Skip to content
← Back to results

A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.

ISCR Case No. 24-00855

Appeal Board

Decided Oct 22, 2026 · Administrative Judge Moira D. Modzelewski · Appeal

Appeal at a glance

The appeal involved a denial of security clearance based on personal conduct and financial considerations. The applicant raised several arguments, including estoppel and challenges to factual findings. The Board affirmed the Administrative Judge's decision, finding no harmful error in the denial of clearance.

Descriptive structured reading of this decided, public Appeal Board decision: what the case says, not a prediction or advice.

Full decision

Open original PDF

The complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.

Decision text, by section

Appearances

FOR GOVERNMENT Andrea M. Corrales, Deputy Chief Department Counsel

Appearances

Samir Nakhleh, Esq. The Department of Defense (DoD) declined to grant Applicant a security clearance. On September 17, 2024, DoD issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR) advising Applicant of the basis of that decision – security concerns raised under Guideline E (Personal Conduct) and Guideline F (Financial Considerations) of the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (AG) in Appendix A of Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (effective June 8, 2017) and DoD Directive 5220.6 (Jan. 2, 1992, as amended) (Directive). On August 27, 2026, Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals Administrative Judge Charles C. Hale denied Applicant national security eligibility. Applicant appealed pursuant to Directive ¶¶ E3.1.28 and E3.1.30. Background Applicant, in her early thirties, graduated from high school in 2010 and has taken college- level classes, but she has not attained a degree. She married and divorced three times, and she has one minor child. Applicant was granted a top secret clearance with access to sensitive compartmented information in December 2021, and she seeks national security eligibility for her employment with a government contractor, for whom she has worked since June 2023.

The SOR alleged seven personal conduct security concerns arising from five employment terminations and unemployment benefits fraud, and four financial considerations security concerns triggered by a bankruptcy, two delinquent accounts, and the aforementioned fraud. The Judge found favorably for Applicant on five of the Guideline E concerns, but he found adversely on one of the employment terminations and on the unemployment benefits fraud. Under Guideline F, the Judge found adversely to Applicant on the allegation related to her unemployment benefits fraud and favorably on the other three allegations. The findings of fact and analysis summarized below pertain solely to the adverse findings. Benefits Fraud (SOR ¶¶ 1.g, 2.d) In June 2017, while she was unemployed, Applicant filed for unemployment benefits with her state’s Department of Labor (SDL), at which time she was informed of both the requirements to remain eligible and her mandatory weekly reporting obligations. Applicant was later employed by Company B and earned income from July 30, 2017 until mid-August 2017 and from September 11, 2017 until February 2018; however, she continued to claim unemployment benefits during these periods. Government Exhibit (GE) 5 at 2-3, 9-10. The SDL subsequently determined that Applicant “fraudulently did not report any of the income she received” during those 15 weeks “and was therefore ineligible for the benefits received.” Id. at 4. Including fraud penalty, fraud interest, and costs, the SDL calculated that Applicant owed approximately $9,279 as of October 2021. Id. at 6. In November 2021, the SDL and Applicant agreed to settle this debt for approximately $8,779, with monthly payments beginning in March 2022. Id. at 27-28. On September 27, 2024, she paid $4,000 to SDL to resolve this debt. Applicant Exhibit (AE) A. At the hearing, Applicant testified that she visited an SDL office in person once in October 2017 to attempt to resolve the matter and made additional attempts by phone or through the online portal. Transcript (Tr.) at 31-35. Although Applicant testified that she had made an unspecified number of $30 payments prior to October 2021 and that she “started paying” $100 monthly payments following the settlement agreement, she provided no further information or corroborating evidence as to the number and timing of payments. Id. at 43. The Judge found this debt resolved after the issuance of the SOR. Employment Termination (SOR ¶ 1.b) In May 2019, Applicant was terminated from employment at Company S for violation of company policies and insubordination, including that she “failed to follow company policy and procedures for attendance, tardiness, absences, and call-out procedures by neglecting to notify management” and “failed to comply with her previous warning which revoked her telework privileges.” GE 7 at 1. On her 2021 security clearance application, Applicant reported that she left Company S because the “position was a temporary six month contract,” and she asserted that she had not been fired or received any discipline or warnings. GE 2 at 21. In her August 2024 response to interrogatories, she denied that she had been terminated from any employer for misconduct or violation of company policy. GE 9 at 59. In her Answer, however, Applicant admitted the allegation about receiving prior warnings at Company S and her ultimate termination, and she attributed her conduct to domestic violence, the resulting divorce, and her chronic medical 2

condition. At the hearing, when questioned why she did not disclose her termination from Company S in response to the interrogatories, Applicant responded, “That was a massive oversight on my part and I should, again, I should have taken the extra two seconds because that should never have been a blip on the map so to speak.” Tr. at 119. Judge’s Analysis The Judge noted Applicant’s traumatic experiences and chronic medical condition and their impact on her employment, terminations, and delinquent accounts. Decision at 14. Within the Guideline F analysis, the Judge concluded that none of the mitigating conditions1 applied to SOR ¶ 2.d, noting the debt was incurred by fraud, Applicant continues to deny the fraud, and her actions to resolve the debt occurred following the issuance of the SOR. Id. Under the Guideline E analysis, the Judge concluded that AG ¶¶ 17(c), 17(d), and 17(e)2 were not established as to SOR ¶¶ 1.b. and 1.g due to Applicant’s repeated omissions and misrepresentations about her termination and her continued denial of fraud: Given [the] clear and unambiguous statement in the May 14, 2019 Employee Warning Notice and the thoroughness with which Applicant went through the summary of [the security] interview, in August 2024, her claim of an “oversight” was not credible. She recently failed to disclose the circumstances involving this employment on multiple occasions during the security clearance process. Similarly, she continues to dispute the SDL fraud findings, despite negotiating for a reduced amount to the fraud total. Her unwillingness to acknowledge her behavior during this employment period and for committing employment benefit fraud cast[s] doubt on her reliability, trustworthiness, and good judgment. Id. at 19. Within the Whole-Person analysis, the Judge noted Applicant’s favorable reference letters and “recent employment success.” Id. He concluded the lingering concerns of Applicant’s refusal to admit fraud and of her omissions and misrepresentations about her termination outweighed the favorable character evidence and debt resolution efforts. Id. at 19-20. 1 AG ¶¶ 20(a): the behavior happened so long ago, was so infrequent, or occurred under such circumstances that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the individual’s current reliability, trustworthiness, or good judgment; 20(b): the conditions that resulted in the financial problem were largely beyond the person’s control (e.g., loss of employment, a business downturn, unexpected medical emergency, a death, divorce or separation, clear victimization by predatory lending practices, or identity theft), and the individual acted responsibly under the circumstances; 20(c): the individual has received or is receiving financial counseling for the problem from a legitimate and credible source, such as a non-profit credit counseling service, and there are clear indications that the problem is being resolved or is under control; and 20(d): the individual initiated and is adhering to a good-faith effort to repay overdue creditors or otherwise resolve debts. 2 AG ¶¶ 17(c): the offense is so minor, or so much time has passed, or the behavior is so infrequent, or it happened under such unique circumstances that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the individual’s reliability, trustworthiness, or good judgment; 17(d): the individual has acknowledged the behavior and obtained counseling to change the behavior or taken other positive steps to alleviate the stressors, circumstances, or factors that contributed to untrustworthy, unreliable, or other inappropriate behavior, and such behavior is unlikely to recur; and 17(e): the individual has taken positive steps to reduce or eliminate vulnerability to exploitation, manipulation, or duress. 3

Discussion On appeal, Applicant raises an estoppel argument, challenges one of the Judge’s findings of fact, and argues for an alternative interpretation or weighing of the record evidence. For the following reasons, Applicant’s arguments are not persuasive, and we affirm the Judge’s decision. Beginning with the estoppel argument, Applicant contends that she received an earlier SOR in 2023 that alleged the same issues, that those issues were favorably adjudicated, and that the Government is precluded from re-adjudicating her clearance eligibility based on identical information. Applicant’s argument is unpersuasive. Applicant was most recently granted Top Secret eligibility in December 2021 based upon a background investigation concluded in October 2021. GE 15 at 1, 3. Although she received an SOR in 2023, the adjudication did not reach a final determination as to her clearance eligibility. Id.; Tr. at 66. Therefore, the matters realleged from the 2023 SOR have not been previously adjudicated. See ISCR Case No. 12-04540, 2014 WL 1400916 at *3 (App. Bd. Mar. 19, 2014) (res judicata may only attach if previous adjudication attained finality and relied on same investigation). Turning next to the challenged finding of fact, the Judge found that Applicant settled the SDL debt (SOR ¶¶ 1.g, 2.d) in November 2021, agreeing to monthly payments beginning in March 2022, and that she paid $4,000 on September 27, 2024, to resolve the debt. The Judge considered the timing of Applicant’s post-SOR resolution of this debt as part of his conclusion that AG ¶ 20(d) did not apply. On appeal, Applicant argues that the Judge failed to consider her pre-SOR debt resolution efforts, citing only her uncorroborated testimony about $30 payments prior to the 2021 settlement agreement and $100 payments in accordance with the settlement. The record evidence is devoid of any specificity as to the number and timing of these purported payments, and the Judge found Applicant’s testimony not credible given her fraudulent conduct, omissions, and misrepresentations, as recently as the August 2024 response to interrogatories. The Judge was not required to accept Applicant’s unrebutted testimony. See DISCR Case No. 90-2069 at 10 (App. Bd. Mar. 25, 1992). The Judge’s finding of fact is supported by substantial record evidence. Applicant’s several remaining arguments on appeal re-state and reweigh the evidence in mitigation, all of which was explicitly and exhaustively discussed in the Judge’s findings and analyses. Applicant’s disagreement with the Judge’s characterizations and weighing of the evidence is not sufficient to demonstrate that the decision was arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law. See ISCR Case No. 04-08975, 2006 WL 2725032 at *1 (App. Bd. Aug. 4, 2006). Conclusion Applicant has not established that the Judge’s conclusions were arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law. The Judge examined the relevant evidence, weighed the disqualifying and mitigating conditions, and articulated a satisfactory explanation for the decision. The record is sufficient to support that the Judge’s findings and conclusions are sustainable. “The general standard is that a clearance may be granted only when ‘clearly consistent with the interests of the national security.’” Dep’t of the Navy v. Egan, 484 U.S. 518, 528 (1988). “Any doubt concerning personnel being considered for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.” AG ¶ 2(b). 4

Order The decision in ISCR Case No. 24-00855 is AFFIRMED. Signed: Moira Modzelewski Moira Modzelewski Administrative Judge Chair, Appeal Board Signed: Allison Marie Allison Marie Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board Signed: Eric H. Borgstrom Eric H. Borgstrom Administrative Judge Member, Appeal Board 5