Skip to content
← Back to results

A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.

ISCR Case No. 25-01094

Granted

Decided Oct 1, 2026 · Administrative Judge Braden M. Murphy · Hearing

Case headnote

Summary

The applicant, a 52-year-old design director, faced security concerns under Guideline F due to past-due Federal and state income taxes from tax years 2023 and 2024. The debts arose during a period marked by personal tragedies, including the loss of a child and a divorce, but the applicant demonstrated a commitment to resolving these debts through established repayment plans. The judge found sufficient evidence to mitigate the financial concerns, granting the applicant eligibility for a security clearance.

Why the applicant prevailed

  • The applicant established a track record of regular payments through an agreed-upon repayment plan with tax authorities.
  • The applicant's tax debts were largely due to circumstances beyond his control, including family tragedies and professional instability.
  • The applicant provided evidence of ongoing efforts to resolve his tax liabilities, demonstrating responsible financial behavior.

Conditions referenced

Disqualifying

  • AG ¶ 19(a) Inability to satisfy debtsraised
  • AG ¶ 19(c) A history of not meeting financial obligationsraised
  • AG ¶ 19(f) Failure to pay annual Federal, state, or local income tax as requiredraised

Mitigating

  • AG ¶ 20(b) Conditions that resulted in the financial problem were largely beyond the person’s controlapplied
  • AG ¶ 20(c) The individual has received or is receiving financial counselingapplied
  • AG ¶ 20(d) The individual initiated and is adhering to a good-faith effort to repay overdue creditorsapplied
  • AG ¶ 20(g) The individual has made arrangements with the appropriate tax authority to file or pay the amount owedapplied

Key rule quoted

Procedural posture

SOR issued
02/05/2026
Answer filed
03/31/2026
Hearing held
08/06/2026 via video-teleconference
Decision date
10/01/2026

Cite for

  • Mitigation of Financial Concerns Under Guideline F Due to Personal Hardships
  • Established Repayment Plans as a Factor in Security Clearance Decisions
  • Impact of Personal Circumstances on Financial Obligations

Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.

From the decision

Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.

Applicant Age
52
Prior Clearance
held
Delinquent Usd
80000
Payment Plan
yes
Bankruptcy
none

Allegations under Guideline F

Reading the 4 per allegation rows needs a free account.

4 rows in this decision.

It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.

Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.

Full decision

Open original PDF

The complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.

Decision text, by section

Appearances

______________ DEFENSE LEGAL SERVICES AGENCY DEFENSE OFFICE OF HEARINGS AND APPEALS In the matter of: ) ) ) ISCR Case No. 25-01094 ) Ap

Decision

plicant for Security Clearance ) Appearances For Government: Erin P. Thompson, Esq., Department Counsel For Applicant: Samir Nahkleh, Esq. 10/01/2026 Decision MURPHY, Braden M., Administrative Judge: Applicant owes past-due Federal and state income taxes from tax years 2023 and 2024. These debts occurred during an isolated period of family tragedy, trauma, and family and professional instability. He has an established track record of regu

Statement of Case

lar payments through an agreed-upon repayment plan with tax authorities, and his tax debts, while still extensive, are being resolved and are under control. Applicant has provided sufficient evidence to mitigate the Guideline F financial considerations security concerns. Applicant’s eligibility for access to classified information is granted. Statement of the Case Applicant submitted a security clearance application (SCA) on November 30, 2024. On February 5, 2026, the Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency (DCSA) issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR) to Applicant detailing security concerns under Guideline F, financial considerations due to past-due Federal and state income taxes. DCSA issued the SOR under Executive Order (Exec. Or.) 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry (February 20, 1960), as amended; Department of Defense (DOD) Directive 5220.6, Defense Industrial Personnel Security Clearance Review

Program (January 2, 1

Findings of Fact

992), as amended (Directive); and Security Executive Agent Directive 4, National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (AG), effective June 8, 2017. Through counsel, Applicant answered the SOR on March 31, 2026, and requested a hearing before an administrative judge from the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA). He also provided attachments identified as Applicant Exhibits (AE) A through K. The case was assigned to me on June 8, 2026. On July 20, 2026, after clarifying Applicant’s sponsorship status, DOHA issued a notice scheduling a video- teleconference hearing for August 6, 2026. The hearing convened as scheduled. Department Counsel submitted Government’s Exhibits (GE) 1 through 4. Applicant testified and submitted AE A through K (attached to the SOR Response) and new exhibits AE L through AE R. One exhibit (AE J) was not admitted, as it is already part of the pleadings. All other exhibits were admitted without objection. I held the record open to allow Applicant the opportunity to submit additional documentation.

On August 14, 2026, Applicant timely submitted additional documents, which were marked and admitted as AE S, T, and U without objection. Those documents are identified in the Facts section below. The record closed on August 17, 2026, and DOHA received the hearing transcript (Tr.) on August 18, 2026. Findings of Fact The four allegations in the SOR (¶¶ 1.a-1.d) concern Applicant’s past-due Federal and state income taxes from tax years (TY) 2023 and 2024. In his SOR response, Applicant “denied” each of the allegations as written, while providing explanations. However, a plain reading of his explanations shows that he “acknowledged” the existence of the debts, while denying that the debts were not being addressed and noting that each tax debt was either being paid, or in one case, had been paid in full, under agreed-upon repayment plans with appropriate tax authorities. (Answer) After a thorough and careful review of the pleadings and the record evidence, I make the following additional findings of fact. Applicant is 52 years old. He and his wife married in 1996. They separated in about February 2023 and divorced in 2026. They have had three children: one is 17, one is 14, and one is deceased. (GE 1 at 18, 22-23; AE S; Tr. 26-27) Applicant has a bachelor’s degree. He worked as a design director for software company A from 2014 until December 2021. Company A was then dissolved and reformed as company D, for whom Applicant was also a director until September 2022. Since October 2020, Applicant has also managed his own ecommerce business out of his home. Beginning in December 2024, he worked for defense contractor C as a senior product designer. He was highly regarded and performed above expectations. His employment there ended at the end of May 2026 because his clearance had not been adjudicated, though he remains sponsored and would return to work if it were granted. 2

(GE 1; Hearing Exhibit VI; AE N; Tr. 25-28) Applicant held a clearance during previous employment in the defense industry, for about 10-12 years. (GE 1 at 32; AE A, AE G; Tr. 28-30, 58-59, 89-92) Applicant also owns several homes as investment properties. In 2021, he and his wife owed five properties: their marital home and another rental property in State 1, and rental properties in States 2, 3, and 4. (AE M; Tr. 31-32) In spring of 2021, their home in State 1 was badly damaged in a house fire. They moved into their State 1 rental property soon thereafter. Six weeks later, in June 2021, their 16-year-old daughter and eldest child was killed in an auto accident. These tragic circumstances put an incalculable strain on Applicant’s marriage. His self-owned ecommerce business also suffered since he worked out of his home, damaged by the fire. That business was for a time their sole income since his wife was in school and not working, and because Applicant lost his employment with Company A in late 2022. (GE 2 at 8-9; Tr. 31-38, 58-62, 71-73) Applicant and his wife separated in March 2023, when she returned to their rebuilt home with their children. To support herself, his wife requested a 50% share of his liquid retirement assets. The early withdrawal from those assets led to tax consequences. Around this time, the tenant in their State 2 rental property moved out and left the home in significant disrepair. Applicant incurred unexpected costs in repairing the property. They sold the home in State 2, but at a greatly depreciated value, leading to additional tax consequences, including the State 2 tax debt at SOR ¶ 1.c. (GE 2 at 8-9; GE 3 at 3- 5; Tr. 31-41, 58-62, 73-74) Applicant referred to these circumstances as the “perfect storm” of tax liability, including the penalty for early withdrawals, business taxes, 1099 (self-employed) taxes, and taxes resulting from the sale of the rental home in State 2. While Applicant does not owe past-due taxes for TY 2022, these unique, unprecedented circumstances led to significant Federal and state tax liability for TY 2023. (GE 2 at 8-9; GE 3 at 3-5; AE O, AE P; Tr. 38-4

Policies

1, 54-55, 71, 79-81) With assistance from their accountant, Applicant and his wife jointly filed their TY 2023 Federal return on June 3, 2024. They owed about $80,000 in taxes. As of June 2025, he owed an additional $14,300 in interest and penalties, for a total of about $94,300. (GE 2 at 17) (SOR ¶ 1.a) Applicant said he was “shell-shocked” by the amount of taxes he owed. He pursued resolution through a tax advocacy firm. It took about a year to establish installments with State 2 and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). (Tr. 42-44, 55-59) Applicant disclosed his past-due Federal and state income taxes for TY 2023 on his November 2024 SCA. (GE 1 at 33-34) Several interrogatories from DCSA and DOHA followed, inquiring about the status of his taxes. He provided responses as requested in June 2025, September 2025, and January 2026. (GE 2, GE 3, GE 4, respectively) 3

In his June 2025 interrogatory response, Applicant also disclosed that his State 2 income tax debt was about $15,000. (SOR ¶ 1.c) In March 2025, he entered into an installment agreement with State 2 with monthly payments of about $418, withdrawn from his checking account. (GE 2 at 8-9, 13, 18-24; AE E; Tr. 46-48) As of September 2025, Applicant owed between $12,000 and $13,000 for his TY 2023 State 2 tax debt. By that time, Applicant owed an estimate

Analysis

d $99,589 to the IRS for TY 2023. The IRS had by then approved a repayment plan at $1,300 a month, and he began those monthly payments in November 2025. (GE 3 at 9-13, 25-39; GE 4; AE B-AE D; Tr. 44-46) (SOR ¶¶ 1.a, 1.c) Applicant’s original accountant filed an extension for his TY 2024 tax returns in April 2025. At the same time, the accountant informed him that they were transitioning to a new career and would be unable to assist him further. It took some time for Applicant to find a new, reliable accountant. His taxes were also complicated by the fact that his wife was a partner in the ecommerce business. His new accountant filed his TY 2024 returns in January 2026. (GE 3 at 26; GE 4; AE Q; Tr. 62-71, 99-100) He owed an additional $34,885 in Federal taxes (GE 4 at 9; SOR ¶ 1.b) and $3,274 more in state income taxes to State 1. (GE 4 at 65-68; SOR ¶ 1.d) He did not owe any state income taxes to any other state. (GE 4; Tr. 42) Due to his increased tax debt from TY 2024, Applicant increased his $1,300 monthly payments to the IRS to an agreed-upon $1,688, beginning in May 2026. Those payments continue. (AE P; Tr. 42-44, 98-99) For TY 2023, as of the hearing date, he owed $65,693 in past-due Federal taxes, $13,254 in interest, and $12,349 in penalties, for a total of $91,297. (AE P; Tr. 84) For TY 2024, as of the hearing date, Applicant owed $42,581 in Federal taxes, $1,295 in interest, and $943 in penalties, for a total of $44,818. (AE Q; Tr. 84) All payments go towards TY 2023 first. As of the close of the record, Applicant’s Federal tax debt totaled a combined $136,115 for TY 2023 and TY 2024. (AE P, AE Q) He has filed an extension for his TY 2025 Federal return, and he expects to meet the October 2026 deadline and pay any taxes owed, especially now that his divorce is final. (AE R; Tr. 102-107) Applicant’s divorce was filed in February 2026 and finalized in June 2026. According to the divorce settlement, he is responsible for all Federal and state tax liabilities through TY 2025. (AE S at 14) His wife maintains the marital home in State 1 as her primary residence. He maintains his home in State 1 (the former rental property) and the two investment properties in States 3 and 4. He has five years to sell or refinance those two properties. He will also maintain sole ownership of his ecommerce business. Selling the rental properties would allow him to use the proceeds to address his tax debt. (AE L, AE M, AE S; Tr. 51-55, 74-79, 86-87, 92-96) On February 13, 2026, Applicant resolved his TY 2024 state tax debt to State 1 with a payment of $4,910. (AE F, AE U; Tr. 49-50, 97-98) SOR ¶ 1.d is resolved. 4

As of August 2026, Applicant had paid $7,546 towards his $13,578 state tax debt to State 2 for TY 2023 (alleged at $12,005). He has $6,032 left to pay. (AE T) SOR ¶ 1.c is being resolved through regular monthly payments of $417. He has no more state tax due or any connections to State 2. (Tr. 82-83) Since beginning to pay his Federal and state tax debts in March 2025 (state) and November 2025 (Federal), he has paid about $12,000 towards his state tax debts and about $14,500 towards his Federal tax debts, about $26,500 combined. Applicant attests that he can continue his agreed-upon monthly tax payments, based on his improved and projected business income, and he is committed to doing so. His recent personal financial statement (PFS) supports this. It shows an estimated $13,000 in monthly income from his business and real estate holdings. The mortgages on his various properties are all current, and he has no other delinquencies. (AE H, AE I, AE K, AE L; Tr. 50-51;) Policies It is well established that no one has a right to a security clearance. As the Supreme Court has held, “the clearly consistent standard indicates that security determinations should err, if they must, on the side of denials.” Department of Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518, 531 (1988). When evaluating an applicant’s eligibility for a security clearance, the administrat

Analysis

ments in November 2025. (GE 3 at 9-13, 25-39; GE 4; AE B-AE D; Tr. 44-46) (SOR ¶¶ 1.a, 1.c) Applicant’s original accountant filed an extension for his TY 2024 tax returns in April 2025. At the same time, the accountant informed him that they were transitioning to a new career and would be unable to assist him further. It took some time for Applicant to find a new, reliable accountant. His taxes were also complicated by the fact that his wife was a partner in the ecommerce business. His new accountant filed his TY 2024 returns in January 2026. (GE 3 at 26; GE 4; AE Q; Tr. 62-71, 99-100) He owed an additional $34,885 in Federal taxes (GE 4 at 9; SOR ¶ 1.b) and $3,274 more in state income taxes to State 1. (GE 4 at 65-68; SOR ¶ 1.d) He did not owe any state income taxes to any other state. (GE 4; Tr. 42) Due to his increased tax debt from TY 2024, Applicant increased his $1,300 monthly payments to the IRS to an agreed-upon $1,688, beginning in May 2026. Those payments continue. (AE P; Tr. 42-44, 98-99) For TY 2023, as of the hearing date, he owed $65,693 in past-due Federal taxes, $13,254 in interest, and $12,349 in penalties, for a total of $91,297. (AE P; Tr. 84) For TY 2024, as of the hearing date, Applicant owed $42,581 in Federal taxes, $1,295 in interest, and $943 in penalties, for a total of $44,818. (AE Q; Tr. 84) All payments go towards TY 2023 first. As of the close of the record, Applicant’s Federal tax debt totaled a combined $136,115 for TY 2023 and TY 2024. (AE P, AE Q) He has filed an extension for his TY 2025 Federal return, and he expects to meet the October 2026 deadline and pay any taxes owed, especially now that his divorce is final. (AE R; Tr. 102-107) Applicant’s divorce was filed in February 2026 and finalized in June 2026. According to the divorce settlement, he is responsible for all Federal and state tax liabilities through TY 2025. (AE S at 14) His wife maintains the marital home in State 1 as her primary residence. He maintains his home in State 1 (the former rental property) and the two investment properties in States 3 and 4. He has five years to sell or refinance those two properties. He will also maintain sole ownership of his ecommerce business. Selling the rental properties would allow him to use the proceeds to address his tax debt. (AE L, AE M, AE S; Tr. 51-55, 74-79, 86-87, 92-96) On February 13, 2026, Applicant resolved his TY 2024 state tax debt to State 1 with a payment of $4,910. (AE F, AE U; Tr. 49-50, 97-98) SOR ¶ 1.d is resolved. 4

As of August 2026, Applicant had paid $7,546 towards his $13,578 state tax debt to State 2 for TY 2023 (alleged at $12,005). He has $6,032 left to pay. (AE T) SOR ¶ 1.c is being resolved through regular monthly payments of $417. He has no more state tax due or any connections to State 2. (Tr. 82-83) Since beginning to pay his Federal and state tax debts in March 2025 (state) and November 2025 (Federal), he has paid about $12,000 towards his state tax debts and about $14,500 towards his Federal tax debts, about $26,500 combined. Applicant attests that he can continue his agreed-upon monthly tax payments, based on his

Whole Person Concept

improved and projected business income, and he is committed to doing so. His recent personal financial statement (PFS) supports this. It shows an estimated $13,000 in monthly income from his business and real estate holdings. The mortgages on his various properties are all current, and he has no other delinquencies. (AE H, AE I, AE K, AE L; Tr. 50-51;) Policies It is well established that no one has a right to a security clearance. As the Supreme Court has held, “the clearly consistent standard indicates that security determinations should err, if they must, on the side of denials.” Department of Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518, 531 (1988). When evaluating an applicant’s eligibility for a security clearance, the administrative judge must consider the adjudicative guidelines. In addition to brief introductory explanations for each guideline, the adjudicative guidelines list potentially disqualifying conditions and mitigating conditions, which are used in evaluating an applicant’s eligibility for access to classified information. These guidelines are not inflexible rules of law. Instead, recognizing the complexities of human behavior, these guidelines are applied in conjunction with the factors listed in the adjudicative process. The administrative judge’s overarching adjudicative goal is a fair, impartial, and commonsense decision. According to AG ¶ 2(a), the entire process is a conscientious scrutiny of a number of variables known as the “whole-person concept.” The administrative judge must consider all available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable, in making a decision. The protection of the national security is the paramount consideration. AG ¶ 2(b) requires that “[a]ny doubt concerning personnel being considered for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.” In reaching this decision, I have drawn only those conclusions that are reasonable, logical, and based on the evidence contained in the record. Likewise, I have not drawn inferences grounded on mere speculation or conjecture. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.14, the Government must present evidence to establish controverted facts alleged in the SOR. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.15, an “applicant is responsible for presenting witnesses and other evidence to rebut, explain, extenuate, or 5

Formal Findings

mitigate facts admitted by applicant or proven by Department Counsel and has the ultimate burden of persuasion to obtain a favorable security decision.” A person who seeks access to classified information enters into a fiduciary relationship with the Government predicated upon trust and confidence. This relationship transcends normal duty hours and endures throughout off-duty hours. The Government reposes a high degree of trust and confidence in individuals to whom it grants access to

Conclusion

classified information. Decisions include, by necessity, consideration of the possible risk the applicant may deliberately or inadvertently fail to safeguard classified information. Such decisions entail a certain degree of legally permissible extrapolation of potential, rather than actual, risk of