Skip to content
← Back to results

A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.

ISCR Case No. 25-00228

Denied

Decided Oct 27, 2026 · Administrative Judge Wilford H. Ross · Hearing

Case headnote

Summary

The applicant, a 45-year-old male with a military background, sought security clearance but faced concerns under Guidelines D, E, F, and J due to a history of criminal conduct and personal behavior. The judge found that the applicant did not mitigate the concerns under Guidelines E and J, while he did mitigate those under Guidelines D and F, ultimately denying his eligibility for access to classified information.

Why the applicant was denied

  • The applicant did not mitigate security concerns under Guideline E (Personal Conduct).
  • The applicant did not mitigate security concerns under Guideline J (Criminal Conduct).

Conditions referenced

Disqualifying

  • E2.a Personal Conductraised
  • J1 Criminal Conductraised

Mitigating

  • D2 Sexual Behaviorapplied
  • F2 Financial Considerationsapplied

Key rule quoted

Procedural posture

SOR issued
03/21/2025
Answer filed
04/18/2025
Hearing held
01/26/2026 via Microsoft TEAMS
Decision date
10/27/2026

Cite for

  • Denial of Security Clearance Due to Unresolved Personal Conduct Issues Under Guideline E
  • Denial of Security Clearance Based on Criminal Conduct Under Guideline J
  • Mitigation of Financial Concerns Under Guideline F Despite Past Debts

Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.

From the decision

Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.

Applicant Age
45
Clearance Level
secret
Prior Clearance
held
Delinquent Usd
26484
Payment Plan
yes
Bankruptcy
none

Allegations under Guideline D

Reading the 1 per allegation row needs a free account.

1 row in this decision.

It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.

Allegations under Guideline E

Reading the 4 per allegation rows needs a free account.

4 rows in this decision.

It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.

Allegations under Guideline F

Reading the 2 per allegation rows needs a free account.

2 rows in this decision.

It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.

Allegations under Guideline J

Reading the 1 per allegation row needs a free account.

1 row in this decision.

It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.

Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.

Full decision

Open original PDF

The complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.

Decision text, by section

Appearances

________ ______________ DEFENSE LEGAL SERVICES AGENCY DEFENSE OFFIC

Decision

E OF HEARINGS AND APPEALS In the matter of: ) ) ) ISCR Case No. 25-00228 ) Applicant for Security Clearance ) Appearances For Government: John B. Renehan, Esquire, Department Counsel For Applicant: Pro se 10/27/2026 Decision ROSS, Wilford H., Administrative Judge: Applicant did not mitigate the security conc

Statement of Case

erns under Guidelines E (Personal Conduct) and J (Criminal Conduct). He mitigated the security concerns under Guidelines D (Sexual Behavior) and F (Financial Considerations). Eligibility for access to classified information is denied. Statement of the Case On March 21, 2025, the Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency (DCSA) issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR1) to Applicant detailing security concerns under Guideline E (SOR 1.a through 1.i). The action was taken under Executive Order (EO) 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry (February 20, 1960), as amended; DOD Directive 5220.6, Defense Industrial Personnel Security Clearance Review Program (January 2, 1992), as amended (Directive); and the adjudicative guidelines (AG) implemented by the DOD on June 8, 2017. Applicant responded to SOR1 in writing (Answer1) on April 18, 2025, and requested a hearing before an administrative judge.

The Government issued a second SOR (SOR2) to Applicant on June 12, 2025. SOR2 contained additional allegations under Guideline E (SOR 1.j through 1.m). SOR 2 also included allegations under Guideline J (SOR 2.a), Guideline D (SOR 3.a), and Guideline F (SOR 4.a and 4.b). Applicant submitted an Answer (Answer2) to the additional SOR allegations on June 27, 2025. Department Counsel was prepared to proceed on August 19, 2025. The case was assigned to me on August 27, 2025. The D

Findings of Fact

efense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA) issued an initial Notice of Microsoft TEAMS Video Teleconference Hearing on November 20, 2025. I convened the hearing as scheduled on January 26, 2026. The Government offered Government Exhibits 1 through 18, which were admitted into evidence without objection. Applicant testified on his own behalf and submitted Applicant Exhibits A through D, which were admitted into evidence without objection. The hearing was continued at the request of both parties in order to obtain additional evidence. The transcript of this hearing (Tr.1) was received on February 9, 2026. A status conference was held on July 15, 2026, in order to resolve scheduling issues. A final hearing was set at the status conference for August 10, 2026. The transcript of this hearing (Tr.2) was received July 27, 2026. The continued hearing was reopened on August 10, 2026. The Government submitted Government Exhibits 19 through 22, which were admitted into evidence without objection. Applicant testified on his own behalf and called two additional witnesses. He also submitted Applicant Exhibits E through L, which were also admitted into evidence without objection. At the end of the hearing Applicant requested that the record remain open for the receipt of additional documentation. He submitted in a timely fashion Applicant Exhibits M through W, which were admitted into evidence without objection. (These exhibits will be further identified when cited in the Decision.) DOHA received the transcript of this hearing (Tr.3) on August 24, 2026. The record closed on August 24, 2026. The hearing and decision were delayed when all administrative judges were furloughed from October 1 through November 12, 2025, during a Federal government shutdown due to a lapse in federal funding. Findings of Fact Applicant is 45 years old, divorced, and has two children. He currently lives with his fiancée. He has a bachelor’s degree and a master’s degree. Applicant served in the United States Marine Corps (USMC) from 2003 through 2014, where he held a Secret clearance. He received an Honorable Discharge. He does not currently work in the defense industry, but is being sponsored for national security eligibility by a proposed employer. As described below, he started work for a municipal government (City One) on July 20, 2026, as an IT Support Technician. (Government Exhibit 1 at Sections 12, 13A, 2

15, 17, 18, and 25, Exhibit 2 at 22-23; Applicant Exhibits C, M (transcript confirming awarding of master’s degree), and V (City One employment verification letter); Tr.3 at 27.) Paragraph 1 (Guideline E, Personal Conduct) The Government alleged in this paragraph of the SOR that Applicant is ineligible for clearance because he has engaged in actions that involve questionable judgment, lack of candor, dishonesty, and unwillingness to comply with rules and regulations. For ease of discussion, the allegations will be discussed in chronological order. This is different than the order set forth in the SOR. 1.m. Applicant admitted that he had been arrested on February 8, 2000, and charged with shoplifting and altering the price of merchandise (under $200). On or about March 20, 2000, he pleaded guilty. (Government Exhibit 2 at 13, Exhibit 3 at 3-4, Exhibit 4 at 13, and Exhibit 5 at 2.) Applicant stated in Answer2, “I was a teenager at the time and made a poor choice influenced by peers. I accepted full responsibility and learned from the experience. I have not repeated any similar conduct in over two decades.” (Applicant Exhibit A; Tr.3 at 65.) 1.l. Applicant admitted that he had been arrested on January 30, 2002, and charged with assault and battery on a family member. The charge was dismissed by the District Attorney on April 17, 2002. (Government Exhibit 2 at 9, Exhibit 4 at 12, Exhibit 5 at 2.) Applicant stated in Answer2 that this incident was a verbal argument with his then spouse. “There were no injuries or repeated incidents. This occurred over 20 years ago and has no bearing on my conduct since.” Applicant stated that this incident occurred because he found evidence of his then wife’s infidelity. (Government Exhibit 3; T r.3 at 63- 65.) 1.k. Applicant admitted that he was investigated by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS) for domestic violence o n or about March 27, 2005. He was ordered by his command to receive counseling at the base Community Counseling Center (CCC). (Government Exhibit 2 at 7-8, Exhibit 4 at 7-8, Exhibit 16; Tr.3 at 55-63.) (Government Exhibit 2 c ontains the wrong dates for this allegation and 1.j.) 1.j. Applicant admitted that he was again investigated by his command and the NCIS for domestic violence on June 28, 2005. The military police report indicates that Applicant was investigated for riot or breech of peace after a verbal altercation with his ex-wife. Applicant was accompanied by a fellow Marine on this occasion. He was formally

Policies

counseled by his commanding officer and ordered to continue classes at the base CCC. 3

Government Exhibit 15 shows that his ex-wife later recanted her allegation of domestic violence. (Answer2, Government Exhibit 1 at 44, Exhibit 2 at 7, 13-14, and Exhibit 15; Tr.3 at 55-63.) 1.i. Applicant admitted that he was arrested and charged with driving under the influence on F ebruary 26, 2011. He pl

eaded guilty on A pril 7, 2011, and w

as awarded fines, unsupervised probation, and five days of confinement. He also received nonjudicial punishment from the USMC that included a reduction in rank and suspended pay forfeitures. Applicant stated in Answer1, “I completed all penalties and corrective actions required and have remained free from alcohol-related incidents since then.” (Government Exhibit 1 at 43, 47, Exhibit 2 at 7, 10-11, 16, Exhibit 4 at 13-14, Exhibit 5 at 2, and Exhibit 14; Applicant Exhibit A; Tr.3 at 49-55.) After the hearing Applicant submitted a “Clarification Regarding Pre-2011 Matters and Prior Security Clearance.” (Applicant Exhibit O.) That statement has been considered. 1.h. Applicant admitted that he was arrested on March 21, 2014, for speeding, driving under the influence, open container, and carrying a concealed weapon. He pleaded guilty on February 23, 2016, to the open container and weapons charge. He received a sentence that included jail time, a fine, and six months’ probation. (Government Exhibit 2 at 11-12, 16, Exhibit 4 at 21-24, Exhibit 13; Applicant Exhibit A.) Applicant stated in Answer1, “These charges stemmed from personal struggles at the time, and I accepted responsibility, completed required corrective measures, and significantly improved my personal decision-making.” (Tr.3 at 39-46.) Applicant has not used alcohol since approximately August 2022. (Government Exhibit 2 at 16; Tr.3 at 46-49.) 1.g. Applicant admitted that he was arrested on June 21, 2014, and charged with assault on a female. The charges were dismissed by the court on or about December 10, 2014. Applicant stated in Answer1 that the dismissal meant there was no finding of guilt or wrongdoing. He told a government investigator that police came to his house due to a verbal argument with his ex-wife. He denied that he had assaulted her on that or any other time. (Government Exhibit 2 at 10, 1

Analysis

2, Exhibit 4 at 25, Exhibit 12 at 1; Tr.3 at 36- 39.) 1.f. Applicant admitted that he was arrested on or about November 7, 2014, and charged with misdemeanor larceny and conspiracy to commit felony larceny. He pleaded 4

guilty to misdemeanor larceny on May 28, 2015, in accordance with a plea agreement. (Government Exhibit 4 at 25-29, Exhibit 12 at 2-3; Applicant Exhibit A.) Applicant stated in Answer1 that the thefts were actually committed by his roommate. He stated, “I was implicated due to association and accepted responsibility as part of a plea agreement. The incident occurred over a decade ago, and I have since demonstrated consistent positive behavior, employment stability, and educational advancement.” (Government Exhibit 1 at 41, Exhibit 2 at 6-7, 9, 12; Tr.3 at 33-36.) 1.e. Applicant admitted that he was arrested on December 16, 2018, and charged with brandishing a firearm, reckless handling of a firearm, and discharging a firearm in a public place. This incident involved an altercation between Applicant and the boyfriend of his former wife. Applicant responded to being shot at by the boyfriend by firing a warning shot himself. He was arrested by police and was acquitted after a jury trial. Applicant stated in Answer1, “I admit the arrest occurred but emphasize that I was acquitted by a jury on or about March 18, 2019. Since then, I have undergone responsible firearm training and committed myself to safe firearm handling practices.” (Government Exhibit 1 at 34, Exhibit 2 at 3-4, Exhibit 4 at 14-15, Exhibit 5 at 2-3, Exhibit 11; Applicant Exhibit A; Tr.3 at 96.) 1.d. Applicant denied t he allegations under this paragraph t hat he was arrested on May 1, 2019, for sexually assaulting a child under the age of 13. The allegation f urther states that the grand jury indicted him for sodomy and rape of a victim under age 13. Applicant was acquitted by a jury on or about November 2, 2020. Applicant states in Answer1, “I deny this allegation completely. I was falsely accused, and a jury fully acquitted me on or about November 2, 2020. This acquittal affirms my innocence regarding this matter.” (Government Exhibit 1 at 40-41; Exhibit 2 at 5-6, 9-11, Exhibit 4 at 15-17, Exhibit 5 at 3-4; TR.1 at 80-92.) During his testimony Applicant stated, “I’m not here today to minimize you know the seriousness of what was alleged, but I deny it to the fullest extent and I ask the Court to weigh out reliability and not just the seriousness of these statements.” (Tr.3 at 87.) Applicant was accused of molesting one of his daughters (D One). The police investigated Applicant and he was eventually charged with the offenses set forth in the SOR. Applicant stated evidence was shown at the trial proving his ex-wife and her family had persuaded his children to invent the incident. (Government Exhibit 9, Exhibit 10, Exhibits 19, 20, 21, and 22; Tr.1 at 90-92; Tr.3 at 83-111.) Government Exhibit 21 are three Defendant (Applicant) exhibits from the trial. Pages 1 to 3 are identified as “Exhibit Defendant No. 1” and consist of what appears to 5

be undated journal entries from D One who was the alleged victim. On page 3 she writes, “Summer ’19 he put his hands on me in the most inappropriate way.” The exhibit does not identify who “he” is, but a reasonable assumption is that the person is Applicant. Applicant denies engaging in this conduct, (Tr.3 at 98-100.) Page 4 of Government Exhibit 21 is identified as “Exhibit Defendant No. 2” and consists of what appears to be a social media post from Applicant’s other daughter (D Two). The post is dated August 17, 2019. D Two is the one who originally told police about the alleged rapes of D One. She wrote, “She [D One] didn’t always have the sick mind set she had but its [sic] what we grew up with so we fit in just 2 months ago she was raped by our own dad.” Once again, Applicant denies engaging in this conduct. (Tr. 3 at 100-104.) Government Exhibit 22 are medical records of Applicant, his ex-wife, and D One. D One was examined on July 8, 2019. As part of the patient history an abuse screen was taken. It states at page 14 of the exhibit, “Patient verbally denies physical, verbal and emotional abuse/neglect.” She was diagnosed on this visit with acute vaginitis and/or a yeast infection. Her hymen was intact. Blood tests of Applicant, his wife, and D One were also conducted. (Government Exhibit 22 at 25-35; Tr.3 at 104-110.) Applicant testified that he believed this false allegation was related to his ex-wife, her family, and her boyfriend trying to end Applicant’s visitation rights with his daughters. He alleged that the firearm incident discussed above under SOR 1.e was also part of this campaign. (Tr.1 at 83-84.) He concluded his testimony on this issue: I understand that all of this is very serious accusations. I’m not trying to minimize any of it. My testimony does remain solid that I deny of this conduct that was described. I never touched any of my daughters in an inappropriate way. Never violated them in any inappropriate way. I understand that the DOHA can still consider the underlying allegations, but I ask the Court to just weigh the full gravity of this entire situation. The family conflict, the medical records, the reliability issues. (Tr.3 at 110-111.) SOR allegations 1.a and 1.b are also connected to SOR 1.d. 1.c. Applicant admitted that he was arrested on or about December 5, 2019, and charged with possession of marijuana (up to one half once), possession of drug paraphernalia, and carrying a concealed weapon. The charges were dismissed on or about February 27, 2020, under the condition that the marijuana, paraphernalia, and 6

weapon were destroyed. This was during the period between his indictment and his trial. (Government Exhibit 4 at 29-31, Exhibit 7, Exhibit 8; Applicant Exhibit A.) Applicant stated in Answer1, “I admit the arrest occurred; however, the charges of possession of marijuana and concealed firearm were dismissed without conviction or penalties. The firearm was legally owned and properly stored in my personal RV residence. The marijuana was present at the gathering but I had no involvement. I have since maintained careful discretion regarding my social interactions.” (Tr.1 at 60-80.) Additional evidence indicates that there were actually two incidents involving Applicant and the police in the December 2019 time frame. He was only arrested once on December 5, 2019. (Government Exhibit 1 at 37-39, Exhibit 2 at 5, 8; Applicant Exhibit J; Tr.1 at 77-80; Tr.3 at 118-121.) 1.b. Applicant denied the allegations in this subparagraph that he was arrested on or about May 14, 2020, and charged with flight escape – fugitive from justice. The charges were later dismissed. Applicant stated in Answer1 that this arrest is directly related to the incident set forth in subparagraph 1.a, below. He further stated that the dismissal had no finding of wrongdoing. (Government Exhibit 2 at 5-6, 8, 12, Exhibit 4 at 11, and Exhibit 6; Applicant Exhibit A; Tr.1 at 92-101.) 1.a. Applicant denied the allegation that he was arrested on or about May 12, 2020, and charged with flight to avoid – fugitive from justice (1st degree). The charges were later dismissed. Applicant stated in Answer1, “The incident arose from a misunderstanding regarding my status in another jurisdiction, and no intent to evade justice was present.” After being questioned by police regarding the alleged sexual assault on his daughter under SOR 1.d Applicant felt it was in his best interest to leave the town and state he lived in. He stated that he did not know there was an arrest warrant out for him. He was arrested by police in a different state on a fugitive warrant and held in jail until he could be transported back to his hometown for trial. (Government Exhibit 2 at 5-6, 8, 12, Exhibit 4 at 11, and Exhibit 6; Applicant Exhibit A; Tr. 1 at 92-101.) In addition to the alleged arrests set forth in the SOR Applicant had additional contact with law enforcement. In approximately May 2017 he was arrested for possession of marijuana and open container of alcohol in vehicle. According to Applicant the marijuana and alcohol were actually in the possession of his friend. Applicant went to court where the marijuana charge was dismissed and he paid a fine for the open container offense. (Government Exhibit 1 at 35, Exhibit 2 at 4.) 7

Paragraph 2 (Guideline J, Criminal Conduct) The Government alleges in this paragraph that Applicant is ineligible for clearance because he has engaged in criminal conduct that creates doubt about a person’s judgment, reliability, and trustworthiness. Applicant admitted with an explanation the single allegation under this paragraph, which stated that the facts set forth under Paragraph 1, above, are cognizable under this guideline as well. In Answer2 he stated, “I acknowledge the factual history cited in Paragraph 1. I have accepted responsibility for all youthful and early adult misjudgments. There is no pattern of ongoing criminal behavior. My conduct over the last several years, including military service, education, and steady employment, reflects my growth and reliability.” Applicant was asked to discuss whether his criminal history shows a pattern. With regard to the Guideline E and Guideline J allegations, with the exception of SOR 1.a, 1.b, and 1.d, he argued that many of the allegations were old, several involved his toxic marriage, and others were not substantiated, the charges were dismissed, or he was acquitted. (Tr.3 113-116.) Paragraph 3 (Guideline D, Sexual Behavior) The Government alleged in this paragraph of the SOR that Applicant is ineligible for clearance because he has engaged in sexual behavior that involves a criminal offense; reflects a lack of judgment or discretion; or may subject the Applicant to undue influence, coercion, exploitation, or duress. Applicant denied the single allegation under this paragraph, which stated that the facts set forth under Subparagraph 1.d, above, are cognizable under this guideline as

Whole Person Concept

well. In Answer2 he stated, “I was falsely accused, arrested, and subsequently acquitted by a jury in 2020. The accusation was weaponized during a contentious custody dispute. I have no history of inappropriate sexual conduct.” Paragraph 4 (Guideline F, Financial Considerations) The Government alleges in this paragraph that Applicant is ineligible for clearance because he is financially overextended and therefore potentially unreliable, untrustworthy, or at risk of having to engage in illegal acts to generate funds. Applicant denied both the allegations in this paragraph. 8

Based on the available documentary evidence Applicant is alleged to owe approximately $33,493 in past-due child support payments and a charged-off automobile debt. The Government provided credit reports of Applicant dated June 12, 2024; and February 19, 2025, supporting the existence of the debts. (Government Exhibits 17 and 18.) The debts are also supported by his admissions to an authorized investigator from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) during an interview on November 14, 2023. (Government Exhibit 2 at 16-17.) The current status of the debts alleged in the SOR is as follows: 4.a. Applicant admits that he owes child support arrearages in the amount of approximately $26,484. The allegation in the SOR referred to t he wrong state. That has been corrected and Applica

Formal Findings

nt submitted documentation showing that he is actually paying the arrearage to the proper state through garnishment of his wages. He also submitted documentation showing that he had made voluntary payments towards his child support and arrearage when the proper state was not garnishing his pay. (Government Exhibit 2 at 16-17; Applicant Exhibit F; Tr.1 at 29-44; Tr.3 at 66-72.) 4.b. Applicant admitted that he had a charged-off automobile loan in the amount of $7,009. The car in question was repossessed in 2020 while Applicant was incarcerated as set forth in allegations 1.a and 1.b, above. Applicant was making regular loan payments through automatic deductions and b

Conclusion

elieves this repossession was unjust and possibly unlawful. He submitted documentation showing that he has filed a dispute with the Federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) that is still in progress. (Government Exhibit 2 at 16-17; Applicant Exhibit G; Tr.1 at 44-52; Tr.3 at 72-77.) Applicant is financially stable. (Tr.