Guideline K: Handling Protected Information
What is Guideline K, Handling Protected Information?
Basis: 296 decided hearing-level ISCR cases raising Guideline K. Descriptive history of decided cases, not a prediction.
Decided hearing cases
296
Ruled for the applicant on this guideline
53%
156 for · 137 against · 1 not recorded
Whole case granted
44%
129 granted · 167 denied
The first percentage is the judge's formal finding on Guideline K itself. The second is how the whole case ended, and a case can be denied on a different guideline: in 28 of the 167 denied cases (17%), the judge had ruled for the applicant on Guideline K. A granted case counts as a ruling for the applicant. The 1 cases with no ruling recorded were all denied, and they stay in the first percentage's base so that it is not flattered. 2 cases in which the concern was withdrawn are left out of it.
Specific issues and how the cases alleging them ended
Failure to safeguard / secure
39% granted · 63 granted · 97 denied
Information handling (unspecified)
57% granted · 66 granted · 49 denied
Unauthorized disclosure
30% granted · 23 granted · 54 denied
Removed classified to personal space
54% granted · 20 granted · 17 denied
Cross domain violation
34% granted · 10 granted · 19 denied
Improperly compiled / used protected info
38% granted · 10 granted · 16 denied
Each bar counts the outcome of the whole case in which the issue was alleged, not the judge's ruling on that issue. A case that raised the issue and was denied on a different ground counts as denied here.
Mitigations judges credited most
- Inadequate training1
- Inadvertent1
- Isolated1
- Time elapsed1
- Time elapsed since behavior1
Counted only where the judge expressly credited the mitigation, not merely where it was claimed.
What the reference material says about protected-information cases
- Pattern and recency drive these cases in the published record: repeated recent violations are denied at high rates, while old, isolated lapses followed by clean conduct and remedial training have been mitigated. (Practitioner case reviews)
From our verified reference library: paraphrased from the named sources and reviewed before publication. Descriptive background, not legal advice about any case.
How the process worksA contested case follows a published sequence. Open this for the short version, or put a question to Ask Mode on the home page. Accounts are free and include up to 25 questions per day.
A contested case follows a published path: a Statement of Reasons, the government's written list of its concerns (an SOR), a written answer, a hearing or a decision on the written record, the judge's decision, and in some cases an appeal.
Read the stages of a DOHA case · Ask a question about the process
Where to go from here
Get help with my case
Send us your question, or the Statement of Reasons you received. No charge, and a CASE analyst reads it. Usually five to ten business days.
Ask a question →I do this for clients
Rank every decision by how closely it matches a matter, see how the assigned judge has ruled, and keep it together with cited exports.
For attorneys and firms →Descriptive statistics from decided public DOHA cases. Not legal advice or a prediction. † marks samples under 20 cases.