Guideline E: Personal Conduct
What is Guideline E, Personal Conduct, and how do those cases end?
Basis: 8,602 decided hearing-level ISCR cases raising Guideline E. Descriptive history of decided cases, not a prediction.
Decided hearing cases
8,602
Ruled for the applicant on this guideline
37%
3,149 for · 5,248 against · 112 not recorded
Whole case granted
23%
1,987 granted · 6,615 denied
The first percentage is the judge's formal finding on Guideline E itself. The second is how the whole case ended, and a case can be denied on a different guideline: in 1,205 of the 6,615 denied cases (18%), the judge had ruled for the applicant on Guideline E. A granted case counts as a ruling for the applicant. The 112 cases with no ruling recorded were all denied, and they stay in the first percentage's base so that it is not flattered. 93 cases in which the concern was withdrawn are left out of it.
Specific issues and how the cases alleging them ended
Falsified the security form
10% granted · 307 granted · 2,770 denied
Personal conduct (unspecified)
26% granted · 781 granted · 2,179 denied
Omission / failure to disclose
26% granted · 692 granted · 1,950 denied
Lack of candor in an interview
11% granted · 170 granted · 1,409 denied
Questionable judgment
24% granted · 348 granted · 1,075 denied
Workplace rules violation
20% granted · 151 granted · 611 denied
Each bar counts the outcome of the whole case in which the issue was alleged, not the judge's ruling on that issue. A case that raised the issue and was denied on a different ground counts as denied here.
Mitigations judges credited most
- Promptly corrected the falsification84
- Acknowledgment & remorse73
- Credible explanation of omission41
- Passage of time20
- Rehabilitation evidence19
Counted only where the judge expressly credited the mitigation, not merely where it was claimed.
What the reference material says about personal-conduct cases
- The recurring theme across the practitioner literature: the concealment routinely weighs more heavily than the underlying conduct. Prompt, self-initiated correction of the record before confrontation is a recognized mitigating condition. (Practitioner sources; SEAD-4 mitigating conditions)
From our verified reference library: paraphrased from the named sources and reviewed before publication. Descriptive background, not legal advice about any case.
How the process worksA contested case follows a published sequence. Open this for the short version, or put a question to Ask Mode on the home page. Accounts are free and include up to 25 questions per day.
A contested case follows a published path: a Statement of Reasons, the government's written list of its concerns (an SOR), a written answer, a hearing or a decision on the written record, the judge's decision, and in some cases an appeal.
Read the stages of a DOHA case · Ask a question about the process
Where to go from here
Get help with my case
Send us your question, or the Statement of Reasons you received. No charge, and a CASE analyst reads it. Usually five to ten business days.
Ask a question →I do this for clients
Rank every decision by how closely it matches a matter, see how the assigned judge has ruled, and keep it together with cited exports.
For attorneys and firms →Descriptive statistics from decided public DOHA cases. Not legal advice or a prediction. † marks samples under 20 cases.