A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.
ISCR Case No. 26-00253
GrantedDecided Oct 2, 2026 · Administrative Judge Mark W. Harvey · Hearing
Case headnote
Summary
The applicant, a 34-year-old strength and conditioning coach for a government contractor, faced security concerns under Guideline F due to two delinquent debts totaling approximately $29,745. The applicant admitted to the debts but demonstrated a good-faith effort to resolve them, including paying one debt in full and actively seeking information about the other. The judge found that the applicant's financial issues were mitigated, leading to a grant of security clearance.
Why the applicant prevailed
- The applicant demonstrated a good-faith effort to resolve his debts, including paying one debt in full.
- The applicant received financial counseling and created a budget to manage his finances.
- The applicant's financial problems were largely due to circumstances beyond his control, such as unemployment and his spouse's inability to work.
Conditions referenced
Disqualifying
- AG ¶ 19(a) Inability to satisfy debtsraised
- AG ¶ 19(c) A history of not meeting financial obligationsraised
Mitigating
- AG ¶ 20(b) Conditions largely beyond the person's controlapplied
- AG ¶ 20(c) Received financial counselingapplied
- AG ¶ 20(d) Good-faith effort to repay debtsapplied
Key rule quoted
“An applicant is not required, as a matter of law, to establish that he has paid off each and every debt listed in the SOR.”
Procedural posture
- SOR issued
- 04/24/2026
- Answer filed
- 06/26/2026
- Hearing held
- 09/11/2026 via Microsoft Teams
- Decision date
- 10/02/2026
Cite for
- Mitigation of Financial Issues Under Guideline F
- Good-faith Efforts to Resolve Debts
- Impact of Personal Circumstances on Financial Obligations
Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.
From the decision
Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.
- Applicant Age
- 34
- Delinquent Usd
- 29745
- Payment Plan
- yes
- Bankruptcy
- none
Allegations under Guideline F
Reading the 2 per allegation rows needs a free account.
2 rows in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.
Full decision
Open original PDFThe complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.
Decision text, by section
Appearances
ty for access to classified information is granted. Statement of the Case On January 1
Decision
2025, Applicant completed a security clearance application (SCA). (Government Exhibit (GE) 1) On April 24, 2026, the Defense
Statement of Case
unterintelligence and Security Agency (DCSA) issued a statement of reasons (SOR) to Applicant under Executive Order (Exec. Or.) 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry (February 20, 1960); Department of Defense (DoD) Directive 5220.6, Defense Industrial Personnel Security Clearance Review Program (Directive) (January 2, 1992), as amended; and Security Executive Agent Directive 4, establishing in Appendix A, the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines for Determining Eligibility for Access to Classified Information or Eligibility to Hold a Sensitive Position (AGs), effective June 8, 2017. (Hearing Exhibit (HE) 1) The SOR detailed reasons why DCSA did not find under the Directive that it is clearly consistent with the interests of national security to grant or continue a security clearance for Applicant and stated his case would be submitted to an Administrative Judge for a determination whether to grant, deny, or revoke his security clearance. Specifically, the SOR set forth security concerns arising under Guideline F. (HE 1) On
Findings of Fact
June 26, 2026, Applicant responded to the SOR. (HE 2) On August 6, 2026, Department Counsel was ready to proceed. On August 12, 2026, the case was assigned to me. On August 17, 2026, the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA) issued a notice scheduling the hearing for September 11, 2026. (HE 3) The hearing was held as scheduled using the Microsoft Teams video teleconference system. During the hearing, Department Counsel offered six exhibits; Applicant did not offer any exhibits; there were no objections; and all proffered exhibits were admitted into evidence. (Tr. 17-19; GE 1-GE 6) Applicant provided five post-hearing documents, which were admitted into evidence without objection. (Applicant Exhibits (AE) A-AE E) On September 21, 2026, DOHA received a copy of the transcript. The record closed on September 30, 2026. (AE E) Some details were excluded to protect Applicant’s right to privacy. Specific information is available in the cited exhibits and transcript. Findings of Fact In Applicant’s SOR response, he admitted the allegations in SOR ¶¶ 1.a and 1.b. H
Analysis
also provided mitigating information. His admissions are accepted as findings of fact. Applicant is a 34-year-old strength and conditioning coach for a government contractor. (Tr. 5-7) He has held this position for 18 months. (Tr. 8) In 2010, he graduated from high school. (Tr. 6) In 2017, he received a bachelor’s degree, and he majored in kinesiology. (Tr. 6) In 2021, he received a master’s degree in kinesiology. (Tr. 6) He has never served in the military. (Tr. 7) In 2021, he married, and he has two children living in his home. (Tr. 7-8) There is no evidence of adverse employment or security issues. Financial Considerations Applicant was unemployed for about three months in 2023. (Tr. 21) From 2023 to present, Applicant moved three times. (Tr. 23-24) His spouse was in an accident, and she was unable to work outside their home for a time. (Tr. 25-26) She recently began earning about $1,500 monthly. (AE E) The SOR alleges two delinquent debts totaling about $29,745. Their status is as follows. SOR ¶ 1.a alleges, and Applicant admitted, that he is indebted to a credit card company on an account that has been charged off for about $15,750. The creditor sued Applicant to enforce the debt. (Tr. 29) On July 23, 2025, the creditor dismissed the lawsuit without prejudice. (Tr. 29; GE 2 at 20) Applicant did not know why the lawsuit was dismissed. (Tr. 29) After the lawsuit was dismissed, Applicant contacted the creditor five or six times trying to obtain information about the account. (Tr. 28; GE 2 at 16-17; AE B; AE C) The law firm handling the case told him on the telephone that they were unable to 2
locate evidence of the debt. (Tr. 30) Applicant asked for a letter concerning the debt, and the creditor’s lawyer did not provide one. (Tr. 31) In 2026, he contacted the creditor about the debt, and he was advised that the law firm he contacted previously was handling the debt. (Tr. 31) He submitted a loan request with his credit union to enable him to settle the debt; however, the loan was denied. (AE D) On September 30, 2026, he contacted the law firm representing the creditor again asking for information. (AE B) On September 30, 2026, he contacted two credit reporting companies and asked them to remove the negative information from his credit bureau report (CBR) because the creditor had not verified the account. (AE C) SOR ¶ 1.b alleges, and Applicant admitted, that he is indebted to a credit card company on an account that has been charged off for about $13,995. On September 3, 2026, the collection agent for the creditor offered to settle the debt for $6,997. (AE A) On September 11, 2026, Applicant paid the creditor $6,997, and this debt is resolved. (AE A) Applicant’s August 3, 2026 CBR indicates he has seven accounts listed as current or paid. (GE 3) He received some financial counseling or advice from banks where he had accounts. (Tr. 40) Applicant and his spouse’s budget indicates their monthly net pay is $6,720; their monthly payments are $5,000; and their monthly net remainder is $1,720. (AE E) Policies The U.S. Supreme Court has recognized the substantial discretion of the Executive Branch in regulating access to information pertaining to national security emphasizing, “no one has a ‘right’ to a security clearance.” Department of the Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518, 528 (1988). As Commander in Chief, the President has the authority to control access to information bearing on national security and to determine whether an individual is sufficiently trustworthy” to have access to such information. Id. at 527. The President has authorized the Secretary of Defense or his designee to grant applicant eligibility for access to classified information “only upon a finding that it is clearly consistent with the national interest to do so.” Exec. Or. 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry § 2 (Feb. 20, 1960), as amended. Eligibility for a security clearance is predicated upon the applicant meeting the criteria contained in the adjudicative guidelines. These guidelines are not inflexible rules of law. Instead, recognizing the complexities of human behavior, these guidelines are applied in conjunction with an evaluation of the whole person. An administrative judge’s overarching adjudicative goal is a fair, impartial, and commonsense decision. An administrative judge must consider all available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable. The Government reposes a high degree of trust and confidence in persons with access to classified information. This relationship transcends normal duty hours and endures throughout off-duty hours. Decisions include, by necessity, consideration of the 3
possible risk the applicant may deliberately or inadvertently fail to safeguard classified information. Such decisions entail a certain degree of legally permissible extrapolation about potential, rather than actual, risk of compromise of classified information. Clearance decisions must be “in terms of the national interest and shall in no sense be a determination as to the loyalty of the applicant concerned.” See Exec. Or. 10865 § 7. Thus, nothing in an unfavorable decision should be construed to suggest that it is based on any express or implied determination about an applicant’s allegiance, loyalty, or patriotism. An unfavorable decision is merely an indication the applicant has not met the strict guidelines the President, Secretary of Defense, and Director of National Intelligence have established for issuing a clearance. Initially, the Government must establish, by substantial evidence, conditions in the personal or professional history of the applicant that may disqualify the applicant from being eligible for access to classified inf
Policies
rmation. The Government has the burden of establishing controverted facts alleged in the SOR. See Egan, 484 U.S. at 531. “Substantial evidence” is “more than a scintilla but less than a preponderance.” See v. Washington Metro. Area Transit Auth., 36 F.3d 375, 380 (4th Cir. 1994). The guidelines presume a nexus or rational connection between proven conduct under any of the criteria listed therein and an applicant’s security suitability. See ISCR Case No. 95-0611 at 2 (App. Bd. May 2, 1996). Once the Government establishes a disqualifying condition by substantial evidence, the burden shifts to the applicant to rebut, explain, extenuate, or mitigate the facts. Directive ¶ E3.1.15. An applicant “has the ultimate burden of demonstrating that it is clearly consistent with the national interest to grant or continue his [or her] security clearance.” ISCR Case No. 01-20700 at 3 (App. Bd. Dec. 19, 2002). The burden of disproving a mitigating condition never shifts to the Government. See ISCR Case No. 02- 31154 at 5 (App. Bd. Sept. 22, 2005). “[S]ecurity clearance determinations should err, if they must, on the side of denials.” Egan, 484 U.S. at 531; see AG ¶ 2(b). Analysis Financial Considerations AG ¶ 18 articulates the security concern for financial problems: Failure to live within one’s means, satisfy debts, and meet financial obligations may indicate poor self-control, lack of judgment, or unwillingness to abide by rules and regulations, all of which can raise questions about an individual’s reliability, trustworthiness, and ability to protect classified or sensitive information. Financial distress can also be caused or exacerbated by, and thus can be a possible indicator of, other issues of personnel security concern such as excessive gambling, mental health conditions, substance misuse, or alcohol abuse or dependence. An 4
individual who is financially overextended is at greater risk of having to engage in illegal or otherwise questionable acts to generate funds. The Appeal Board explained the scope and rationale for the financial considerations security concern in ISCR Case No. 11-05365 at 3 (App. Bd. May 1, 2012) (citation omitted) as follows: This concern is broader than the possibility that an applicant might knowingly compromise classified information to raise money in satisfaction of his or her debts. Rather, it requires a Judge to examine the totality of an applicant’s financial history and circumstances. The Judge must consider pertinent evidence regarding t he applicant’s self-control, judgment, and other qualities essential to protecting the national secrets as well as the vulnerabilities inherent in the circumstances. The Directive presumes a nexus between proven conduct under any of the Guidelines and an applicant’s security eligibility. AG ¶ 19 includes d
Analysis
squalifying conditions that could raise a security concern and may be disqualifying in this case: “(a) inability to satisfy debts”; and “(c) a history of not meeting financial obligations.” The record establishes the disqualifying conditions in AG ¶¶ 19(a) and 19(c), requiring additional inquiry about the possible applicability of mitigating conditions. Discussion of the disqualifying conditions is contained in the mitigation section, infra. The financial considerations mitigating conditions under AG ¶ 20, which may be applicable in this case, are as follows: (a) the behavior happened so long ago, was so infrequent, or occurred under such circumstances that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the individual’s current reliability, trustworthiness, or good judgment; (b) the conditions that resulted in the financial problem were largely beyond the person’s control (e.g., loss of employment, a business downturn, unexpected medical emergency, a death, divorce or separation, clear victimization by predatory lending practices, or identity theft), and the individual acted responsibly under the circumstances; (c) the individual has received or is receiving financial counseling for the problem from a legitimate and credible source, such as a non-profit credit counseling service, and there are clear indications that the problem is being resolved or is under control; (d) the individual initiated and is adhering to a good-faith effort to repay overdue creditors or otherwise resolve debts; and (e) the individual has a reasonable basis to dispute the legitimacy of the past-due debt which is the cause of the problem and provides documented 5
proof to substantiate the basis of the dispute or provides evidence of actions to resolve the issue. The Appeal Board in ISCR Case No. 10-04641 at 4 (App. Bd. Sept. 24, 2013) explained Applicant’s responsibility for proving the applicability of mitigating conditions as follows: Once a concern arises regarding an applicant’s security clearance eligibility, there is a strong presumption against the grant or maintenance of a security clearance. See Dorfmont v. Brown, 913 F.2d 1399, 1401 (9th Cir. 1990), cert. denied, 499 U.S. 905 (1991). After the Government presents evidence raising security concerns, the burden shifts to the applicant to rebut or mitigate those concerns. See Directive ¶ E3.1.15. The standard applicable in security clearance decisions is that articulated in Egan, supra. “Any doubt concerning personnel being considered for access to classified information will be resolved in favor of the national security.” Directive, Encl. 2 ¶ 2(b). In ADP Case No. 23-00547 at 3 (App. Bd. Apr. 23, 2024), the DOHA Appeal Board said: [A]n applicant must act responsibly given his or her circumstances and develop a reasonable plan for repayment, accompanied by concomitant conduct even if it may only provide for the payment of debts one at a time. ISCR Case No. 07-06482 at 3 (App. Bd. May 21, 2008). What constitutes responsible behavior depends on the facts of a given case and the fact that an applicant’s debts will not be paid off for a long time, in and of itself, may be of limited security concern. ISCR Case No. 09-08462 at 4. Relevant to the equation is an assessment as to whether an applicant acted responsibly given [his or] her limited resources See, e.g., ISCR Case No. 08-06567 at 3- 4 (App. Bd. Oct 29, 2009). “[U]ntil an applicant has a meaningful financial track record, it cannot be said as a matter of law that he has initiated a good-faith effort to repay overdue creditors or otherwise resolved debts. The phrase ‘meaningful track record’ necessarily includes evidence of actual debt reduction through payment on debts.” ISCR Case No. 22-02226 at 2 (App. Bd. Oct. 27, 2023) (citing ISCR Case No. 05-01920 at 5 (App. Bd. Mar. 1, 2007)). A security clearance adjudication is not a debt-collection procedure. It is designed to evaluate an applicant’s judgment, reliability, and trustworthiness. See ISCR Case No. 09-02160 (App. Bd. Jun. 21, 2010). Applicants are not required “to be debt-free in order to qualify for a security clearance. Rather, all that is required is that an applicant act responsibly given his or her circumstances and develop a reasonable plan for repayment, accompanied by ‘concomitant conduct’ that is, actions which evidence a serious intent to effectuate the plan.” ISCR Case No. 15-02903 at 3 (App. Bd. Mar. 9, 2017) (denial of 6
security clearance remanded) (citing ISCR Case No.13-00987 at 3, n. 5 (App. Bd. Aug. 14, 2014)). There is no requirement that an applicant make payments on all delinquent debts simultaneously, nor is there a requirement that the debts alleged in the SOR be paid first. See ISCR Case No. 07-06482 at 2-3 (App. Bd. May 21, 2008). The SOR alleges two delinquent debts totaling about $29,745. Applicant admitted SOR ¶ 1.a, that he was indebted to a credit card company on an account that has been charged off for about $15,750. He is willing to pay this debt. He repeatedly asked the creditor for information; however, the creditor was unable to locate information on the account. He asked the credit reporting companies to verify the account or remove the negative information. Applicant showed good faith in his handling of this debt, and it is mitigated. Applicant admitted SOR ¶ 1.b, that he was indebted to a credit card company on an account that had been charged off for about $13,995. On September 3, 2026, the collection agent for the creditor offered to settle the debt for $6,997. (AE A) On September 11, 2026, Applicant paid the creditor $6,997, and this debt is resolved. AG ¶ 20(a) does not apply. “It is also well established that an applicant’s ongoing, unpaid debts demonstrate a continuing course of conduct and can be viewed as recent for purposes of the Guideline F mitigating conditions.” ISCR Case No. 22-02226 at 2 (App. Bd. Oct. 27, 2023) (citing ISCR Case No. 15-06532 at 3 (App. Bd. Feb. 16, 2017)). AG ¶ 20(b) does not fully apply. Applicant was unemployed for about three months in 2023. (Tr. 21) From 2023 to present, Applicant moved three times. His spouse was in an accident, and she was unable to work outside their home for a time. These circumstances do not fully mitigate his financial issues because he did not provide specific enough information about the
Whole Person Concept
hanges in his family income to show why he had significant delinquent debt. AG ¶ 20(c) applies. Applicant received some financial counseling and generated a budget. His August 2026 CBR shows there are “clear indications that the problem is being resolved or is under control.” He has a plan to resolve the last SOR debt, and he has taken steps to effectuate that plan. AG ¶ 20(d) applies. He demonstrated a “good-faith effort to repay overdue creditors or otherwise resolve debts.” AG ¶ 20(e) does not apply. Applicant described the background of the SOR ¶ 1.b debt. He admits responsibility for the debt, and he is willing to pay it once the creditor advises him of the amount owed. Applicant made sufficient progress resolving his delinquent debts. He has several paid or current accounts listed in his CBRs. He received some financial counseling, and he has made enough progress resolving his delinquent debts to show his good faith. 7
There are clear indications that his financial problem is being resolved, and his finances are under control. Future financial problems are unlikely to occur. AG ¶¶ 20(c) and 20(d) are established, and financial considerations security concerns are mitigated. Whole-Person Concept Under the whole-person concept, the administrative judge must evaluate an applicant’s eligibility for a security clearance by considering the totality of the applicant’s conduct and all the circumstances. The administrative judge should consider the nine adjudicative process factors listed at AG ¶ 2(d): (1) the nature, extent, and seriousness of the conduct; (2) the circumstances surrounding the conduct, to include knowledgeable participation; (3) the frequency and recency of the conduct; (4) the individual’s age and maturity at the time of the conduct; (5) the extent to which participation is voluntary; (6) the presence or absence of rehabilitation and other permanent behavioral changes; (7) the motivation for the conduct; (8) the potential for pressure, coercion, exploitation, or duress; and (9) the likelihood of continuation or recurrence. Under AG ¶ 2(c), “[t]he ultimate determination” of whether to grant a security clearance “must be an overall commonsense judgment based upon careful consideration of the guidelines” and the whole-person concept. My comments under Guideline F are incorporated in my whole-person analysis. Some of the factors in AG ¶ 2(d) were addressed under that guideline but some warrant additional comment. Applicant is a 34-year-old strength and conditioning coach for a government contractor. He has held this position for 18 months. In 2010, he graduated from high school. In 2017, he received a bachelor’s degree, and he majored in kinesiology, and in 2021, he received a master’s degree in kinesiology. There is no evidence of adverse employment or security issues. The evidence supporting approval of Applicant’s security clearance is detailed in the financial considerations section, supra, and this evidence is more persuasive than the evidence against mitigation. Applicant’s CBRs show a history of paying most of his delinquent debts and financial improvement. He recently paid one of the two SOR debts, and he has promised to pay the remaining SOR debt. The Appeal Board has addressed a key element in the whole-person analysis in financial cases stating: . . . the concept of meaningful track record necessarily includes evidence of actual debt reduction through payment of debts. However, an applicant is not required, as a matter of law, to establish that he has paid off each and every debt listed in the SOR. All that is required is that an applicant 8
demonstrate that he has . . . established a plan to resolve his financial problems and taken significant actions to implement that plan. The Judge can reasonably consider the entirety of an applicant’s financial situation and his actions in evaluating the extent to which that applicant’s plan for the reduction of his outstanding indebtedness is credible and realistic. See Directive ¶ E2.2(a) (Available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable, should be considered in reaching a determination.) There is no requirement that a plan provide f or payments on all outstanding debts simultaneously. Rather, a reasonable plan (and concomitant conduct) may provide for the payment of such debts one at a time. Likewise, there is no requirement that the first debts actually paid in furtherance of a reasonable debt plan be the ones liste
Formal Findings
in the SOR. ISCR Case No. 07-06482 at 2-3 (App. Bd. May 21, 2008) (internal citations and quotation marks omitted). Applicant’s actions show financial responsibility and judgment, and he has established his reliability, trustworthiness, and ability to protect classified information. See AG ¶ 18. It is well settled that once a concern arises regarding an applicant’s security clearance eligibility, there is a strong presumption against granting a security clearance. See Dorfmont, 913 F.2d at 1401. “[A] favorable clearance decision means that the record discloses no basis for doubt about an applicant’s eligibility for access to classified information.” ISCR Case No. 18-02085 at 7 (App. Bd. Jan. 3, 2020) (citing ISCR Case No.12-00270 at 3 (App. Bd. Jan. 17, 2014)). I have carefully applied the law, as set forth in Egan, Dorfmont, Exec. Or. 10865, the Directive, the AGs, and the Appeal Board’s jurisprudence to the facts and circumstances in the context of the whole person. Applicant mitigated financial considerations security concerns. Applicant is a
Conclusion
vised that the government can evaluate his finances at any time and revoke his security clearance if he fails to establish and maintain his financial responsibility. Formal Findings Formal findings For or Against Applicant on the allegations set forth in the SOR, as required by Section E3.1.25 of Enclosure 3 of the Directive, are: Paragraph 1, Guideline F: FOR APPLICANT Subparagraphs 1.a and 1.b: For Applicant 9
_____________________ Conclusion I conclude that it is clearly consistent with the interests of national security of the United States to grant or continue Applicant’s national security eligibility for access to classified information. Eligibility for access to classified information is granted. Mark Harvey Administrative Judge 10