A decided public DOHA case, shown for research, not advice or a prediction.
ISCR Case No. 26-00049
DeniedDecided Oct 26, 2026 · Administrative Judge Mark W. Harvey · Hearing
Case headnote
Summary
The applicant, a 28-year-old senior data system administrator, faced security clearance denial under Guidelines D (sexual behavior), E (personal conduct), and J (criminal conduct) due to allegations of sexual assault and subsequent misconduct leading to an other than honorable discharge from the military. The judge found that the applicant's conduct raised significant security concerns that were not mitigated by his explanations or claims of innocence.
Why the applicant was denied
- The applicant was charged with sexual assault and issued a military protective order.
- He received an other than honorable discharge for misconduct related to the sexual assault charge.
- The applicant's admissions and explanations regarding his conduct were not credible or sufficient to mitigate security concerns.
Conditions referenced
Disqualifying
- E2.A5.1 Criminal conductraised
- E2.A5.2 Sexual behaviorraised
- E2.A5.3 Personal conductraised
Key rule quoted
“The security clearance decision must be based on the whole person concept, considering all relevant factors, including the applicant's conduct and circumstances surrounding it.”
Procedural posture
- SOR issued
- 03/24/2026
- Answer filed
- 06/20/2026
- Hearing held
- 10/05/2026 via Microsoft Teams
- Decision date
- 10/21/2026
Cite for
- Denial of Security Clearance Due to Serious Allegations of Sexual Misconduct
- Impact of Military Discharge Characterization on Security Clearance Eligibility
- Credibility of Applicant's Explanations in the Context of Security Concerns
Editorial summary generated for research. Not legal advice; not a prediction. Verify against the full decision before relying on any quoted language.
From the decision
Facts this decision states, each with the sentence it comes from. Descriptive of the record, not an assessment.
- Applicant Age
- 28
- Bankruptcy
- none
Allegations under Guideline D
Reading the 1 per allegation row needs a free account.
1 row in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Allegations under Guideline E
Reading the 3 per allegation rows needs a free account.
3 rows in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Allegations under Guideline J
Reading the 1 per allegation row needs a free account.
1 row in this decision.
It opens the per allegation record on every guideline: the amounts, the findings, and the sentence behind each row.
Descriptive standardized rendering of a decided public case. The verbatim source decision is below.
Full decision
Open original PDFThe complete official text, footnotes and signatures included, is in the original PDF.
Decision text, by section
Appearances
J (criminal conduct), and D (sexual behavior) are not mitigated. Eligibility for access to classifie
Decision
information is denied. Statement of the Case On February 24, 2025, Applicant completed a security clearance application (SCA). (Government Exhibit (GE) 1) On March 24, 2026, the Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency
Statement of Case
DCSA) issued a statement of reasons (SOR) to Applicant under Executive Order (Exec. Or.) 10865, Safeguarding Classified Information within Industry (February 20, 1960); Department of Defense (DoD) Directive 5220.6, Defense Industrial Personnel Security Clearance Review Program (Directive) (January 2, 1992), as amended; and Security Executive Agent Directive 4, establishing in Appendix A, the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines for Determining Eligibility for Access to Classified Information or Eligibility to Hold a Sensitive Position (AGs), effective June 8, 2017. (Hearing Exhibit (HE) 1) The SOR detailed reasons why DCSA did not find under the Directive that it is clearly consistent with the interests of national security to grant or continue a security clearance for Applicant and stated his case would be submitted to an administrat
Findings of Fact
ve judge for a determination whether to grant, deny, or revoke his security clearance. Specifically,
the SOR set forth security concerns arising under Guidelines D, J, and E. (HE 1) On June 20, 2026, Applicant responded to the SOR. (HE 2) On August 21, 2026, Department Counsel was ready to proceed. On September 4, 2026, the case was assigned to me. On September 17, 2026, the Defense Office of Hearings and Appeals (DOHA) issued a notice scheduling the hearing for October 5, 2026. (HE 3) The hearing was held as scheduled, using the Microsoft Teams video teleconference system. During the hearing, Department Counsel offered five exhibits; Applicant did not offer any exhibits; there were no objections; and all proffered exhibits were admitted into evidence. (Tr. 12-14; GE 1-GE 5) The record was not held op
Policies
pdf 37) Applicant’s statement is the only statement from the MCIO materials provided for admission into evidence at his security clearance hearing. In his MCIO statement, Applicant said he went to several bars, and he consumed an excessive amount of alcohol. (GE 3 at 5-6, .pdf 41-42) He vomited in the bathroom of the third bar, and he went to additional bars where he consumed more alcohol. (GE 3 at 6, .pdf 42) The MCIO videotaped and recorded Applicant’s interview, and it occurred over a three-hour period. He described what happened after leaving the last bar in an MCIO summary of interview as follows: His next memory after being at the aforementioned bar was being awakened by a taxi driver at his barracks [in an overseas location]. He recalled that he went to his room and couldn’t get in his bathroom as the door to his bathroom was locked. He believed that he had to urinate once he arrived at his room, so he likely urinated in his sink. He believes that this happened as he recalled seeing urine around his sink the next morning. He related that he might have vomited after arriving at his room, but he didn’t know where he vomited, possibly in his sink. He didn’t see vomit the next day anywhere in the room. He wasn’t sure, but he might have changed his clothes after arriving in his room. He wasn’t sure if anyone was in his room when he arrived, but he left his room door unlocked when he went out for the ev
Analysis
ning with [name omitted]. [Applicant] next recalled being awakened in his bed by sunlight coming through his curtains over his window. When he awoke, [Sgt G] was lying next to him naked and asleep. [Applicant] awakened [Sgt G] by shaking her. He then recalled that [Sgt G] rolled over and opened her legs, so [Applicant] began to perform cunnilingus on her. He then began to have sexual intercourse with her during which he tried to kiss her, but she turned her head to one side away from him. He recalled seeing her eyes open, but he wasn’t sure if her eyes remained open while he had sex with her. He then stopped to put on a condom, but he couldn’t recall if he used the condom or just opened it and held it in his hand. He recalled that when he began to cuddle with her after getting the condom, she pushed him away, so he didn’t continue to have sexual intercourse with her. Instead, he told her he was sorry, grabbed a blanket, and slept on the floor. 4
* * *
After awaking later that day, [Applicant] texted [Sgt G] to apologize and try to determine how she felt about having had sex with him. He also wanted to know what she recalled and hoped she could help him recall specifically what had happened between the two of them. [Applicant] related that he apologized [to Sgt G] because he had observed blood on his bed sheets and figured that he had raped her which caused her to bleed on his bed. He also recalled that there were items that appeared to have been thrown around his room and were out of place; he recalled having cleaned his room prior to going out the night before. (GE 3 at 5-7, .pdf 41-43) At his hearing, Applicant said in 2023, he was a sergeant, and his specialty was data systems administrator. (Tr. 16) Sgt G was a female assigned to his unit but not to his section, and Applicant knew her for several months before he engaged in sexual activity with her in May 2023. (Tr. 20-22) She lived in the same barracks as Applicant. (Tr. 27) At his hearing, Applicant said in May 2023, he went to several bars with members in his unit. (Tr. 17-19) He said Sgt G was with Applicant and the person who had a nearby room and shared a bathroom with him in the barracks, JP. During part of the evening, Applicant separated from Sgt G and went to a different bar. (Tr. 22-23) Toward the end of the outing at a bar, he “started to black out” from alcohol consumption. (Tr. 25) At one point, he observed Sgt G at a bar kissing JP, who was intoxicated. (Tr. 26-27) Sgt G agreed to ensure that Applicant and JP made it safely back to the barracks. (Tr. 27-28) Applicant said that he saw Sgt G and JP use the same taxi to return to the barracks. (Tr. 28, 50) He believed something may have happened between Sgt G and JP when they were alone in Applicant’s barracks room. The evidence to support this theory was JP’s statement that he wanted to apologize to Sgt G; his room was in disarray when he arrived several hours after Sgt G and JP left the bar; JP was sleeping on the bathroom floor, which was between JP and Applicant’s room; and Sgt G was in his room when he arrived. (Tr. 50-51) He conceded that he did not know if anything happened between JP and Sgt G before he arrived at his barracks room. (Tr. 44) Applicant said he continued drinking about three hours after his friends went back to the barracks, and he said, “either I got a taxi or one of my friends, they know where I live, they put me in a taxi or escorted me to a taxi and told them where to take me.” (Tr. 28) He estimated that he drank 15 or 16 beers over the course of the evening and early morning before going to his barracks room. (Tr. 46) He said he arrived at the barracks at about 5:30 am. (Tr. 29) Applicant said he was “pretty sure” he engaged in cunnilingus on Sgt G. (Tr. 33) However, the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) summary of interview states: 5
Another [unit member] named [JP], got Subject and [JP] an Uber back at their barracks. There, [JP] passed out in Subject’s bathroom. Shortly thereafter [Sgt G] came to Subject’s room. Subject does not recall how it happened but remembers [Sgt G] pulled Subject to her and they kissed. Subject does not believe anything else occur[ed] between [Sgt G] and Subject.
* * * Subject’s Master Sergeant took Subject to the offices of the [MCIO] where Subject was informed he was under investigation for sexual assault. [Sgt G] reported that Subject sexually assaulted her that morning in Subject’s room. Subject denies this ever happened and the [MCIO] eventually found Subject innocent in 10/2024. Subject provided the following factors he believes were considered in f inding Subject innocent of the charges: [Sgt G] had reported being sexually assaulted on six other occasions while in [a U.S. armed force], further details unknown; [Sgt G] came to Subject’s room; There was a delay of one week between the alleged incident and [Sgt G] reporting the incident; There was no DNA evidence or semen in a condom found in Subject’s trash can to indicate intercourse occurred; Subject had been a Sexual Assault Prevention/Readiness Victim Advocate since 2022 and trained to prevent just such events from happening or to assist victims of sexual assault; and Subject had a pristine military record w
ith no problems, . . . , or writeups. Despite b
eing held i nnocent, Subject’s commanding officer, [a lieutenant colonel], put in a request for an Administrative Board to review Subject’s conduct and continued enlistment. (GE 5 at 5, .pdf 95 (emphasis added)) At his hearing, Applicant claimed that he told the OPM investigator that he engaged in cunnilingus with Sgt G; however, this information was not included in the OPM summary. (Tr. 34) When he told the investigator that the MCIO found him to be “innocent,” he meant he was not convicted of a crime. (Tr. 63-64) At his hearing, Applicant said when he arrived at his barracks room, Sgt G was already there, and she was nude. (Tr. 42-43) He was “pretty sure” that before he arrived, she threw her clothing around his room because she had difficulty finding her clothing the next morning. (Tr. 42-43) Later in his hearing, he said, “I don’t remember [JP] or [Sgt G] being in my room upon arrival. I just remember laying straight down with no issues. I remember my room being a mess, but I don’t remember people being in it.” (Tr. 45) At his hearing, Applicant said at the time of the MCIO interview, he believed that he raped Sgt G. (Tr. 46) He explained why he now believes he did not engage in sexual intercourse with Sgt G as follows: 6
I don’t remember having sex. And I remember that I think it almost led to sex, and I attempted to put a condom on, but I couldn’t even get erect, at the time, because in the trash can there was a condom that was open but it was not used. And I believe she was on her menstrual cycle and there was no blood on it. So, I don’t think we even had sex or intercourse at all, from my recollection. I think I just attempted to put the condom on and then nothing and just decided not to even do anything from that time frame. (Tr. 36) Applicant said that he “was super drunk during the occurrence. [He] was blacked out,” and he did not remember most of what occurred when he was in bed with Sgt G. (Tr. 45) The following exchange occurred between Applicant and Department Counsel (DC): DC: Do you remember whether or not you penetrated Sergeant [G] with your -- with your penis? Applicant: I highly doubt it. I don’t recall, no, but I highly doubt it. DC: Okay. But you – you – you don’t have a recollection and you don’t know. Is that a fair statement? Applicant: I would say the fair statement is I don’t know, but I’m pretty sure I didn’t because the condom was unused. . . . (Tr. 38) Applicant agreed with his statement to the MCIO investigator that when Sgt G pushed him away, he stopped the sexual activity. (Tr. 39) He conceded that he probably used the term “sex” to the MCIO investigator; however, he was not referring to sexual intercourse. (Tr. 39) Department Counsel asked him if he told Sgt G that he was sorry after he engaged in sexual activity with her, and he replied, “I don’t recall my exact words, no.” (Tr. 39) Applicant said, the next day, he sent Sgt G a text because “there was like a big pool of blood on my bed;” and JP also wanted to apologize to her. (Tr. 44, 48) However, he did not know why JP wanted to apologize to Sgt G. (Tr. 48-49) The day after the sexual incident in Applicant’s barracks room, Applicant and JP went to Sgt G’s room to apologize and find out what she remembered; however, she did not answer when they knocked on her door. (Tr. 52) Later, he sent Sgt G a text in which he said he was going to turn himself in to the military police. (Tr. 53) He was going to report the incident to the military police because he was a victim advocate for people who were sexually assaulted, and his mother was a victim of rape. (Tr. 53, 76) Applicant said he was innocent of the sexual assault for the following reasons: I just don’t believe that I initiated anything with her. I’m pretty sure from gathering what I gathered that she went into the room to have sex with [JP]. 7
Within the Admin Sep Board, she said that she would never have sex on her menstrual cycle or do anything of that matter. But the -- the fact of the matter is she was in my room, she was naked, and she got in the bed, and she was doing something with [JP] to make him lock himself in the room. So, it was like, okay, if you lied about that, what else would you be lying about? So, it was like one of those types o
Whole Person Concept
things. (Tr. 65) Applicant did not believe that Sgt G was as intoxicated during the sexual incident as she claimed to be. (Tr. 68-69) Applicant stated: I don’t believe she was passed out, for one. I don’t believe that I was the one who had the -- I don’t think I had sex with her at all. I do remember having oral sex. I don’t know -- I don’t – I never had intercourse with her. And as well as a statement of hers saying that she would never have sex on her menstrual cycle or do anything with anyone, I also believe that was a lie. (Tr. 69) Applicant believed that Sgt G wanted to engage in sex with JP, not Applicant, and that Applicant engaged in sexual activity (cunnilingus) with her. (Tr. 69) Applicant’s administrative separation board Applicant was represented by counsel at his separation board. (Tr. 58) He had access to the MCIO report of investigation including the videotaped interviews. (Tr. 58- 59) Sgt G testified at Applicant’s separation board. (Tr. 59) She said her alcohol consumption impaired her memory. (Tr. 59) The summary of her statement at the separation board concerning the sexual assault is as follows: I know [JP] and [another unit member] from work. There were around 150 [armed forces personnel] in the unit, so we got to interact with everyone. Due to my billet, I had to interact with them more on a professional standpoint. I have not expressed interests in either of them. . . . I remember going to several bars and I was drinking. I do not remember how many drinks I had. I don’t remember what time I left . . . or how I got back to the barracks. . . . I don’t remember going in [Applicant’s] room. I remember waking up and seeing [Applicant] on top of me. I used to struggle to sleep after that. I remember his confused face before he got off me. I was worried about myself more than [Applicant] and when I looked at myself, l was naked. I stood up and because I had started my period, I reached down to feel my tampon string and I couldn’t. After that I was trying to find my clothes. Eventually, I found my stuff, and I got out of there as fast as I could . . . . I do not remember [Applicant] performing oral sex or sex with me. I do not recall him kissing me. I don’t recall wrapping my legs around him. I know that he did not have a shirt on. After he got off me, I was focused on grabbing my stuff and leaving. I regularly use tampons and depending on 8
what day it is I use different sizes. So, the first and second days I use a bigger size and that night I was using a bigger size. It’s not uncomfortable but I know it’s there. There would never have been a situation where I wou
Formal Findings
t. To this day that affects me. Sometimes I don’t know how to deal with it. It’s been very hard. . . . I filed an expedited transfer after this. . . . I’ve been using tampons since I was 15 and I’d know if it was pushed too far up and that is not something I would do myself. . . . I usually do not drink. That night [Applicant] was not buying my drinks. I hung out with multiple people that night. I showed no romantic interests in [JP], but l made out with him that night. I had roughly 5-6 drinks that night including shots. Around 3 am I texted [another unit m
Conclusion
mber] stating that I was babysitting the other [unit members]. I don’t remember leaving with [JP] in a taxi going back to barracks. I do not remember walking into the barracks and walking into my room or [Applicant’s] room and takin