 6-7 (emphasis added). Discussion On appeal, Applicant highlights that the Judge failed to credit him for payments on the alleged debts, that he more broadly failed to consider the alleged debts in the context of his overall financial history and his payments on non-alleged debts, and that his reliance on the timing of Applicant’s efforts is not supported by the record. These arguments have merit. When an Administrative Judge’s factual findings are challenged, the Board must determine whether “[t]he Administrative Judge’s findings of fact are supported by such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion in light of all the contrary evidence in the same record.” Directive, E3.1.32.1. The Board must consider not only whether there is record evidence supporting a judge’s findings, but also whether there is evidence that fairly 3
detracts from the weight of the evidence supporting those findings, and whether the judge’s findings reflect a reasonable interpretation of the record evidence as a whole. ISCR Case No. 02 12199 at 2–3 (App. Bd. Aug. 8, 2005). A judge’s decision can be arbitrary or capricious if: it does not examine relevant evidence; it fails to articulate a satisfactory explanation for its conclusions, including a rational connection between the facts found and the choice made; it does not consider relevant factors; it reflects a clear error of judgment; it fails to consider an important aspect of the case; it offers an explanation for the decision that runs contrary to the record evidence; or it is so implausible that it cannot be ascribed to a mere difference of opinion. See ISCR Case No. 95-0600, 1996 WL 480993 at *3 (App. Bd. May. 16, 1996) (citing Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n v. State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29, 43 (1983)). Our review confirms that the Judge made erroneous findings and conclusions and failed to consider relevant evidence about alleged and non-alleged debts, as detailed below. Factual Errors on Alleged Debts Aggregate Debt: As a preliminary matter, the Judge’s conclusion that “[t]he record evidence established Applicant’s three delinquent accounts, totaling approximately $45,000” is erroneous. Decision at 5. When the SOR was issued, the debts alleged in SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.b had already been significantly reduced, as discussed further below. All record evidence confirmed that the aggregate delinquent debt was $35,010 at the time the SOR was issued, rather than the greater amount alleged in the SOR and adopted by the Judge. SOR ¶ 1.a: The Judge made three errors regarding this debt. 1) He erroneously concluded that this debt was delinquent in the alleged amount of $11,010. Applicant took out a personal loan for $30,000 in September 2015. In December 2019, the account became delinquent and was charged off at $11,010. Applicant made payments on the charged-off account until October 2021, reducing the balance to $6,050, as reported in Applicant’s SCA and confirmed by all record evidence. 2) The Judge failed to acknowledge or credit these pre-SOR payments, which contradict his over-arching conclusion that all remedial efforts were post-SOR. 3) By email post-hearing, Applicant verified with the creditor that $6,050 remained the pay off amount, which the Judge mischaracterized as a settlement offer, failing to acknowledge that the actual debt was $6,050 and not $11,010. SOR ¶ 1.b: The Judge made three errors regarding this delinquent vehicle loan. 1) He erroneously concluded that this debt was delinquent in the alleged amount of $7,704. Although charged off in August 2020 at $7,704, the deficiency balance after auction was $4,969 as of September 2022. Applicant made regular payments from September 2022 through July 2024 and further reduced the balance to $2,731, as reflected on the Government’s pre-SOR July 2025 credit report and Applicant’s March 2025 credit report. 2) The Judge failed to acknowledge or credit the two years of pre-SOR payments, which contradict his over-arching conclusion that all remedial efforts were post-SOR, instead 4
erroneously finding that “[Applicant] surrendered the vehicle in about 2020 or 2022 and took no further steps to address the deficiency balance on the account.” Id. at 6 (emphasis added). 3) After the hearing, Applicant paid the full balance of $2,731 and provided proof to the Judge. The Judge acknowledged the payment but then stated, “there is no further information as to whether this was a lump-sum settlement or one of multiple agreed-upon payments,”1 when in fact the payment satisfied the remaining debt of $2,731. Failure to Consider Relevant Evidence In addition to the factual errors on the alleged debts highlighted above, we conclude that the Judge failed to consider relevant evidence of record. The Judge found that the three alleged debts became delinquent between December 2017 and August 2020 and focused on Applicant’s failure to resolve them prior to receiving the SOR in August 2025. In doing so, the Judge overlooked a critical fact—Applicant had six consumer accounts that became delinquent during this timeframe, not just the three alleged, and he resolved three of them prior to receiving the SOR in August 2025.2 In conducting his mitigation analysis, the Judge omitted any reference to Applicant’s remedial efforts on the three non-alleged delinquent debts and instead made an erroneous adverse conclusion on one of them. We turn to the non-alleged debts and that error now. Applicant introduced evidence that, prior to the SOR, he successfully resolved three delinquent debts: 1) A charged-off credit card account in the amount of $1,441, for which Applicant started payments in November 2022 and paid the balance in August 2023, two years prior to the SOR;3 2) A delinquent credit card account closed by the creditor in the amount of $3,338, for which Applicant began payments in September 2022 and paid the balance in November 2024, ten months prior to the SOR; and 3) A charged off credit card account in the amount of $3,304, which Applicant paid off in two payments by December 2024, nine months prior to the SOR. Notably, in his mitigation analysis, the Judge found that “[Applicant] reported two delinquent accounts on his [SCA], including SOR ¶ 1.a., but took no further action to address these debts.” Id. at 6 (emphasis added). That is incorrect. On his June 2022 SCA, Applicant disclosed the delinquent credit card account identified at 1) above. Contrary to the Judge’s finding, Applicant began consistent payments on the reported debt in November 2022 and paid off the balance in August 2023, two years prior to the SOR. 1 Id. at 3. 2 In his Findings of Fact, the Judge briefly noted that Applicant “identified two past-due credit card accounts . . . which he paid in August 2023 and December 2024,” but made no further reference. Id. at 4. 3 The two credit reports in evidence are unclear as to whether Applicant paid the full balance on this debt or a settlement balance. 5
In evaluating Guideline F cases, the Board has consistently noted that the concept of “‘meaningful track record’ necessarily includes evidence of actual debt reduction through payment of debts. See, e.g., ISCR Case No. 05-01920 at 5 (App. Bd. Mar. 1, 2007). However, an applicant is not required to establish that he has paid off each debt listed in the SOR. The Board has previously noted that an applicant is not required to be debt-free nor to develop a plan for paying off all debts immediately or simultaneously. All that is required is that an applicant act responsibly given his circumstances and develop a reasonable plan for repayment, accompanied by “concomitant conduct,” that is, actions which evidence a serious intent to effectuate the plan. Additionally, there is no requirement that the first debts paid be the ones listed in the SOR. ISCR Case No. 07-06482 at 3 (App. Bd. May 21, 2008). Said differently, a judge should evaluate alleged debts in the context of an applicant’s overall efforts on resolving his financial delinquencies, rather than narrowly focusing on the alleged debts and ignoring other remedial efforts. Here, the Judge failed to do so by focusing solely on the three alleged debts and omitting any consideration of the three satisfied debts. In failing to consider Applicant’s successful payment efforts on non-alleged debts, the Judge failed to consider relevant evidence and an important aspect of the case. Timing of Debt Resolution Efforts Applicant argues that the Judge’s adverse decision relied unduly on the timing of Applicant’s efforts and that this reliance is particularly problematic because he was simply wrong about the timing in several regards. We agree. As is clear from the Judge’s findings and analysis summarized above, the Judge found adversely to Applicant because he was convinced that Applicant failed to take any steps to address his financial delinquencies prior to issuance of the SOR. In his Whole-Person Concept analysis, the Judge first acknowledged some mitigating evidence but concluded: “Unfortunately, the timing of his debt-resolution efforts – all after the issuance of the SOR – undercuts his evidence in mitigation.” Id. at 7. We note first that the timing of debt-resolution efforts is one of the many factors to be weighed in light of the totality of the evidence. But in this case, the Judge’s critical conclusion – that all debt-resolution efforts came after issuance of the SOR – is also demonstrably wrong, as detailed above. Specifically, the statement is erroneous as it pertains to two of the three alleged debts (SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.b), as Applicant made significant pre-SOR payments on those debts, and it entirely ignores Applicant’s successful resolution of three non-alleged debts prior to receiving the SOR. The Judge’s errors regarding the timing of Applicant’s efforts are inarguably harmful, as he relied so heavily upon them in his mitigation and Whole-Person Concept analyses. Conclusion Based on our review of the record, we conclude that the Judge’s decision contains cumulative errors that result in arbitrary and capricious findings, as they fail to consider important aspects of the case and run contrary to the weight of the record evidence. Based on the record as a whole, the alleged financial concerns are mitigated by Applicant’s debt resolution efforts. At the close of the record, Applicant’s debt situation could be summarized as follows: Having amassed six delinquent debts beginning in about 2017, Applicant had completely resolved four – three prior to issuance of the SOR and one post-hearing. Of his two remaining debts, he was in compliance with a payment plan on SOR ¶ 1.c that began in November 2025 and was in contact with the creditor for the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.a, which had a balance of $6,050. The Judge’s adverse decision is not sustainable. See ISCR Case No. 22-01002 at 4 (App. Bd. Sep. 26, 2024) (Reversal 6
is appropriate when the Board concludes from the record that a contrary formal finding or overall grant or denial of security clearance eligibility is the clear outcome.). Order The decision in ISCR Case No. 25-00859 is REVERSED. Signed: Moira Modzelewski Moira Modzelewski Administrative Judge Chair, Appeal Board Signed: Jennifer Goldstein Jennifer Goldstein Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board Separate Opinion of Board Member Allison Marie I respectfully dissent. I agree with my colleagues that the Judge made certain errors in factual findings about Applicant’s debt resolution efforts, which may have affected the disqualification and mitigation analyses. I disagree, however, that upon correction of the identified errors, an “overall grant . . . of security clearance eligibility is the clear outcome based on the record.” ISCR Case No. 22-01002, 2024 WL 4445514 at *3 (App. Bd. Sep. 26, 2024). For the following reasons, I would instead remand the matter to the Judge to correct the errors and issue a new decision. Applicant submitted his SCA in June 2022, at which time the three SOR allegations and two of the three unalleged debts identified by the Majority were delinquent. The record reflects that the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.a was charged off for $11,010 in December 2019, that a payment was last made on the account in October 2021, and that the delinquent balance was $6,050 as of June 2022.4 While Applicant initially testified that he made no payments on the debt and had not contacted the creditor since it became delinquent, he later affirmed his SCA explanation that he made “payments off and on,” agreeing that he may have “tried to make payments at some point.” Tr. at 42, 51-53. The Majority conclude that Applicant should be credited with the full pre-October 2021 reduction, but it is not entirely clear how and when the balance decreased from $11,010 to $6,050. Even if the evidence sufficiently established that Applicant should be credited with that 4 Applicant disclosed the $6,050 delinquent balance on his June 2022 SCA. See GE 1 at 32; Tr. at 52-53. 7
reduction – a matter properly left to the Judge – the record also reflects that Applicant took no steps to resolve the remaining $6,050 balance after October 2021. The record next reflects that the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.b was originally charged off for $7,704 in August 2020 and later decreased to the $4,969 deficiency balance that remained after auction in September 2022. At that same time, monthly payments of about $99 began crediting to the account and continued for about two years, through July 2024, further reducing the balance to $2,731. The Majority conclude that Applicant made those payments appearing on his credit report; however, Applicant testified – and adamantly so – that he had no contact with the creditor after about 2020 when he told them that he wanted to surrender the vehicle, including when he noticed it was finally repossessed several years later or when he received the SOR alleging the delinquency. Id. at 54-59. Here again, even if the evidence sufficiently established that Applicant should be credited with the post-auction reduction, the record also reflects that no further payments were made between July 2024 and Applicant’s lump sum payment resolving the debt on May 20, 2026 – two weeks after the hearing. While the Judge failed to recognize that final payment as fully resolving the account, it is well settled that repayment of a debt does not curtail further analysis of its security significance.5 The weight to be afforded Applicant’s post-hearing payment in light of the entire record is a matter properly left to the Judge on remand. The record also reflects that the $26,240 debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.c became delinquent in about 2017 and that Applicant’s effort to resolve the account began in November 2025, two months after receiving the SOR, when he agreed to settle the debt for $14,432 via $100 bi-weekly payments. As of the close of the record, he had consistently made the first 14 payments. The Judge acknowledged these recent efforts but found that their timing detracted from mitigation. Indeed, the Board has frequently highlighted the importance of considering the timing6 and consistency7 of an applicant’s debt repayment in evaluating mitigation. Applicant’s repayment efforts are favorable evidence and warrant consideration. The weight afforded those efforts in light of his pattern of delaying and suspending repayment – which bears on both his financial responsibility generally and his willingness and ability to maintain the bi-weekly payments required through May 2031 to fully resolve his most significant delinquency – is for the Judge to determine. Finally, I agree that Applicant’s pre-SOR resolution of about $6,000 in unalleged debt warrants consideration in the Guideline F mitigation analysis, but so does the timing of those efforts. The unalleged delinquencies were resolved in August 2023, November 2024, and December 2024, after which the record reflects no apparent active debt resolution until November 2025. The Judge should be permitted to weigh that period of inactivity together with the favorable repayment efforts that preceded and followed it. Reversal here effectively determines that, once the identified factual errors are corrected, the record could not reasonably support denial of Applicant’s national security eligibility. I 5 See ISCR Case No. 03-04704, 2005 WL 4048824 at *3 (App. Bd. Sep. 21, 2005) (“Many facts and circumstances surrounding the debt, including the manner in which it was incurred, the circumstances under which it became delinquent, and the manner in which Applicant addressed the delinquency are relevant factors for the Judge's consideration, notwithstanding the fact that the debt delinquency was eventually resolved.”). 6 See ISCR Case No. 15-06440, 2017 WL 6988287 at *3 (App. Bd. Dec. 26, 2017). 7 See ISCR Case No. 01-21386, 2003 WL 21979739 at *2 (App. Bd. Jun. 11, 2003). 8
disagree. The corrected facts may strengthen Applicant’s case for mitigation, but they do not compel it. Whether those facts, weighed against the timing and consistency of Applicant’s debt- resolution efforts, establish mitigation is a determination that the Judge should make in the first instance. The case should be remanded to permit that determination. Signed: Allison Marie Allison Marie Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board 9
Appearances
FOR GOVERNMENT Andrea M. Corrales, Esq., Deputy Chief Department Counsel
Appearances
Nelson Robles, Esq. The Department of Defense (DoD) declined to grant Applicant a security clearance. On August 14, 2025, DoD issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR) advising Applicant of the basis of that decision – security concerns raised under Guideline F (Financial Considerations) of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (AG) in Appendix A of Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (effective June 8, 2017) and DoD Directive 5220.6 (Jan. 2, 1992, as amended) (Directive). On July 28, 2026, Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals Administrative Judge Eric H. Borgstrom denied Applicant national security eligibility. Applicant appealed pursuant to Directive ¶¶ E3.1.28 and E3.1.30. The SOR alleged three delinquent consumer debts that totaled about $44,900, and the Judge found adversely to Applicant on all three. On appeal, Applicant argues that the Judge’s mitigation and Whole-Person Concept analyses failed to consider the alleged debts in the context of his overall financial and payment history and that his reliance on the timing of Applicant’s debt- resolution efforts runs contrary to record evidence. Finding merit, we reverse.
Judge’s Findings of Fact Applicant is in his mid-30s and single, with no children. After graduation from high school in 2009, Applicant served in the U.S. Navy from 2010 through 2021. Since his honorable discharge from active duty, Applicant has been employed as a test engineer for a federal contractor. He has been enrolled in community college since 2023. In his June 2022 security clearance application (SCA), Applicant reported two delinquent debts—the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.a and a credit card debt that is not alleged. In explanation on the SCA, Applicant cited “Stupid Financial Decisions,” explaining that he was at one point making more than he could spend, but then transferred to a location with low wages and accrued some debt. He stated that he was “slowly paying it off when I can.” Government Exhibit (GE) 1 at 32– 33. The Judge summarized the status of the three alleged debts as follows: SOR ¶ 1.a: A personal loan for $30,000, this debt was incurred in September 2015 and charged off in about December 2019 in the approximate amount of $11,010. In his 2022 SCA, Applicant reported this account and estimated its delinquency as December 2017. At hearing, Applicant testified that he was unaware of the delinquency until about September 2023, when he checked his credit report. The Judge found that, as of the hearing, Applicant “had not made any payments on this account or had any communications with the creditor,” that he contacted the creditor post-hearing and “received a settlement offer of $6,050,” but that there was no evidence of any payments towards the settlement at the close of the record. Decision at 2–3. SOR ¶ 1.b: This vehicle loan was opened in January 2018 and charged off in about August 2020 in the approximate amount of $7,704. Because of mechanical problems, Applicant voluntarily surrendered the vehicle for repossession. Although he expected to pay the creditor the deficiency balance following the auction of the vehicle, Applicant had “not had any further communication with the creditor since he surrendered the collateral” and “had taken no steps to address or resolve the delinquent debt.” Id. at 3. The Judge noted that post-hearing Applicant paid $2,732 on the account but found that “there is no further information as to whether this was a lump- sum settlement or one of multiple agreed-upon payments.” Id. SOR ¶ 1.c: Applicant testified that this credit card account has been delinquent since about 2017, with an approximate balance of $26,240. The creditor agreed to settle the debt for approximately $14,400, and Applicant provided proof that he began making regular $100 bi weekly payments on this account in November 2025 totaling $1,403 at the time of the hearing. Applicant testified that he earned approximately $98,000 in salary in 2025, with an anticipated salary for 2026 of approximately $101,600. In addition to his salary, he receives monthly disability compensation from the Department of Veterans Affairs, which increased shortly before his May 2026 hearing from $750 to approximately $2,200. The Judge found that Applicant prepared a debt repayment plan in April 2026, that he established a bi-weekly budgeting system with autopay for most recurring expenses, and that he expressed his intent to pay SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.c within the next two years. The Judge noted that Applicant attributed his financial delinquencies to some financial mismanagement, cost-of-living 2
adjustments after he relocated with the Navy, and a toxic relationship with a former girlfriend that resulted in Applicant forcing her removal from his house via foreclosure. The Judge also noted that Applicant “identified two past-due credit card accounts, totaling approximately $7,500, which he paid in August 2023 and December 2024.” Id. at 4. Judge’s Analysis The Judge found that “[t]he record evidence established Applicant’s three delinquent accounts, totaling approximately $45,000.” Id. at 5. In concluding that Applicant did not mitigate the established security concerns either under Guideline F or the Whole-Person Concept, the Judge cited the timing of Applicant’s remedial efforts and made the following findings and conclusions pertinent to the appeal: For the repossessed vehicle (SOR ¶ 1.b.), he surrendered the vehicle in about 2020 or 2022 and took no further steps to address the deficiency balance on the account. He reported two delinquent accounts on his e-QIP, including SOR ¶ 1.a., but took no further action to address these debts or to participate in credit counseling to understand how to address and resolve these debts. After the issuance of the SOR, Applicant initiated a payment plan with one creditor (SOR ¶ 1.c.), and, after the hearing, he contacted the other two creditors to negotiate repayment plans. These efforts are favorable evidence in mitigation; however, the timing of these efforts must be considered. The timing of Applicant’s debt-resolution efforts is relevant and material to the evaluation of his evidence in mitigation. (internal citation omitted.) . . . I found Applicant’s testimony to be credible and his acknowledgement of his past financial mismanagement to be sincere. In April 2026, he developed a structured and reasonable debt-resolution plan, and he has taken some steps in furtherance of this plan. Unfortunately, the timing of his debt-resolution efforts – all after the issuance of the SOR – undercuts his evidence in mitigation. Id. at 6-7 (emphasis added). Discussion On appeal, Applicant highlights that the Judge failed to credit him for payments on the alleged debts, that he more broadly failed to consider the alleged debts in the context of his overall financial history and his payments on non-alleged debts, and that his reliance on the timing of Applicant’s efforts is not supported by the record. These arguments have merit. When an Administrative Judge’s factual findings are challenged, the Board must determine whether “[t]he Administrative Judge’s findings of fact are supported by such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion in light of all the contrary evidence in the same record.” Directive, E3.1.32.1. The Board must consider not only whether there is record evidence supporting a judge’s findings, but also whether there is evidence that fairly 3
detracts from the weight of the evidence supporting those findings, and whether the judge’s findings reflect a reasonable interpretation of the record evidence as a whole. ISCR Case No. 02 12199 at 2–3 (App. Bd. Aug. 8, 2005). A judge’s decision can be arbitrary or capricious if: it does not examine relevant evidence; it fails to articulate a satisfactory explanation for its conclusions, including a rational connection between the facts found and the choice made; it does not consider relevant factors; it reflects a clear error of judgment; it fails to consider an important aspect of the case; it offers an explanation for the decision that runs contrary to the record evidence; or it is so implausible that it cannot be ascribed to a mere difference of opinion. See ISCR Case No. 95-0600, 1996 WL 480993 at *3 (App. Bd. May. 16, 1996) (citing Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n v. State Farm Mut. Auto Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29, 43 (1983)). Our review confirms that the Judge made erroneous findings and conclusions and failed to consider relevant evidence about alleged and non-alleged debts, as detailed below. Factual Errors on Alleged Debts Aggregate Debt: As a preliminary matter, the Judge’s conclusion that “[t]he record evidence established Applicant’s three delinquent accounts, totaling approximately $45,000” is erroneous. Decision at 5. When the SOR was issued, the debts alleged in SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.b had already been significantly reduced, as discussed further below. All record evidence confirmed that the aggregate delinquent debt was $35,010 at the time the SOR was issued, rather than the greater amount alleged in the SOR and adopted by the Judge. SOR ¶ 1.a: The Judge made three errors regarding this debt. 1) He erroneously concluded that this debt was delinquent in the alleged amount of $11,010. Applicant took out a personal loan for $30,000 in September 2015. In December 2019, the account became delinquent and was charged off at $11,010. Applicant made payments on the charged-off account until October 2021, reducing the balance to $6,050, as reported in Applicant’s SCA and confirmed by all record evidence. 2) The Judge failed to acknowledge or credit these pre-SOR payments, which contradict his over-arching conclusion that all remedial efforts were post-SOR. 3) By email post-hearing, Applicant verified with the creditor that $6,050 remained the pay off amount, which the Judge mischaracterized as a settlement offer, failing to acknowledge that the actual debt was $6,050 and not $11,010. SOR ¶ 1.b: The Judge made three errors regarding this delinquent vehicle loan. 1) He erroneously concluded that this debt was delinquent in the alleged amount of $7,704. Although charged off in August 2020 at $7,704, the deficiency balance after auction was $4,969 as of September 2022. Applicant made regular payments from September 2022 through July 2024 and further reduced the balance to $2,731, as reflected on the Government’s pre-SOR July 2025 credit report and Applicant’s March 2025 credit report. 2) The Judge failed to acknowledge or credit the two years of pre-SOR payments, which contradict his over-arching conclusion that all remedial efforts were post-SOR, instead 4
erroneously finding that “[Applicant] surrendered the vehicle in about 2020 or 2022 and took no further steps to address the deficiency balance on the account.” Id. at 6 (emphasis added). 3) After the hearing, Applicant paid the full balance of $2,731 and provided proof to the Judge. The Judge acknowledged the payment but then stated, “there is no further information as to whether this was a lump-sum settlement or one of multiple agreed-upon payments,”1 when in fact the payment satisfied the remaining debt of $2,731. Failure to Consider Relevant Evidence In addition to the factual errors on the alleged debts highlighted above, we conclude that the Judge failed to consider relevant evidence of record. The Judge found that the three alleged debts became delinquent between December 2017 and August 2020 and focused on Applicant’s failure to resolve them prior to receiving the SOR in August 2025. In doing so, the Judge overlooked a critical fact—Applicant had six consumer accounts that became delinquent during this timeframe, not just the three alleged, and he resolved three of them prior to receiving the SOR in August 2025.2 In conducting his mitigation analysis, the Judge omitted any reference to Applicant’s remedial efforts on the three non-alleged delinquent debts and instead made an erroneous adverse conclusion on one of them. We turn to the non-alleged debts and that error now. Applicant introduced evidence that, prior to the SOR, he successfully resolved three delinquent debts: 1) A charged-off credit card account in the amount of $1,441, for which Applicant started payments in November 2022 and paid the balance in August 2023, two years prior to the SOR;3 2) A delinquent credit card account closed by the creditor in the amount of $3,338, for which Applicant began payments in September 2022 and paid the balance in November 2024, ten months prior to the SOR; and 3) A charged off credit card account in the amount of $3,304, which Applicant paid off in two payments by December 2024, nine months prior to the SOR. Notably, in his mitigation analysis, the Judge found that “[Applicant] reported two delinquent accounts on his [SCA], including SOR ¶ 1.a., but took no further action to address these debts.” Id. at 6 (emphasis added). That is incorrect. On his June 2022 SCA, Applicant disclosed the delinquent credit card account identified at 1) above. Contrary to the Judge’s finding, Applicant began consistent payments on the reported debt in November 2022 and paid off the balance in August 2023, two years prior to the SOR. 1 Id. at 3. 2 In his Findings of Fact, the Judge briefly noted that Applicant “identified two past-due credit card accounts . . . which he paid in August 2023 and December 2024,” but made no further reference. Id. at 4. 3 The two credit reports in evidence are unclear as to whether Applicant paid the full balance on this debt or a settlement balance. 5
In evaluating Guideline F cases, the Board has consistently noted that the concept of “‘meaningful track record’ necessarily includes evidence of actual debt reduction through payment of debts. See, e.g., ISCR Case No. 05-01920 at 5 (App. Bd. Mar. 1, 2007). However, an applicant is not required to establish that he has paid off each debt listed in the SOR. The Board has previously noted that an applicant is not required to be debt-free nor to develop a plan for paying off all debts immediately or simultaneously. All that is required is that an applicant act responsibly given his circumstances and develop a reasonable plan for repayment, accompanied by “concomitant conduct,” that is, actions which evidence a serious intent to effectuate the plan. Additionally, there is no requirement that the first debts paid be the ones listed in the SOR. ISCR Case No. 07-06482 at 3 (App. Bd. May 21, 2008). Said differently, a judge should evaluate alleged debts in the context of an applicant’s overall efforts on resolving his financial delinquencies, rather than narrowly focusing on the alleged debts and ignoring other remedial efforts. Here, the Judge failed to do so by focusing solely on the three alleged debts and omitting any consideration of the three satisfied debts. In failing to consider Applicant’s successful payment efforts on non-alleged debts, the Judge failed to consider relevant evidence and an important aspect of the case. Timing of Debt Resolution Efforts Applicant argues that the Judge’s adverse decision relied unduly on the timing of Applicant’s efforts and that this reliance is particularly problematic because he was simply wrong about the timing in several regards. We agree. As is clear from the Judge’s findings and analysis summarized above, the Judge found adversely to Applicant because he was convinced that Applicant failed to take any steps to address his financial delinquencies prior to issuance of the SOR. In his Whole-Person Concept analysis, the Judge first acknowledged some mitigating evidence but concluded: “Unfortunately, the timing of his debt-resolution efforts – all after the issuance of the SOR – undercuts his evidence in mitigation.” Id. at 7. We note first that the timing of debt-resolution efforts is one of the many factors to be weighed in light of the totality of the evidence. But in this case, the Judge’s critical conclusion – that all debt-resolution efforts came after issuance of the SOR – is also demonstrably wrong, as detailed above. Specifically, the statement is erroneous as it pertains to two of the three alleged debts (SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.b), as Applicant made significant pre-SOR payments on those debts, and it entirely ignores Applicant’s successful resolution of three non-alleged debts prior to receiving the SOR. The Judge’s errors regarding the timing of Applicant’s efforts are inarguably harmful, as he relied so heavily upon them in his mitigation and Whole-Person Concept analyses. Conclusion Based on our review of the record, we conclude that the Judge’s decision contains cumulative errors that result in arbitrary and capricious findings, as they fail to consider important aspects of the case and run contrary to the weight of the record evidence. Based on the record as a whole, the alleged financial concerns are mitigated by Applicant’s debt resolution efforts. At the close of the record, Applicant’s debt situation could be summarized as follows: Having amassed six delinquent debts beginning in about 2017, Applicant had completely resolved four – three prior to issuance of the SOR and one post-hearing. Of his two remaining debts, he was in compliance with a payment plan on SOR ¶ 1.c that began in November 2025 and was in contact with the creditor for the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.a, which had a balance of $6,050. The Judge’s adverse decision is not sustainable. See ISCR Case No. 22-01002 at 4 (App. Bd. Sep. 26, 2024) (Reversal 6
is appropriate when the Board concludes from the record that a contrary formal finding or overall grant or denial of security clearance eligibility is the clear outcome.). Order The decision in ISCR Case No. 25-00859 is REVERSED. Signed: Moira Modzelewski Moira Modzelewski Administrative Judge Chair, Appeal Board Signed: Jennifer Goldstein Jennifer Goldstein Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board Separate Opinion of Board Member Allison Marie I respectfully dissent. I agree with my colleagues that the Judge made certain errors in factual findings about Applicant’s debt resolution efforts, which may have affected the disqualification and mitigation analyses. I disagree, however, that upon correction of the identified errors, an “overall grant . . . of security clearance eligibility is the clear outcome based on the record.” ISCR Case No. 22-01002, 2024 WL 4445514 at *3 (App. Bd. Sep. 26, 2024). For the following reasons, I would instead remand the matter to the Judge to correct the errors and issue a new decision. Applicant submitted his SCA in June 2022, at which time the three SOR allegations and two of the three unalleged debts identified by the Majority were delinquent. The record reflects that the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.a was charged off for $11,010 in December 2019, that a payment was last made on the account in October 2021, and that the delinquent balance was $6,050 as of June 2022.4 While Applicant initially testified that he made no payments on the debt and had not contacted the creditor since it became delinquent, he later affirmed his SCA explanation that he made “payments off and on,” agreeing that he may have “tried to make payments at some point.” Tr. at 42, 51-53. The Majority conclude that Applicant should be credited with the full pre-October 2021 reduction, but it is not entirely clear how and when the balance decreased from $11,010 to $6,050. Even if the evidence sufficiently established that Applicant should be credited with that 4 Applicant disclosed the $6,050 delinquent balance on his June 2022 SCA. See GE 1 at 32; Tr. at 52-53. 7
reduction – a matter properly left to the Judge – the record also reflects that Applicant took no steps to resolve the remaining $6,050 balance after October 2021. The record next reflects that the debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.b was originally charged off for $7,704 in August 2020 and later decreased to the $4,969 deficiency balance that remained after auction in September 2022. At that same time, monthly payments of about $99 began crediting to the account and continued for about two years, through July 2024, further reducing the balance to $2,731. The Majority conclude that Applicant made those payments appearing on his credit report; however, Applicant testified – and adamantly so – that he had no contact with the creditor after about 2020 when he told them that he wanted to surrender the vehicle, including when he noticed it was finally repossessed several years later or when he received the SOR alleging the delinquency. Id. at 54-59. Here again, even if the evidence sufficiently established that Applicant should be credited with the post-auction reduction, the record also reflects that no further payments were made between July 2024 and Applicant’s lump sum payment resolving the debt on May 20, 2026 – two weeks after the hearing. While the Judge failed to recognize that final payment as fully resolving the account, it is well settled that repayment of a debt does not curtail further analysis of its security significance.5 The weight to be afforded Applicant’s post-hearing payment in light of the entire record is a matter properly left to the Judge on remand. The record also reflects that the $26,240 debt alleged at SOR ¶ 1.c became delinquent in about 2017 and that Applicant’s effort to resolve the account began in November 2025, two months after receiving the SOR, when he agreed to settle the debt for $14,432 via $100 bi-weekly payments. As of the close of the record, he had consistently made the first 14 payments. The Judge acknowledged these recent efforts but found that their timing detracted from mitigation. Indeed, the Board has frequently highlighted the importance of considering the timing6 and consistency7 of an applicant’s debt repayment in evaluating mitigation. Applicant’s repayment efforts are favorable evidence and warrant consideration. The weight afforded those efforts in light of his pattern of delaying and suspending repayment – which bears on both his financial responsibility generally and his willingness and ability to maintain the bi-weekly payments required through May 2031 to fully resolve his most significant delinquency – is for the Judge to determine. Finally, I agree that Applicant’s pre-SOR resolution of about $6,000 in unalleged debt warrants consideration in the Guideline F mitigation analysis, but so does the timing of those efforts. The unalleged delinquencies were resolved in August 2023, November 2024, and December 2024, after which the record reflects no apparent active debt resolution until November 2025. The Judge should be permitted to weigh that period of inactivity together with the favorable repayment efforts that preceded and followed it. Reversal here effectively determines that, once the identified factual errors are corrected, the record could not reasonably support denial of Applicant’s national security eligibility. I 5 See ISCR Case No. 03-04704, 2005 WL 4048824 at *3 (App. Bd. Sep. 21, 2005) (“Many facts and circumstances surrounding the debt, including the manner in which it was incurred, the circumstances under which it became delinquent, and the manner in which Applicant addressed the delinquency are relevant factors for the Judge's consideration, notwithstanding the fact that the debt delinquency was eventually resolved.”). 6 See ISCR Case No. 15-06440, 2017 WL 6988287 at *3 (App. Bd. Dec. 26, 2017). 7 See ISCR Case No. 01-21386, 2003 WL 21979739 at *2 (App. Bd. Jun. 11, 2003). 8
disagree. The corrected facts may strengthen Applicant’s case for mitigation, but they do not compel it. Whether those facts, weighed against the timing and consistency of Applicant’s debt- resolution efforts, establish mitigation is a determination that the Judge should make in the first instance. The case should be remanded to permit that determination. Signed: Allison Marie Allison Marie Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board 9