A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.
ISCR Case No. 25-00703
DeniedDecided Oct 7, 2026 · Administrative Judge Richard A. Cefola · Hearing
Case headnote
Summary
The applicant, a 51-year-old former U.S. Army Ranger with a history of psychological conditions, sought a security clearance under Guidelines I and E. He was diagnosed with Bipolar II Disorder and PTSD, and failed to follow a prescribed treatment plan, raising concerns about his judgment and reliability. Although he had previously been convicted of child abuse, this conduct was found to be mitigated due to successful counseling and the sealing of his court records. Ultimately, the judge denied the application due to unresolved psychological issues.
Why the applicant was denied
- The applicant failed to follow a prescribed treatment plan for his psychological conditions, which raised concerns about his judgment and reliability.
- A licensed clinical psychologist diagnosed the applicant with an unspecified personality disorder, indicating a serious personnel security risk due to emotional instability.
- The applicant is not currently under the care of a mental health professional, increasing the risk of symptom recurrence.
Conditions referenced
Disqualifying
- I.A Psychological Conditionsapplied
- I.B Psychological Conditionsapplied
- I.D Psychological Conditionsapplied
Mitigating
- E.D Personal Conductapplied
Key rule quoted
“The protection of the national security is the paramount consideration.”
Procedural posture
- SOR issued
- 03/16/2026
- Answer filed
- 04/16/2026
- Hearing held
- 08/11/2026
- Decision date
- 10/07/2026
Cite for
- Failure to Follow a Prescribed Treatment Plan Under Guideline I
- Serious Personnel Security Risk Due to Psychological Conditions
- Mitigation of Personal Conduct Issues Under Guideline E
Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.
From the decision
Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.
- Applicant Age
- 51
Allegations under Guideline E
Reading the 1 per allegation row needs a free account.
1 row in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Allegations under Guideline I
Reading the 2 per allegation rows needs a free account.
2 rows in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.
Full decision
Open original PDFThe complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.
Decision text, by section
______________ ______________ DEFENSE LEGAL SERVICES AGENCY DEFENSE OFFICE OF HEARINGS AND APPEALS In the matter of: )
)
)
ISCR Case No. 25-00703
) Applicant for Security Clearance ) Appearances For Government: Aubrey De Angelis, Esquire, Department Counsel For Applicant: Samir Nakhleh, Esquire, Applicant’s Counsel 10/07/2026 Decision CEFOLA, Richard A., Administrative Judge: On April 29, 2025, Applicant submitted his Electronic Questionnaire for Investigations Processing (e-QIP). On March 16, 2026, the Department of Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency (DCSA) issued Applicant a Statement of Reasons (SOR) detailing security concerns under Guidelines I and E. The action was taken under Executive Order 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry (February 20, 1960), as amended; Department of Defense Directive 5220.6, Defense Industrial Personnel Security Clearance Review Program (January 2, 1992), as amended (Directive); and the Adjudicative Guidelines effective June 8, 2017. Applicant answered the SOR (Answer), which included Applicant’s Exhibits (AppXs) A through J, in writing on April 16, 2026, and requested a hearing before an administrative judge. The Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA) received the request soon thereafter. I received the case assignment on July 1, 2026. DOHA issued a Notice of Hearing on July 6, 2026, and I convened the hearing as scheduled on August 11, 2026. The Government offered Exhibits (GXs) 1 through 6, which were received without objection. Applicant testified on his own behalf. He also asked that the record be kept open until September 4, 2026, for the receipt of additional documentation. On August
18, 2026, Applicant also offered AppX K, which was admitted without objection. No further post-hearing documents were offered; and as such, the record was closed on September 4, 2026. DOHA received the transcript of the hearing (TR) on August 24, 2026. Based upon a review of the pleadings, exhibits, and testimony, eligibility for access to classified information is denied. Findings of Fact In his Answer to the SOR Applicant denied the factual allegations in Subparagraph 1.a. of the SOR. He admitted the factual allegations in Subparagraphs 1.b. and 2.a. of the SOR, with explanations. He also provided additional information to support his request for eligibility for a security clearance. Applicant is 51 years old, married three times, but presently unmarried. He has two minor children, and one adult child. Applicant served in the U.S. Army as a Ranger from January 1993 until July 1998. He was medically discharged with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Applicant has a Bachelor of Science degree in Engineering Physics. He works for a defense contractor as Director of Program Management and Site Lead. (TR at page 5 lines 8~17, at page 11 line 10 to page 12 line 7, at page 12 line 17 to page 13 line 18, and GX 2 at pages 5, 11~14, 17~18, 20~23, and 25~27.) Guideline I – Psychological Conditions (These allegations will be discussed in chronological order.) 1.b. Applicant admits that in about June 2017 he was diagnosed as suffering from a Bipolar II Disorder in addition to PTSD. In about May 2020, Applicant stopped engaging in mental health treatment, and in about May 2022, he discontinued his psychotropic medications without consulting a mental health provider. (TR at page 35 line 23 to page 38 line 21, at page 43 line 16 to page 60 line 14, at page 86 line 3 to page 90 line 2, and GXs 3 and 5.) 1.a. Applicant was evaluated by a licensed clinical psychologist on September 16, 2024, who issued a “Report” on October 28, 2024. He diagnosed Applicant as suffering from an “Unspecified Personality Disorder with narcissistic and antisocial Features.” The psychologist noted, in part, the following: [T]his condition poses a serious personnel security risk due to inherent emotional instability and erratic changes in attitudes and behaviors. While . . . [Applicant] reports no symptoms at present, his lack of environmental stressors raises concerns about the likelihood of future symptom recurrence. Active, targeted treatment, such as psychotherapy or counseling, is the most effective way to mitigate psychological security risks. However, . . . [Applicant] is not currently under the care of a mental health professional, which increases his risk for symptom recurrence or functional decomposition. 2
Given these factors, . . . [Applicant’s] judgment, reliability, and trustworthiness are impaired due to his personality instability and lack of substantive treatment. I recommend that he seek treatment for his condition, as it is chronic and unlikely to resolve spontaneously. (GX 6 at page 6.) Applicant is currently not under the care of a mental health professional, and he has not offered any countervailing, more recent favorable diagnosis. Psychological Conditions is found against Applicant. (TR at page 19 line 4 to page 23 line 3, at page 40 line 5 to page 41 line 19, at page 90 line 3 to page 92 line 17, and GX 6.) Guideline E - Personal Conduct 2.a. Applicant admits that in March 2023 he was found guilty of child abuse. This is the result of incidents vis-a-vis his son in July and August of 2020, more than six years ago. Applicant has since given up custody of his minor children. He was placed on probation, successfully participated in counseling; and as a result, his court records have been sealed and the charge dismissed. Personal Conduct is found for Applicant. (TR at page 23 line 4 to page 24 line 2, at page 27 line 4 to page 35 line 22, at page 60 line 15 to page 84 line 1, and GX 3 and AppX K.) Policies When evaluating an applicant’s suitability for a security clearance, the administrative judge must consider the adjudicative guidelines (AG). In addition to brief introductory explanations for each guideline, the adjudicative guidelines list potentially disqualifying conditions and mitigating conditions, which are useful in evaluating an applicant’s eligibility for access to classified information. These guidelines are not inflexible rules of law. Instead, recognizing the complexities of human behavior, administrative judges apply the guidelines in conjunction with the factors listed in AG ¶ 2 describing the adjudicative process. The administrative judge’s overarching adjudicative goal is a fair, impartial, and commonsense decision. According to AG ¶ 2(a), the entire process is a conscientious scrutiny of a number of variables known as the whole-person concept. The administrative judge must consider all available, reliable information about the person, past and present, favorable and unfavorable, in making a decision. The protection of the national security is the paramount consideration. AG ¶ 2(b) requires that “[a]ny doubt concerning personnel being considered for national security eligibility will be resolved in favor of the national security.” In reaching this decision, I have drawn only those conclusions that are reasonable, logical and based on the evidence contained in the record. Likewise, I have avoided drawing inferences grounded on mere speculation or conjecture. 3
Under Directive ¶ E3.1.14, the Government must present evidence to establish controverted facts alleged in the SOR. Under Directive ¶ E3.1.15, an “applicant is responsible for presenting witnesses and other evidence to rebut, explain, extenuate, or mitigate facts admitted by the applicant or proven by Department Counsel, and has the ultimate burden of persuasion as to obtaining a favorable clearance decision.” A person who seeks access to classified information enters into a fiduciary relationship with the Government predicated upon trust and confidence. This relationship transcends normal duty hours and endures throughout off-duty hours. The Government reposes a high degree of trust and confidence in individuals to whom it grants access to classified information. Decisions include, by necessity, consideration of the possible risk the applicant may deliberately or inadvertently fail to protect or safeguard classified information. Such decisions entail a certain degree of legally permissible extrapolation as to potential, rather than actual, risk of compromise of classified information. Section 7 of Executive Order 10865 provides that decisions shall be “in terms of the national interest and shall in no sense be a determination as to the loyalty of the applicant concerned.” See also EO 12968, Section 3.1(b) (listing multiple prerequisites for access to classified or sensitive information). Analysis Guideline I – Psychological Conditions The security concern relating to the guideline for Psychological Conditions is set forth at AG ¶ 27: Certain emotional, mental, and personality conditions can impair judgment, reliability, or trustworthiness. A formal diagnosis of a disorder is not required for there to be a concern under this guideline. A duly qualified mental health professional (e.g. clinical psychologist or psychiatrist) employed by, or acceptable to and approved by the U.S. Government, should be consulted when evaluating potentially disqualifying and mitigating information under this guideline and an opinion, including prognosis, should be sought. No negative inference concerning the standards in this guideline may be raised solely on the basis of mental health counseling. The guideline at AG ¶ 28 contains five conditions that could raise a security concern and may be disqualifying. Three conditions are established: (a) behavior that casts doubt on an individual’s judgment, stability, reliability, or trustworthiness, not covered under any other guideline and that may indicate an emotional, mental, or personality condition, including, but not limited to, irresponsible, violent, self-harm, suicidal, paranoid, manipulative, impulsive, chronic lying, deceitful, exploitative, or bizarre behaviors; 4
(b) an opinion by a duly qualified mental health professional that the individual has a condition that may impair judgment, stability, reliability, or trustworthiness; and (d) failure to follow a prescribed treatment plan related to a diagnosed psychological/psychiatric condition that may impair judgment, stability, reliability, or trustworthiness, including but not limited to failure to take prescribed medication or failure to attend required counseling sessions. Applicant has been diagnosed by a duly qualified mental health professional as suffering from a condition that may impair judgment, stability, reliability, or trustworthiness. He has failed to follow a prescribed treatment plan related to that diagnosed psychological condition. Therefore, AG ¶ 28 is established. The guideline at AG ¶ 29 contains five conditions that could mitigate security concerns. Five conditions may be applicable: (a) the identified condition is readily controllable with treatment, and the individual has demonstrated ongoing and consistent compliance with the treatment plan; (b) the individual has voluntarily entered a counseling or treatment program for a condition that is amenable to treatment, and the individual is currently receiving counseling or treatment with a favorable prognosis by a duly qualified metal health professional; (c) recent opinion by a duly qualified mental health professional employed by, or acceptable to and approved by, or acceptable to and approved by the U.S. Government that an individual’s previous condition is under control or in remission, and has a low probability of recurrence or exacerbation; (d) the past psychological/psychiatric condition was temporary, the situation has been resolved, and the individual no longer shows indications of emotional instability; and (e) there is no indication of a current problem. None of these apply. Applicant’s condition is not temporary or readily controlled, he is receiving no counseling, and there is indication of a current problem. Therefore, AG ¶ 29 is not established. Psychological Conditions is found against Applicant. Guideline E - Personal Conduct The security concern relating to the guideline for Personal Conduct is set out in AG ¶ 15: 5
Conduct involving questionable judgment, lack of candor, dishonesty, or unwillingness to comply with rules and regulations can raise questions about an individual's reliability, trustworthiness, and ability to protect classified or sensitive information. Of special interest is any failure to cooperate or provide truthful and candid answers during national security investigative or adjudicative processes. The guideline notes several conditions that could raise security concerns under AG ¶ 16. One is potentially applicable in this case: (d) credible adverse information that is not explicitly covered under any other guideline and may not be sufficient by itself for an adverse determination, but which, when combined with all available information, supports a whole-person assessment of questionable judgment, untrustworthiness, unreliability, lack of candor, unwillingness to comply with rules and regulations, or other characteristics indicating that the individual may not properly safeguard classified or sensitive information. This includes, but is not limited to, consideration of: (1) untrustworthy or unreliable behavior to include breach of client confidentiality, release of proprietary information, unauthorized release of sensitive corporate or government protected information; (2) any disruptive, violent, or other inappropriate behavior; (3) a pattern of dishonesty or rule violations; and (4) evidence of significant misuse of Government or other employer's time or resources. Applicant physically abused his male child in 2020. Clearly it was inappropriate behavior. The evidence is sufficient to raise this disqualifying condition. AG ¶ 17 provides conditions that could mitigate security concerns. I considered all of the mitigating conditions under AG ¶ 17 including: (c) the offense is so minor, or so much time has passed, or the behavior is so infrequent, or it happened under such unique circumstances that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on the individual's reliability, trustworthiness, or good judgment; and (d) the individual has acknowledged the behavior and obtained counseling to change the behavior or taken other positive steps to alleviate the stressors, circumstances, or factors that contributed to untrustworthy, 6
unreliable, or other inappropriate behavior, and such behavior is unlikely to recur. Applicant’s conduct occurred more than six years ago. He has successfully navigated the court system resulting in the allegation being sealed and dismissed. Applicant has also given up custody of his minor son and received counseling; and as such, has little contact with him. Such behavior is unlikely to recur. Personal Conduct is found for Applicant. Whole-Person Concept Under the whole-person concept, the administrative judge must evaluate an applicant’s eligibility for a security clearance by considering the totality of an applicant’s conduct and all the circumstances. The administrative judge should consider the nine adjudicative process factors listed at AG ¶ 2(d): (1) the nature, extent, and seriousness of the conduct; (2) the circumstances surrounding the conduct, to include knowledgeable participation; (3) the frequency and recency of the conduct; (4) the individual’s age and maturity at the time of the conduct; (5) the extent to which participation is voluntary; (6) the presence or absence of rehabilitation and other permanent behavioral changes; (7) the motivation for the conduct; (8) the potential for pressure, coercion, exploitation, or duress; and (9) the likelihood of continuation or recurrence. AG ¶ 2(b) requires each case must be judged on its own merits. Under AG ¶ 2(c), the ultimate determination of whether to grant eligibility for a security clearance must be an overall commonsense judgment based upon careful consideration of the guidelines and the whole-person concept. I considered the potentially disqualifying and mitigating conditions in light of all the facts and circumstances surrounding this case. Applicant is clearly respected in the workplace. (AppXs B~J.) However, overall, the record evidence leaves me with questions and doubts as to Applicant’s eligibility and suitability for a security clearance. For all these reasons, I conclude Applicant failed to mitigate the security concerns arising from his Psychological Conditions. Formal Findings Formal findings for or against Applicant on the allegations set forth in the SOR, as required by ¶ E3.1.25 of Enclosure 3 of the Directive, are: Paragraph 1, Guideline I: AGAINST APPLICANT Subparagraphs 1.a. and 1.b: Against Applicant 7
_________________ Paragraph 2, Guideline E: FOR APPLICANT Subparagraph 2.a: For Applicant Conclusion In light of all of the circumstances presented by the record in this case, it is not clearly consistent with the national interest to grant Applicant national security eligibility for a security clearance. Eligibility for access to classified information is denied. Richard A. Cefola Administrative Judge 8