A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.
ISCR Case No. 23-02237
DeniedDecided Oct 20, 2026 · Administrative Judge Bryan J. Olmos · Hearing
Case headnote
Summary
The applicant, a 60-year-old pharmacist, faced security clearance denial under Guideline A (Allegiance to the United States) and Guideline E (Personal Conduct) due to his past membership in a hate group and workplace misconduct. The judge found that the applicant did not mitigate the security concerns, particularly regarding his willingness to associate with extremist groups and his failure to disclose disciplinary actions in his security clearance application.
Why the applicant was denied
- The applicant's past membership in a hate group raised significant security concerns under Guideline A.
- The applicant failed to disclose multiple workplace reprimands in his security clearance application, violating Guideline E.
- The applicant expressed a willingness to associate with like-minded individuals from the hate group, indicating divided loyalties.
Conditions referenced
Disqualifying
- AG ¶ 2(a) Allegiance to the United Statesraised
- AG ¶ 2(c) Personal Conductraised
Key rule quoted
“The Department of War has long prohibited service members from actively engaging in extremist activities.”
Procedural posture
- SOR issued
- 08/13/2025
- Answer filed
- 09/01/2025 Requested decision based on written record.
- Hearing held
- 09/09/2026 Hearing conducted as scheduled.
- Decision date
- 10/20/2026
Cite for
- Security Concerns Related to Membership in Extremist Organizations Under Guideline A
- Failure to Disclose Workplace Reprimands Under Guideline E
- Impact of Personal Conduct on Security Clearance Eligibility
Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.
From the decision
Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.
- Applicant Age
- 60
- Bankruptcy
- none
Allegations under Guideline A
Reading the 5 per allegation rows needs a free account.
5 rows in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Allegations under Guideline E
Reading the 5 per allegation rows needs a free account.
5 rows in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.
Full decision
Open original PDFThe complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.
Decision text, by section
Decision
______________ ______________ DEFENSE LEGAL SERVICES AGENCY DEFENSE OFFICE OF HEARINGS AND A
Statement of Case
EALS In the matter of: ) ) ) ISCR Case No. 23-02237 ) Applicant for Security Clearance ) Appearances For Government: Daniel O’Reilley, Esq., Department Counsel For Applicant: Pro se 10/20/2026 Decision OLMOS, Bryan J., Administrative Judge: Applicant did not mitigate the security concerns raised under Guideline A (Allegiance to the United States) and Guideline E (Personal Conduct). Eligibility for access to classified information is denied. Statement of the Case On August 13, 2025, the Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency (DCSA) issued a Statement of Reasons (SOR) to Applicant detailing security concerns under Guideline A and Guideline E. The DCSA issued the SOR under Executive Order (Exec. Or.) 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry (February 20, 1960), as amended; Department of Defense (DOD) Directive 5220.6, Defense Industrial Personnel Security Clearance Review Program (January 2, 1992), as amended (Directive); and the Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (SEAD 4), National Security Adjudicative Guidelines (AG), effective June 8, 2017. On September 1, 2025, Applicant answered the SOR (Answer) and requested a decision based on the written record by an administrative judge from the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA), in lieu of a hearing. On November 20, 2025, Department Counsel requested a hearing in accordance with ¶ E3.1.3 of the Directive. The hearing was convened as scheduled on September 9, 2026. Department Counsel offered into evidence Government Exhibits (GX) 1-6, which were admitted without
Findings of Fact
objection. During the hearing, Department Counsel motioned to amend the SOR, revising SOR ¶ 2.d to reflect the correct date of November 2022 for the security clearance application (SCA) referenced in the allegation. Applicant did not object and the SOR was amended. Applicant testified and the record closed at the conclusion of the hearing. DOHA received the hearing transcript (Tr.) on September 16, 2026. (Tr. 17-23) Administrative Notice Department Counsel requested that I take administrative notice (AN) of certain facts about domestic violence extremists (DVEs) in the United States and about an organization that I will refer to as “Group X.” I took administrative notice as requested, without objection. Those materials are marked as Administrative Notice (AN) I-XIV. It is permissible to take administrative notice of official documents posted by federal agencies. See ISCR Case No. 99-0452 at 4 (App. Bd. Mar. 21, 2000). Official pronouncements by the President, State Department, Department of Defense, or other appropriate federal agency on matters of national security are legislative facts for purposes of DOHA adjudications and must govern a Judge’s analysis. ISCR Case No. 17-04208 at 3 (App. Bd. Aug. 7, 2019). Findings of Fact Under Guideline A, the SOR alleges that, in 2012, Applicant paid a membership fee to join a chapter of Group X located in State B (SOR ¶ 1.b), and he remained a member of that chapter into 2018 (SOR ¶ 1.a). The SOR alleges that, while he was a member, he was tasked to recruit new members to Group X in person and online (SOR ¶ 1.c) and sent two payments of $700 to the senior leader of the State B chapter of Group X after receiving threats (SOR ¶ 1.d). The SOR further alleges that, despite separating himself from Group X in 2018, Applicant expressed an ongoing willingness to associate with “like-minded” people if there was a Group X chapter closer to his residence in State C (SOR ¶ 1.e). Under Guideline E, the SOR alleges that, during unspecified dates while employed with Company 1, Applicant received verbal reprimands for making racial comments (SOR ¶ 2.a) and singing a song containing racial pejoratives in the workplace (SOR ¶ 2.c). The SOR also alleges that he received a written warning for reviewing a coworker’s employee evaluation without her permission (SOR ¶ 2.b). Further, the amended SOR alleges that he falsified material facts when he failed to disclose the reprimands he received while employed with Company 1 in his November 2022 SCA (SOR ¶ 2.d). Additionally, the Guideline A security concerns were cross alleged under Guideline E (SOR ¶ 2.e). In his Answer to the SOR, Applicant admitted SOR ¶¶ 1.a – 1.e and denied SOR ¶¶ 2.a – 2.c. His response to SOR ¶ 2.e was erroneously directed toward SOR ¶ 2.d, and it is construed as a denial of SOR ¶ 2.d. Because he omitted a response to SOR ¶ 2.e, that omission is also deemed a denial. He provided extenuating and mitigating 2
information. His admissions are incorporated into my findings of fact. After a review of the pleadings and evidence submitted, I make the following additional findings of fact. Background Applicant is 60 years old. He earned a bachelor’s degree in 1988 and a doctorate in pharmacy in 1996. He has resided at his current residence in State C since 1996. His government contracting experience includes providing pharmacy services at a military installation through Company 1 from September 2014 to January 2018, followed by service at another military installation through Company 2 between July 2018 and April 2019. He subsequently transitioned to retail pharmacy operations, serving with Company 3 from August 2019 to July 2020 and Company 4 from September 2020 to August 2023. In August 2023, he returned to government contract work with Company 5, where he currently serves as a pharmacist, supporting the same military installation he worked at while with Company 1. (GX 1, 4; Tr. 12-13, 35-36, 127-130) Involvement in Group X Applicant’s association with Group X began in about 2012, when he was about 46 years old. He described growing increasingly frustrated by news of statues and monuments commemorating the Confederacy and Confederate history being taken down around the country. He considered himself a historian and began searching online for “like-minded” people he could talk with about the “chaos” surrounding the “rewriting of history.” He described “like-minded” people as “white men with a belief system of the “Old South,” which he further defined as “an appreciation for Confederate history, white pride, and Christianity.” (GX 4-5; Tr. 28-45) While online, Applicant connected with Mr. O, who held a senior leadership position within a chapter of Group X located in State B, an adjacent state to Applicant’s residence. Applicant explained that Mr. O was the type of “like-minded” person that matched his search. The two engaged in casual conversations about news, family, and current events. Mr. O was impressed by the way Applicant spoke and wrote on social media. Despite never meeting in person, Applicant came to regard Mr. O as an “old friend.” (GX 4-5; Tr. 39-46) In 2012, Mr. O invited Applicant to formally join the Group X chapter located in State B. During his April 2023 security interview with a government investigator, Applicant stated that, prior to becoming a member, he was aware of the history of Group X as an organization and admitted to knowing about their “status as a hate group and [as] domestic terrorists.” Even with that knowledge, he thought “it would be cool” to be a member. He told the investigator that Group X “is really not a bad group” and the classifications associated with the organization are from the original members a long time ago. In April 2025, he responded to interrogatories and verified the accuracy of the investigator’s summary of his April 2023 security interview. (GX 4-5; Tr. 39-46) 3
Applicant paid a $20 membership fee to Mr. O and received clothing and regalia associated with Group X. Applicant swore an oath to the State B chapter of Group X. Although he later claimed he could not recall the content of the oath, during his April 2023 security interview, he compared it to a police officer or military service member taking an oath of office. Following his initiation, he participated in weekly meetings conducted through video chats where members would discuss recruitment and intimidation tactics as well as violence that was happening “to other white people” around the world. During his April 2023 security interview, he stated he wore clothing associated with Group X during some meetings. At the hearing, however, he testified that he only tried on the clothing one time to see if it fit and did not wear it again. (GX 4-5; Tr. 27-30, 51-65) Applicant stated that he purged non-Group X members from his personal social media accounts because he did not want them to see Group X’s communications. He described that the State B chapter of Group X had to change social media groups several times due to non-members entering the group chats. He also had to use multiple computer encryption applications to communicate with the State B chapter of Group X. (GX 4) Around 2013, Applicant was directed to recruit new members to the State B chapter of Group X. In response, he attempted to recruit two acquaintances from the military installation where he was employed. Both individuals declined his overtures, though he claimed that they remained friends afterwards. During his April 2023 interview, he disclosed that he had sought an elected leadership position within the State B chapter of Group X but failed to secure the necessary votes. In subsequent testimony, he clarified that Mr. O had discussed appointing him to the role of chapter historian, but this appointment never materialized and no election ever occurred. (GX 4-5, Tr. 51-66, 85-87, 102-104) As an active member of the State B chapter of Group X, Applicant received notifications from Mr. O and other chapter members about planned cross burnings across the country, including a specific invitation to a 2016 event in State B. Applicant understood that cross burnings were a symbol of racial intimidation to “outsiders,” who he defined as nonmembers of Group X. During his April 2023 interview, he stated that cross burning never took place where he lived but he admitted he would have attended one if it was closer to him. However, at the hearing, he testified that he would not have participated in cross burnings because “that wasn’t my level of interest.” (GX 4-5; Tr. 43-65) On multiple occasions, Applicant was also asked to participate in “[Group X] Watches.” He described a “[Group X] Watch” as an action where members wrote “[Group X] is Watching You” on a
piece of paper, placed it in a weighted bag and threw it into the yards of “outsiders.” He described this as a “ridiculous” action and “probably a hateful thing to do.” He refused to participate. While he understood that these acts, like cross burnings, were intended for intimidation, he continued to be a member of the State B chapter of Group X. (GX 4-5; Tr. 55-60) 4
In about 2014, Applicant received a message from Mr. O containing pictures of people being assaulted. He understood that these were pictures of members of Group X that had betrayed the organization. He recognized this as a threat and knew that he “could never speak against or betray” Group X. After receiving these pictures, he did not report the matter to law enforcement or immediately attempt to distance himself from Mr. O or the State B chapter of Group X. (GX 4-5; Tr. 65-69) In about 2016, Mr. O texted Applicant requesting $700 for a car payment. Applicant described being frustrated over the request. However, he ultimately agreed and sent the funds. (GX 4-5, Tr. 68-70) In about November 2017, Applicant posted on social media a picture of himself in his backyard wearing a shirt with the symbol of the Schutzstaffel (SS) of Nazi Germany. He testified that he purchased the shirt because he was “interested in all types of history” and posted the picture online because he “thought it was fun.” Several individuals associated with Group X expressed approval of the picture, and he responded with affirmations of membership and loyalty to Group X. When one person commented that Applicant was fit to fight, Applicant responded, “Without a doubt, my brother!!! We will attain such glorious Victory for Our White Race!!!” When asked about his comments during his hearing, he stated, Those are words that I wrote then. … And I’m a good writer, and I put my thoughts down. I dress up my thoughts. And that’s what you’re seeing is my writing style, by adding exclamation points and stuff like that. (GX 2, 4-5; Tr. 72-89) Applicant did not wear his Nazi SS shirt in public because he “did not want to offend” anyone. However, he stated, I didn’t think it was that big of a deal. They were running an ongoing thing on ‘The History Channel’ about it. And I saw the symbol and I said, hey
Background
AN) of certain facts about domestic violence extremists (DVEs) in the United States and about an organization that I will refer to as “Group X.” I took administrative notice as requested, without objection. Those materials are marked as Administrative Notice (AN) I-XIV. It is permissible to take administrative notice of official documents posted by federal agencies. See ISCR Case No. 99-0452 at 4 (App. Bd. Mar. 21, 2000). Official pronouncements by the President, State Department, Department of Defense, or other appropriate federal agency on matters of national security are legislative facts for purposes of DOHA adjudications and must govern a Judge’s analysis. ISCR Case No. 17-04208 at 3 (App. Bd. Aug. 7, 2019)
Background
Findings of Fact Under Guideline A, the SOR alleges that, in 2012, Applicant paid a membership fee to join a chapter of Group X located in State B (SOR ¶ 1.b), and he remained a member of that chapter into 2018 (SOR ¶ 1.a). The SOR alleges that, while he was a member, he was tasked to recruit new members to Group X in person and online (SOR ¶ 1.c) and sent two payments of $700 to the senior leader of the State B chapter of Group X after receiving threats (SOR ¶ 1.d). The SOR further alleges that, despite separating himself from Group X in 2018, Applicant expressed an ongoing willingness to associate with “like-minded” people if there was a Group X chapter closer to his residence in State C (SOR ¶ 1.e). Under Guideline E, the SOR alleges that, during unspecified dates while employed with Company 1, Applicant received verbal reprimands for making racial comments (SOR ¶ 2.a) and singing a song containing racial pejoratives in the workplace (SOR ¶ 2.c). The SOR also alleges that he received a written warning for reviewing a coworker’s employee evaluation without her permission (SOR ¶ 2.b). Further, the amended SOR alleges that he falsified material facts when he failed to disclose the reprimands he received while employed with Company 1 in his November 2022 SCA (SOR ¶ 2.d). Additionally, the Guideline A security concerns were cross alleged under Guideline E (SOR ¶ 2.e). In his Answer to the SOR, Applicant admitted SOR ¶¶ 1.a – 1.e and denied SOR ¶¶ 2.a – 2.c. His response to SOR ¶ 2.e was erroneously directed toward SOR ¶ 2.d, and it is construed as a denial of SOR ¶ 2.d. Because he omitted a response to SOR ¶ 2.e, that omission is also deemed a denial. He provided extenuating and mitigating 2
information. His admissions are incorporated into my findings of fact. After a review of the pleadings and evidence submitted, I make the following additional findings of fact. Background Applicant is 60 years old. He earned a bachelor’s degree in 1988 and a doctorate in pharmacy in 1996. He has resided at his current residence in State C since 1996. His government contracting experience includes providing pharmacy services at a military installation through Company 1 from September 2014 to January 2018, followed by service at another military installation through Company 2 between July 2018 and April 2019. He subsequently transitioned to retail pharmacy operations, serving with Company 3 from August 2019 to July 2020 and Company 4 from September 2020 to August 2023. In August 2023, he returned to government contract work with Company 5, where he currently serves as a pharmacist, supporting the same military installation he worked at while with Company 1. (GX 1, 4; Tr. 12-13, 35-36, 127-130) Involvement in Group X Applicant’s association with Group X began in about 2012, when he was about 46 years old. He described growing increasingly frustrated by news of statues and monuments commemorating the Confederacy and Confederate history being taken down around the country. He considered himself a historian and began searching online for “like-minded” people he could talk with about the “chaos” surrounding the “rewriting of history.” He described “like-minded” people as “white men with a belief system of the “Old South,” which he further defined as “an appreciation for Confederate history, white pride, and Christianity.” (GX 4-5; Tr. 28-45) While online, Applicant connected with Mr. O, who held a senior leadership position within a chapter of Group X located in State B, an adjacent state to Applicant’s residence. Applicant explained that Mr. O was the type of “like-minded” person that matched his search. The two engaged in casual conversations about news, family, and current events. Mr. O was impressed by the way Applicant spoke and wrote on social media. Despite never meeting in person, Applicant came to regard Mr. O as an “old friend.” (GX 4-5; Tr. 39-46) In 2012, Mr. O invited Applicant to formally join the Group X chapter located in State B. During his April 2023 security interview with a government investigator, Applicant stated that, prior to becoming a member, he was aware of the history of Group X as an organization and admitted to knowing about their “status as a hate group and [as] domestic terrorists.” Even with that knowledge, he thought “it would be cool” to be a member. He told the investigator that Group X “is really not a bad group” and the classifications associated with the organization are from the original members a long time ago. In April 2025, he res
Background
onded to interrogatories and verified the accuracy of the investigator’s summary of his April 2023 security interview. (GX 4-5; Tr. 39-46) 3
Applicant paid a $20 membership fee to Mr. O and received clothing and regalia associated with Group X. Applicant swore an oath to the State B chapter of Group X. Although he later claimed he could not recall the content of the oath, during his April 2023 security interview, he compared it to a police officer or military service member taking an oath of office. Following his initiation, he participated in weekly meetings conducted through v
Background
deo chats where members would discuss recruitment and intimidation tactics as well as violence that was happening “to other white people” around the world. During his April 2023 security interview, he stated he wore clothing associated with Group X during some meetings. At the hearing, however, he testified that he only tried on the clothing one time to see if it fit and did not wear it again. (GX 4-5; Tr. 27-30, 51-65) Applicant stated that he purged non-Group X members from his personal social media accounts because he did not want them to see Group X’s communications. He described that the State B chapter of Group X had to change social media groups several times due to non-members entering the group chats. He also had to use multiple computer encryption applications to communicate with the State B chapter of Group X. (GX 4) Around 2013, Applicant was directed to recruit new members to the State B chapter of Group X. In response, he attempted to recruit two acquaintances from the military installation where he was employed. Both individuals declined his overtures, though he claimed that they remained friends afterwards. During his April 2023 interview, he disclosed that he had sought an elected leadership position within the State B chapter of Group X but failed to secure the necessary votes. In subsequent testimony, he clarified that Mr. O had discussed appointing him to the role of chapter historian, but this appointment never materialized and no election ever occurred. (GX 4-5, Tr. 51-66, 85-87, 102-104) As an active member of the State B chapter of Group X, Applicant received notifications from Mr. O and other chapter members about planned cross burnings across the country, including a specific invitation to a 2016 event in State B. Applicant understood that cross burnings were a symbol of racial intimidation to “outsiders,” who he defined as nonmembers of Group X. During his April 2023 interview, he stated that cross burning never took place where he lived but he admitted he would have attended one if it was closer to him. However, at the hearing, he testified that he would not have participated in cross burnings because “that wasn’t my level of interest.” (GX 4-5; Tr. 43-65) On multiple occasions, Applicant was also asked to participate in “[Group X] Watches.” He described a “[Group X] Watch” as an action where members wrote “[Group X] is Watching You” on a
piece of paper, placed it in a weighted bag and threw it into the yards of “outsiders.” He described this as a “ridiculous” action and “probably a hateful thing to do.” He refused to participate. While he understood that these acts, like cross burnings, were intended for intimidation, he continued to be a member of the State B chapter of Group X. (GX 4-5; Tr. 55-60) 4
Whole Person Concept
In about 2014, Applicant received a message from Mr. O containing pictures of people being assaulted. He understood that these were pictures of members of Group X that had betrayed the organization. He recognized this as a threat and knew that he “could never speak
Policies
ainst or betray” Group X. After receiving these pictures, he did not report the matter to law enforcement or immediately attempt to distance himself from Mr. O or the State B chapter of Group X. (GX 4-5; Tr. 65-69) In about 2016, Mr. O texted Applicant requesting $700 for a car payment. Applicant described being frustrated over the request. However, he ultimately agreed and sent the funds. (GX 4-5, Tr. 68-70) In about November 2017, Applicant posted on social media a picture of himself in his backyard wearing a shirt with the symbol of the Schutzstaffel (SS) of Nazi Germany. He testified that he purchased the shirt because he was “interested in all types of history” and posted the picture online because he “thought it was fun.” Several individuals associated with Group X expressed approval of the picture, and he responded with affirmations of membership and loyalty to Group X. When one person commented that Applicant was fit to fight, Applicant responded, “Without a doubt, my brother!!! We will attain such glorious Victory for Our White Race!!!” When asked about his comments during his hearing, he stated, Those are words that I wrote then. … And I’m a good writer, and I put my thoughts down. I dress up my thoughts. And that’s what you’re seeing is my writing style, by adding exclamation points and stuff like that. (GX 2, 4-5; Tr. 72-89) Applicant did not wear his Nazi SS shirt in public because he “did not want to offend” anyone. However, he stated, I didn’t think it was that big of a deal. They were running an ongoing thing on ‘The History Channel’ about it. And I saw the symbol and I said, hey, that’s cool. It was cool to me at the time. It’s not cool now because it’s been brought under scrutiny, which so many other things have. As a self-professed historian, he was aware of the history of the Nazi SS, particularly in relation to the persecution of Jews and other minority populations. Regarding his statements within the online comments, he stated, “They’re nothing that I live by now.” (GX 2, 4-5; Tr. 72-89) In about December 2017, Mr. O again demanded $700 from Applicant to assist with a c
Analysis
payment. When Applicant initially refused, Mr. O again sent him images of individuals who had been physically assaulted. Mr. O warned Applicant that compliance would be in his best interest. Applicant described being fearful of the threat and ultimately sent the funds. Recognizing that Mr. O was financially exploiting him, Applicant decided 5
to no longer associate with Mr. O or Group X. He blocked all Group X members from his social media accounts. He has not had contact with them since then. (GX 4-5; Tr. 50-70, 100-102) Applicant submitted an SCA in November 2022. In Section 29 (Association Record), in response to the question of whether he had “EVER been a member of an organization that advocates or practices commission of acts of force or violence to discourage others from exercising their rights under the U.S. Constiution,” Applicant answered “No” and omitted any mention of Group X or his membership in the State B chapter. (GX 1) During his April 2023 security interview, when asked about his social media activity, Applicant detailed his association with Mr. O and the State B chapter of Group X. While maintaining that his active involvement with Group X had ceased, he expressed an openness to associating with "like-minded" individuals if a Group X chapter were established closer to his home. He stated that he stopped using his social media accounts due to his perception that he could not express his opinions freely. He denied having engaged in derogatory, hateful, or discriminatory speech, expressing bias toward any protected class, or holding divided loyalties to the United States. (GX 4) In his May 2025 response to interrogatories, Applicant stated that he had thrown away all materials associated with Group X and the State B chapter. Regarding his membership, he stated, “What an error in judgment I made. Today, I have accepted that fact and my life is so much better.” (GX 5) In his September 2025 Answer to the SOR, Applicant admitted to being a former member of the State B chapter of Group X but claimed it was “without intent to be a terrorist or to be involved in any acts of terrorism.” He stated, “my reason for joining was simply because I was upset about [the] removal of our Confederate statues,” and was “looking for a forum of discussion” about the “Old South.” He admitted he had attempted to recruit individuals into Group X but had been unsuccessful and never had an “intent to harm anyone.” (Answer) During the hearing, Applicant affirmed that his initial attraction to Group X stemmed from an interest in the heritage of the “Old South” and his concerns over the revision of Confederate history and culture. He described having family ties to a Confederate soldier whose statue was removed. However, he also admitted to a detailed understanding of the history of Group X, and its historic use of violence, threats, and intimidation to infringe on the constitutional rights of others, particularly certain minority, ethnic, and religious communities. He considered his participation in the State B chapter of Group X to be “benign” as he did not “hate anybody” and was “not interested in that angle.” Instead, he was “simply looking to talk about the current events of the day.” (GX 4 5; Tr. 28-46, 70-72) Applicant repeatedly distanced himself from the violent aspects of Group X and stated, “It was not something that I believed in for myself. That wasn’t my truth.” He 6
claimed he never participated in any activities within the State B chapter of Group X that reflected hate or bias toward other groups and stated that he never intended to hurt anyone. He testified that “[Group X] means nothing to me now.” (Tr. 96-106, 142-144) History of Group X I took administrative notice of certain facts about DVEs and Group X. Historically, Group X has used violence and terror to deny civil rights and political power to minority, ethnic, and religious communities in the United States. Several federal agencies categorize Group X and its offshoots as DVEs under the Racially or Ethnically Motivated Violent Extremist (RMVE) threat category, which focuses on individuals using unlawful force to further political or social goals derived from racial or ethnic bias such as white supremacist violence. RMVEs are considered one of the most persistent, lethal, and active domestic violent extremist threats in the United States. (AN I-XIV) Because Group X is highly decentralized, law enforcement has shifted its focus from group affiliation to investigating and prosecuting specific criminal acts. Recent federal criminal cases highlight the diverse range of extremist activities intercepted by authorities. These include neutralizing high-level threats like a 2016 conviction of a Group X member plotting to build a bomb to attack a minority community, as well as prosecuting weapon offenses in 2013 and 2015 involving illegal firearm possession. Federal prosecutors actively target hate crimes including localized intimidation efforts, securing convictions for threats through the mail in 2014 and prosecuting civil rights violations for cross burnings as recently as 2023. (AN I-XIV) The Department of War has long prohibited service members from actively engaging in extremist activities. These expectations extend to defense contractors through regulatory provisions relating to required adverse information reporting and insider threat protections, as well as the security clearance guidelines. (AGs; AN I) Personal Conduct In his November 2022 SCA, Applicant listed his employment with Company 1 and answered “No” to having “received a written warning, been officially reprimanded, suspended, or disciplined for misconduct in the workplace” within the last seven years. He stated he left Company 1 for “family circumstances” and was “seeking relocation.” However, during his April 2023 interview, he disclosed that he had received one verbal and two written reprimands while employed with Company 1. (GX 1, 4-5) The first incident occurred on an unspecified date when someone in a group knocked over a drink onto Applicant while in the employee breakroom. Applicant detailed that, when asked about the incident by a coworker, he identified the people involved by their racial origin and received a verbal reprimand for the racial comment. (GX 4-5; Tr. 107-110) 7
The second incident occurred on an unspecified date when a coworker left her employee evaluation out in the open. Applicant explained that he looked at it and later commented to the employee about her evaluation. For this, he received a written reprimand for his conduct but refused to sign it. (GX 4-5; Tr. 111-117) The third incident occurred in about November 2017, when Applicant sang a song at work that contained racial pejoratives. A coworker heard the song and made a complaint. Applicant received a written reprimand for his conduct but refused to sign it. (GX 4-5; Tr. 117-121) During his April 2023 interview, Applicant stated he did not find any of his comments to be inappropriate or improper for the workplace. He stated he did not list the reprimands in his November 2022 SCA because he felt that they were not valid and he had not signed them. (GX 4) In his May 2025 response to interrogatories, Applicant detailed that he had received “a simple write up” by a military supervisor for looking at a coworker’s evaluation. He also recalled that, in November 2017, he sang a song with “racist references” in it. He explained that he had originally learned it from his grandmother as a "happy song" and was unaware of the “racist lyrics” until after he sang them. In his response to the interrogatories, he expressed regret, stating, “I hate that it caused harm or hurt feelings and I apologize for the outcome.” (GX 5) In his September 2025 SOR Answer, Applicant admitted to receiving a reprimand from the military supervisor for reviewing a coworker’s evaluation. However, he denied being reprimanded after the breakroom incident. He also acknowledged singing a song containing “racial lyrics” at work and explained that he forgot those specific lyrics were in the song until it was too late to stop singing them. He denied receiving a reprimand for the incident. Additionally, he denied falsifying material facts in his November 2022 SCA by omitting these reprimands, asserting that he was never issued any verbal or written reprimands by Company 1 or any other entity regarding his “job security.” Finally, he stated that he voluntarily resigned from Company 1 without prejudice. (Answer) During the hearing, Applicant acknowledged that he identified coworkers in the breakroom by race and accessed a colleague’s employee evaluation without authorization. He further acknowledged singing a song containing racially offensive lyrics in the workplace, contending that he had inadvertently sang the words before he recognized their offensive nature. Nonetheless, he minimized the severity of his conduct and the resulting reprimands, emphasizing that his sole formal reprimand originated from the military supervisor rather than his direct employer, Company 1. (Tr. 111-121) When questioned about omitting the reprimands from his November 2022 SCA, Applicant testified that he did not sign the reprimands or report the conduct because he did not consider them “serious,” noting the incidents occurred “without malice.” He further 8
stated he omitted them because he did not believe they qualified as “viable reprimand[s].” (Tr. 115-121) Whole-Person Factors Applicant repeatedly claimed that his association with Group X reflected an “error in judgment” and that he “feel[s] much better now” having put that association entirely in his past. He believes he is a loyal citizen of the United States. He stressed that, in his current position, he provides care to a diverse community and is “full of pride” in “giving back to our military.” He believes he “get[s] along with everybody” and is making a positive impact in the workplace. (GX 4-5; Tr. 37-38, 83-85, 139-142) Policies It is well established that no one has a right to a security clearance. As the Supreme Court held in Department of the Navy v. Egan, “the clearly consistent standard indicates that security determinations should err, if they must, on the side of denials.” 484 U.S. 518, 531 (1988) When evaluating an applicant’s suitability for a security clearance, the administrative judge must consider the adjudicative guidelines. In addition to brief introductory explanations for each guideline, the adjudicative guidelines list potentially disqualifying conditions and mitigating conditions, which are used in evaluating an applicant’s eligibility for access to classified information. These guidelines are not inflexible rules of law. Instead, recognizing the complexities of human behavior, these guidelines are applied in conjunction with the factors listed in the adjudicative process. The administrative judge’s overarching adjudicative goal is a fair, impartial, and commonsense decision. According to AG ¶ 2(a), the entire process is a conscientious scrutiny of a number of variables known as the “whole-person concept.” The administrative judge must consider all available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable, in making a decision. The protection of the national security is the paramount consideration. AG ¶ 2(b) requires that “[a]ny doubt concerning personnel being considered for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.” In reaching this decision, I have drawn only those conclusions that are reasonable, logical, and based on the evidence contained in the record. Likewise, I have not drawn inferences grounded on mere speculation or conjecture. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.14, the Government must present evidence to establish controverted facts alleged in the SOR. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.15, an “applicant is responsible for presenting witnesses and other evidence to rebut, explain, extenuate, or 9
mitigate facts admitted by applicant or proven by Department Counsel and has the ultimate burden of persuasion to obtain a favorable security decision.” A person who seeks access to classified information enters into a fiduciary relationship with the Government predicated upon trust and confidence. This relationship transcends normal duty hours and endures throughout off-duty hours. The Government reposes a high degree of trust and confidence in individuals to whom it grants access to classified information. Decisions include, by necessity, consideration of the possible risk the applicant may deliberately or inadvertently fail to safeguard classified information. Such decisions entail a certain degree of legally permissible extrapolation of potential, rather than actual, risk of compromise of classified information. Analysis Guideline A: Allegiance to the United States The security concern for allegiance to the United States is set out in AG ¶ 3: The willingness to safeguard classified or sensitive information is in doubt if there is any reason to suspect an individual’s allegiance to the United States. There is no positive test for allegiance, but there are negative indicators. These include participation in or support for acts against the United States or placing the welfare or interests of another country above those of the United States. Finally, the failure to adhere to the laws of the United States may be relevant if the violation of law is harmful to stated U.S. interests. An individual who engages in acts against the United States or provides support or encouragement to those who do has already demonstrated willingness to compromise national security. I have considered the disqualifying conditions under AG ¶ 4 and the following are potentially applicable: (a) involvement in, support of, training to commit, or advocacy of any act of sabotage, espionage, treason, terrorism, or sedition against the United States; (b) association or sympathy with persons who are attempting to commit, or who are committing, any of the above acts; and (c) association or sympathy with persons or organizations that advocate, threaten, or use force or violence, or use any other illegal or unconstitutional means, in an effort to: (1) overthrow or influence the U.S. Government or any state or local government; (2) prevent Federal, state, or local government personnel from performing their official duties; (3) gain retribution for perceived wrongs caused by the Federal, state, or local 10
government; and (4) prevent others from exercising their rights under the Constitution or laws of the United States or of any state. Under Guideline A, the primary security concern is that an individual must demonstrate unquestioned allegiance to the United States. An applicant’s willingness to join, support, or associate with any organization or movement that advocates the use of force, violence, or other illegal means to deprive individuals of their constitutional rights acts as a disqualifier for security clearance eligibility. Group X is considered a DVE, classified by various federal agencies as an RMVE, which represents one of the most lethal, persistent, and active domestic violent extremist threats within the United States. Historically, Group X has engaged in violence, armed intimidation and domestic terrorism with the intention of oppressing various minorities, ethnic, and religious groups, and infringing upon their civil liberties. Driven primarily by racial grievances and white supremacist ideology, identified members of Group X continue to be subject to federal investigation and prosecution for hate crimes, civil rights violations, and coordinated intimidation campaigns. As a self-professed historian, Applicant joined Group X in 2012 with full knowledge of its ideological foundation and background. He affirmed his commitment to Group X by paying dues, swearing a formal oath, attending meetings, wearing Group X regalia, writing in support of the group and, at one point, being actively considered for a leadership role. This was a deliberate, structured affiliation rather than passive or incidental contact. Early in his affiliation, Applicant actively solicited two coworkers at a military installation to join Group X. Attempting to recruit personnel for a recognized extremist movement from within a military facility represents an overt act of an insider threat. Additionally, in 2017, he published a photograph of himself wearing a Nazi SS shirt and later stating, in a message to other Group X members, "We will attain such glorious Victory for Our White Race!!!" This conduct reflects an explicit endorsement of fascist and white supremacist beliefs. It further demonstrates his long association with an organization that advocates for the use of violence and intimidation to deny equal protection and constitutional rights to various target populations. In review of the security concerns under Guideline A, Applicant’s association with Group X is insufficient to establish a security concern under AG ¶ 4(a). Although Group X has a historical record of localized terrorism and intimidation, its current activities focus primarily on hate speech, unlawful discrimination, and racially motivated violence rather than active subversion. Similarly, the security concern under AG ¶ 4(b) is not established. While Applicant has openly endorsed Group X’s white supremacist and fascist ideologies, holding racially extremist views does not inherently translate to supporting or encouraging others to participate in acts of espionage, sabotage, or treason against the United States. However, the evidence establishes that Applicant paid dues and sustained formal membership with Group X from 2012 through 2017. Group X historically and actively 11
employs violence, intimidation, and unlawful acts to oppress individuals of their constitutionally guaranteed civil rights. His active membership, recruitment efforts, and sympathies for this group satisfy the threshold for a security concern to be established under AG ¶ 4(c)(4) for SOR ¶¶ 1.a – 1.e I have considered the mitigating conditions under AG ¶ 5 and the following are potentially applicable: (a) the individual was unaware of the unlawful aims of the individual or organization and severed ties upon learning of these; (c) involvement in the above activities occurred for only a short period of time and was attributable to curiosity or academic interest; and (d) the involvement or association with such activities occurred under such unusual circumstances, or so much time has elapsed, that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the individual’s current reliability, trustworthiness, or allegiance. Applicant began associating with Group X in 2012 out of a professed concern over the “rewriting” of history as several Confederate statutes and monuments were being taken down around the country. While he was involved in Group X, he never participated in cross burnings or “[Group X] Watches” and repeatedly stated that he was “not interested in that angle” of the group. He separated from Group X at the end of 2017. He no longer associates with any of its members and has blocked them from his social media accounts. He repeatedly claimed he made a significant “error in judgment” by participating with Group X and believes he has put that association entirely in his past. He stressed that, in his current position, he serves a diverse community and is “full of pride” in “giving back to our military.” He believes he is a loyal citizen of the United States. All the above- mentioned mitigating conditions must be considered. Conversely, by common knowledge, and certainly given his interest in history as reflected in his April 2023 security interview and in his testimony, Applicant knew about Group X’s extensive history of violence and intimidation when he became a member in 2012. Yet, he paid dues, swore an oath, wore Group X regalia, participated in meetings, considered running for a leadership position, provided funds to a State B Group X leader, advocated for the ideology of the group online, and actively recruited for the group. While he stated he did not participate in cross burnings or “[Group X] Watches,” he remained a member with knowledge that these intimidating events occurred. Additionally, he provided conflicting accounts regarding his reasons for not attending cross burnings, his pursuit of a leadership role, and the circumstances under which he wore Group X regalia. Further, he remained a member of Group X even after he received photos from Mr. O of another Group X member who had been beaten. This reflects his tolerance for Group X’s criminal actions of intimidation. Mitigation under AG ¶ 5(a) is not applicable. 12
When asked about the posting online of himself wearing a Nazi SS shirt and his written statement about achieving "Glorious Victory for Our White Race!!!," Applicant attempted to frame his interest in Nazism, like his interest in the “Old South,” as purely historical. However, his actions and statements demonstrate an active advocacy for the tenants of Group X, not a mere curiosity or a detached academic interest. Mitigation under AG ¶ 5(c) is not applicable. Applicant’s departure from Group X occurred after he experienced personal financial exploitation from Mr. O, not because he rejected Group X’s ideology. He tolerated Group X’s hateful activities and threats against others until he was personally affected. As recently as his security interview in April 2023, he stated he would still associate with “like-minded” people if a Group X chapter were closer to where he lived. This reflects an ongoing willingness to participate in an extremist group. Mitigation under ¶ AG 5(d) is not applicable. Applicant has a constitutional right to freedom of belief and association, so long as those beliefs and associations do not infringe upon the constitutionally protected rights of others. He do
es not have a constitutional right to a security clearance. See Egan, 484 U.S. at 528. To be determined eligible for access to classified information, he must rebut, explain, extenuate, or mitigate the significant conduct or circumstances established by the Government and he has the ultimate burden of persuasion to obtain a favorable security decision. He has not met his burden to mitigate the Guideline A security concerns. Guideline E: Personal Conduct The security concern for personal conduct is set out in AG ¶ 15:
Analysis
When Applicant initially refused, Mr. O again sent him images of individuals who had been physically assaulted. Mr. O warned Applicant that compliance would be in his best interest. Applicant described being fearful of the threat and ultimately sent the funds. Recognizing that Mr. O was financially exploiting him, Applicant decided 5
to no longer associate with Mr. O or Group X. He blocked all Group X members from his social media accounts. He has not had contact with them since then. (GX 4-5; Tr. 50-70, 100-102) Applicant submitted an SCA in November 2022. In Section 29 (Association Record), in response to the question of whether he had “EVER been a member of an organization that advocates or practices commission of acts of force or violence to discourage others from exercising their rights under the U.S. Constiution,” Applicant answered “No” and omitted any mention of Group X or his membership in the State B chapter. (GX 1) During his April 2023 security interview, when asked about his social media activity, Applicant detailed his association with Mr. O and the State B chapter of Group X. While maintaining that his active involvement with Group X had ceased, he expressed an openness to associating with "like-minded" individuals if a Group X chapter were established closer to his home. He stated that he stopped using his social media accounts due to his perception that he could not express his opinions freely. He denied having engaged in derogatory, hateful, or discriminatory speech, expressing bias toward any protected class, or holding divided loyalties to the United States. (GX 4) In his May 2025 response to interrogatories, Applicant stated that he had thrown away all materials associated with Group X and the State B chapter. Regarding his membership, he stated, “What an error in judgment I made. Today, I have accepted that fact and my life is so much better.” (GX 5) In his September 2025 Answer to the SOR, Applicant admitted to being a former member of the State B chapter of Group X but claimed it was “without intent to be a terrorist or to be involved in any acts of terrorism.” He stated, “my reason for joining was simply because I was upset about [the] removal of our Confederate statues,” and was “looking for a forum of discussion” about the “Old South.” He admitted he had attempted to recruit individuals into Group X but had been unsuccessful and never had an “intent to harm anyone.” (Answer) During the hearing, Applicant affirmed that his initial attraction to Group X stemmed from an interest in the heritage of the “Old South” and his concerns over the revision of Confederate history and culture. He described having family ties to a Confederate soldier whose statue was removed. However, he also admitted to a detailed understanding of the history of Group X, and its historic use of violence, threats, and intimidation to infringe on the constitutional rights of others, particularly certain minority, ethnic, and religious communities. He considered his participation in the State B chapter of Group X to be “benign” as he did not “hate anybody” and was “not interested in that angle.” Instead, he was “simply looking to talk about the current events of the day.” (GX 4 5; Tr. 28-46, 70-72) Applicant repeatedly distanced himself from the violent aspects of Group X and stated, “It was not something that I believed in for myself. That wasn’t my truth.” He 6
claimed he never participated in any activities within the State B chapter of Group X that reflected hate or bias toward other groups and stated that he never intended to hurt anyone. He testified that “[Group X] means nothing to me now.” (Tr. 96-106, 142-144) History of Group X I took administrative notice of certain facts about DVEs and Group X. Historically, Group X has used violence and terror to deny civil rights and political power to minority, ethnic, and religious communities in the United States. Several federal agencies categorize Group X and its offshoots as DVEs under the Racially or Ethnically Motivated Violent Extremist (RMVE) threat category, which focuses on individuals using unlawful force to further political or social goals derived from racial or ethnic bias such as white supremacist violence. RMVEs are considered one of the most persistent, lethal, and active domestic violent extremist threats in the United States. (AN I-XIV) Because Group X is highly decentralized, law enforcement has shifted its focus from group affiliation to investigating and prosecuting specific criminal acts. Recent federal criminal cases highlight the diverse range of extremist activities intercepted by authorities. These include neutralizing high-level threats like a 2016 conviction of a Group X member plotting to build a bomb to attack a minority community, as well as prosecuting weapon offenses in 2013 and 2015 involving illegal firearm possession. Federal prosecutors actively target hate crimes including localized intimidation efforts, securing convictions for threats through the mail in 2014 and prosecuting civil rights violations for cross burnings as recently as 2023. (AN I-XIV) The Department of War has long prohibited service members from actively engaging in extremist activities. These expectations extend to defense contractors through regulatory provisions relating to required adverse information reporting and insider threat protections, as well as the security clearance guidelines. (AGs; AN I) Personal Conduct In his November 2022 SCA, Applicant listed his employment with Company 1 and answered “No” to having “received a written warning, been officially reprimanded, suspended, or disciplined for misconduct in the workplace” within the last seven years. He stated he left Company 1 for “family circumstances” and was “seeking relocation.” However, during his April 2023 interview, he disclosed that he had received one verbal and two written reprimands while employed with Company 1. (GX 1, 4-5) The first incident occurred on an unspecified date when someone in a group knocked over a drink onto Applicant while in the employee breakroom. Applicant detailed that, when asked about the incident by a coworker, he identified the people involved by their racial origin and received a verbal reprimand for the racial comment. (GX 4-5; Tr. 107-110) 7
The second incident occurred on an unspecified date when a coworker left her employee evaluation out in the open. Applicant explained that he looked at it and later commented to the employee about her evaluation. For this, he received a written reprimand for his conduct but refused to sign it. (GX 4-5; Tr. 111-117) The third incident occurred in about November 2017, when Applicant sang a song at work that contained racial pejoratives. A coworker heard the song and made a complaint. Applicant received a written reprimand for his conduct but refused to sign it. (GX 4-5; Tr. 117-121) During his April 2023 interview, Applicant stated he did not find any of his comments to be inappropriate or improper for the workplace. He stated he did not list the reprimands in his November 2022 SCA because he felt that they were not valid and he had not signed them. (GX 4) In his May 2025 response to interrogatories, Applicant detailed that he had received “a simple write up” by a military supervisor for looking at a coworker’s evaluation. He also recalled that, in November 2017, he sang a song with “racist references” in it. He explained that he had originally learned it from his grandmother as a "happy song" and was unaware of the “racist lyrics” until after he sang them. In his response to the interrogatories, he expressed regret, stating, “I hate that it caused harm or hurt feelings and I apologize for the outcome.” (GX 5) In his September 2025 SOR Answer, Applicant admitted to receiving a reprimand from the military supervisor for reviewing a coworker’s evaluation. However, he denied being reprimanded after the breakroom incident. He also acknowledged singing a song containing “racial lyrics” at work and explained that he forgot those specific lyrics were in the song until it was too late to stop singing them. He denied receiving a reprimand for the incident. Additionally, he denied falsifying material facts in his November 2022 SCA by omitting these reprimands, asserting that he was never issued any verbal or written reprimands by Company 1 or any other entity regarding his “job security.” Finally, he stated that he voluntarily resigned from Company 1 without prejudice. (Answer) During the hearing, Applicant acknowledged that he identified coworkers in the breakroom by race and accessed a colleague’s employee evaluation without authorization. He further acknowledged singing a song containing racially offensive lyrics in the workplace, contending that he had inadvertently sang the words before he recognized their offensive nature. Nonetheless, he minimized the severity of his conduct and the resulting reprimands, emphasizing that his sole formal reprimand originated from the military supervisor rather than his direct employer, Company 1. (Tr. 111-121) When questioned about omitting the reprimands from his November 2022 SCA, Applicant testified that he did not sign the reprimands or report the conduct because he did not consider them “serious,” noting the incidents occurred “without malice.” He further 8
stated he omitted them because he did not believe they qualified as “viable reprimand[s].” (Tr. 115-121) Whole-Person Factors Applicant repeatedly claimed that his association with Group X reflected an “error in judgment” and that he “feel[s] much better now” having put that association entirely in his past. He believes he is a loyal citizen of the United States. He stressed that, in his current position, he provides care to a diverse community and is “full of pride” in “giving back to our military.” He believes he “get[s] along with everybody” and is making a positive impact in the workplace. (GX 4-5; Tr. 37-38, 83-85, 139-142) Policies It is well established that no one has a right to a security clearance. As the S
Analysis
preme Court held in Department of the Navy v. Egan, “the clearly consistent standard indicates that security determinations should err, if they must, on the side of denials.” 484 U.S. 518, 531 (1988) When evaluating an applicant’s suitability for a security clearance, the administrative judge must consider the adjudicative guidelines. In addition to brief introductory explanations for each guideline, the adjudicative guidelines list potentially disqualifying conditions and mitigating conditions, which are used in evaluating an applicant’s eligibility for access to classified information. These guidelines are not inflexible rules of law. Instead, recognizing the complexities of human behavior, these guidelines are applied in conjunction with the factors listed in the adjudicative process. The administrative judge’s overarching adjudicative goal is a fair, impartial, and commonsense decision. According to AG ¶ 2(a), the entire process is a conscientious scrutiny of a number of variables known as the “whole-person concept.” The administrative judge must consider all available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable, in making a decision. The protection of the national security is the paramount consideration. AG ¶ 2(b) requires that “[a]ny doubt concerning personnel being considered for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.” In reaching this decision, I have drawn only those conclusions that are reasonable, logical, and based on the evidence contained in the record. Likewise, I have not drawn inferences grounded on mere speculation or conjecture. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.14, the Government must present evidence to establish controverted facts alleged in the SOR. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.15, an “applicant is responsible for presenting witnesses and other evidence to rebut, explain, extenuate, or 9
mitigate facts admitted by applicant or proven by Department Counsel and has the ultimate burden of persuasion to obtain a favorable security decision.” A person who seeks access to classified information enters into a fiduciary relationship with the Government predicated upon trust and confidence. This relationship transcends normal duty hours and endures throughout off-duty hours. The Government reposes a high degree of trust and confidence in individuals to whom it grants access to classified information. Decisions include, by necessity, consideration of the possible risk the applicant may deliberately or inadvertently fail to safeguard classified information. Such decisions entail a certain degree of legally permissible extrapolation of potential, rather than actual, risk of compromise of classified information. Analysis Guideline A: Allegiance to the United States The security concern for allegiance to the United States is set out in AG ¶ 3: The willingness to safeguard classified or sensitive information is in doubt if there is any reason to suspect an individual’s allegiance to the United States. There is no positive test for allegiance, but there are negative indicators. These include participation in or support for acts against the United States or placing the welfare or interests of another country above those of the United States. Finally, the failure to adhere to the laws of the United States may be relevant if the violation of law is harmful to stated U.S. interests. An individual who engages in acts against the United States or provides support or encouragement to those who do has already demonstrated willingness to compromise national security. I have considered the disqualifying conditions under AG ¶ 4 and the following are potentially applicable: (a) involvement in, support of, training to commit, or advocacy of any act of sabotage, espionage, treason, terrorism, or sedition against the United States; (b) association or sympathy with persons who are attempting to commit, or who are committing, any of the above acts; and (c) association or sympathy with persons or organizations that advocate, threaten, or use force or violence, or use any other illegal or unconstitutional means, in an effort to: (1) overthrow or influence the U.S. Government or any state or local government; (2) prevent Federal, state, or local government personnel from performing their official duties; (3) gain retribution for perceived wrongs caused by the Federal, state, or local 10
government; and (4) prevent others from exercising their rights under the Constitution or laws of the United States or of any state. Under Guideline A, the primary security concern is that an individual must demonstrate unquestioned allegiance to the United States. An applicant’s willingness to join, support, or associate with any organization or movement that advocates the use of force, violence, or other illegal means to deprive individuals of their constitutional rights acts as a disqualifier for security clearance eligibility. Group X is considered a DVE, classified by various federal agencies as an RMVE, which represents one of the most lethal, persistent, and active domestic violent extremist threats within the United States. Historically, Group X has engaged in violence, armed intimidation and domestic terrorism with the intention of oppressing various minorities, ethnic, and religious groups, and infringing upon their civil liberties. Driven primarily by racial grievances and white supremacist ideology, identified members of Group X continue to be subject to federal investigation and prosecution for hate crimes, civil rights violations, and coordinated intimidation campaigns. As a self-professed historian, Applicant joined Group X in 2012 with full knowledge of its ideological foundation and background. He affirmed his commitment to Group X by paying dues, swearing a formal oath, attending meetings, wearing Group X regalia, writing in support of the group and, at one point, being actively considered for a leadership role. This was a deliberate, structured affiliation rather than passive or incidental contact. Early in his affiliation, Applicant actively solicited two coworkers at a military installation to join Group X. Attempting to recruit personnel for a recognized extremist movement from within a military facility represents an overt act of an insider threat. Additionally, in 2017, he published a photograph of himself wearing a Nazi SS shirt and later stating, in a message to other Group X members, "We will attain such glorious Victory for Our White Race!!!" This conduct reflects an explicit endorsement of fascist and white supremacist beliefs. It further demonstrates his long association with an organization that advocates for the use of violence and intimidation to deny equal protection and constitutional rights to various target populations. In review of the security concerns under Guideline A, Applicant’s association with Group X is insufficient to establish a security concern under AG ¶ 4(a). Although Group X has a historical record of localized terrorism and intimidation, its current activities focus primarily on hate speech, unlawful discrimination, and racially motivated violence rather than active subversion. Similarly, the security concern under AG ¶ 4(b) is not established. While Applicant has openly endorsed Group X’s white supremacist and fascist ideologies, holding racially extremist views does not inherently translate to supporting or encouraging others to participate in acts of espionage, sabotage, or treason against the United States. However, the evidence establishes that Applicant paid dues and sustained formal membership with Group X from 2012 through 2017. Group X historically and actively 11
employs violence, intimidation, and unlawful acts to oppress individuals of their constitutionally guaranteed civil rights. His active membership, recruitment efforts, and sympathies for this group satisfy the threshold for a security concern to be established under AG ¶ 4(c)(4) for SOR ¶¶ 1.a – 1.e I have considered the mitigating conditions under AG ¶ 5 and the following are potentially applicable: (a) the individual was unaware of the unlawful aims of the individual or organization and severed ties upon learning of these; (c) involvement in the above activities occurred for only a short period of time and was attributable to curiosity or academic interest; and (d) the involvement or association with such activities occurred under such unusual circumstances, or so much time has elapsed, that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the individual’s current reliability, trustworthiness, or allegiance. Applicant began associating with Group X in 2012 out of a professed concern over the “rewriting” of history as several Confederate statutes and monuments were being taken down around the c
Whole Person Analysis
untry. While he was involved in Group X, he never participated in cross burnings or “[Group X] Watches” and repeatedly stated that he was “not interested in that angle” of the group. He separated from Group X at the end of 2017. He no longer associates with any of its members and has blocked them from his social media accounts. He repeatedly claimed he made a significant “error in judgment” by participating with Group X and believes he has put that association entirely in his past. He stressed that, in his current position, he serves a diverse community and is “full of pride” in “giving back to our military.” He believes he is a loyal citizen of the United States. All the above- mentioned mitigating conditions must be considered. Conversely, by common knowledge, and certainly given his interest in history as reflected in his April 2023 security interview and in his testimony, Applicant knew about Group X’s extensive history of violence and intimidation when he became a member in 2012. Yet, he paid dues, swore an oath, wore Group X regalia, participated in meetings, considered running for a leadership position, provided funds to a State B Group X leader, advocated for the ideology of the group online, and actively recruited for the group. While he stated he did not participate in cross burnings or “[Group X] Watches,” he remained a member with knowledge that these intimidating events occurred. Additionally, he provided conflicting accounts regarding his reasons for not attending cross burnings, his pursuit of a leadership role, and the circumstances under which he wore Group X regalia. Further, he remained a member of Group X even after he received photos from Mr. O of another Group X member who had been beaten. This reflects his tolerance for Group X’s criminal actions of intimidation. Mitigation under AG ¶ 5(a) is not applicable. 12
When asked about the posting online of himself wearing a Nazi SS shirt and his written statement about achieving "Glorious Victory for Our White Race!!!," Applicant attempted to frame his interest in Nazism, like his interest in the “Old South,” as purely historical. However, his actions and statements demonstrate an active advocacy for the tenants of Group X, not a mere curiosity or a detached academic interest. Mitigation under AG ¶ 5(c) is not applicable. Applicant’s departure from Group X occurred after he experienced personal financial exploitation from Mr. O, not because he rejected Group X’s ideology. He tolerated Group X’s hateful activities and threats against others until he was personally affected. As recently as his security interview in April 2023, he stated he would still associate with “like-minded” people if a Group X chapter were closer to where he lived. This reflects an ongoing willingness to participate in an extremist group. Mitigation under ¶ AG 5(d) is not applicable. Applicant has a constitutional right to freedom of belief and association, so long as those beliefs and associations do not infringe upon the constitutionally protected rights of others. He do
es not have a constitutional right to a security clearance. See Egan, 484 U.S. at 528. To be determined eligible for access to classified information, he must rebut, explain, extenuate, or mitigate the significant conduct or circumstances established by the Government and he has the ultimate burden of persuasion to obtain a favorable security decision. He has not met his burden to mitigate the Guideline A security concerns. Guideline E: Personal Conduct The security concern for personal conduct is set out in AG ¶ 15:
Formal Findings
nduct involving questionable judgment, lack of candor, dishonesty, or unwillingness to comply with rules and regulations can raise questions about an individual’s reliability, trustworthiness, and ability to protect classified or sensitive information. Of special interest is any failure to cooperate or provide truthful and candid answers during national security investigative or adjudicative processes. … I have considered the disqualifying conditions under AG ¶ 16 and the following are potentially applicable: (a) deliberate omiss
Conclusion
n, concealment, or falsification of relevant facts from any personnel security questionnaire, personal history statement, or similar form used to conduct investigations, determine employment qualifications, award bene