Statistics
Outcome patterns across decided public DOHA cases. The filters below narrow the view by concern, time period, representation, and judge. Descriptive statistics, not predictions. Data through October 2026.
Reference dates for comparisons: the current adjudicative guidelines took effect in June 2017, and updated marijuana guidance was issued in December 2021.
Key findings
Cases in view
21
decided public DOHA cases
Hearing decisions
21
decided after a hearing or on the written record
Appeal decisions
0
Appeal Board decisions, counted separately
Decisions span 2003 to 2003
Using this page: the filters above narrow every section, selecting a chart row opens the cases underneath it, and each section downloads as a CSV file.
Grant rates over time
How often clearances were granted, by year.
29% granted overall (6 of 21). Yearly rates ranged 29 to 29% where the yearly sample is large enough.
Swipe the chart for earlier years. Select any year to filter the page to it.
How to read this chart
Grey bars count the decisions published in each year, read against the left axis. The blue line is the grant rate for that year, read against the right axis, and it is drawn only for years with 20 or more decided cases. The shaded band over 1999 and 2000 marks two years when very few decisions were published: DOHA published few decisions online before 2002, and almost none survive for those two years. The dashed lines mark the June 2017 adjudicative guidelines and the December 2021 marijuana guidance taking effect. They do not claim that either change caused what the chart shows.
Outcomes by concern
How the cases raising each concern ended, and how the judge ruled on the concern itself.
- E · Personal Conduct
23% granted · 64 granted · 217 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 32% of 281 cases decided on it (89 for, 191 against, 1 not recorded).
- Falsified the security form
11% granted · 14 granted · 117 denied
- Omission / failure to disclose
27% granted · 28 granted · 75 denied
- Personal conduct (unspecified)
28% granted · 25 granted · 64 denied
- Lack of candor in an interview
16% granted · 9 granted · 49 denied
- Questionable judgment
30% granted · 11 granted · 26 denied
- Pattern of dishonesty / rule violations
10% granted · 2 granted · 19 denied
- Falsified the security form
- B · Foreign Influence
60% granted · 128 granted · 84 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 67% of 212 cases decided on it (143 for, 62 against, 7 not recorded).
- Foreign relationship (unspecified)
58% granted · 75 granted · 54 denied
- Parent in a foreign country
62% granted · 79 granted · 49 denied
- Sibling in a foreign country
63% granted · 63 granted · 37 denied
- Spouse dual / foreign citizen
47% granted · 22 granted · 25 denied
- In law in foreign country
63% granted · 29 granted · 17 denied
- Extended family in foreign country
50% granted · 22 granted · 22 denied
- Friend in foreign country
64% granted · 16 granted · 9 denied
- Financial support to foreign relative
50% granted · 10 granted · 10 denied
- Foreign relationship (unspecified)
- F · Financial Considerations
31% granted · 58 granted · 131 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 34% of 189 cases decided on it (65 for, 120 against, 4 not recorded).
- Financial (unspecified)
30% granted · 50 granted · 119 denied
- Credit-card debt
29% granted · 15 granted · 36 denied
- Unpaid taxes
28% granted · 13 granted · 34 denied
- Bankruptcy filing
38% granted · 10 granted · 16 denied
- Utility / phone debt
19% granted · 5 granted · 21 denied
- Auto-loan debt
24% granted · 6 granted · 19 denied
- Civil judgment against applicant
8% granted · 2 granted · 22 denied
- Financial (unspecified)
- J · Criminal Conduct
16% granted · 30 granted · 157 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 24% of 187 cases decided on it (45 for, 141 against, 1 not recorded).
- Criminal conduct (unspecified)
14% granted · 16 granted · 100 denied
- DUI / DWI (criminal)
15% granted · 6 granted · 33 denied
- Drug related criminal charge
5% granted · 2 granted · 36 denied
- Fraud / deception criminal
6% granted · 2 granted · 32 denied
- Theft / larceny
11% granted · 3 granted · 24 denied
- Assault / battery
12% granted · 3 granted · 23 denied
- Criminal conduct (unspecified)
- C · Foreign Preference
56% granted · 66 granted · 52 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 62% of 118 cases decided on it (73 for, 43 against, 2 not recorded).
- Foreign passport possession / use
54% granted · 50 granted · 42 denied
- Foreign citizenship acquisition / application
52% granted · 41 granted · 38 denied
- Failure to renounce / surrender foreign status
55% granted · 28 granted · 23 denied
- Foreign preference (unspecified)
54% granted · 27 granted · 23 denied
- Foreign military / government service
62% granted · 16 granted · 10 denied
- Foreign passport possession / use
- G · Alcohol Consumption
26% granted · 21 granted · 60 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 43% of 81 cases decided on it (35 for, 46 against).
- DUI / DWI (alcohol)
25% granted · 15 granted · 44 denied
- Binge / intoxication pattern
22% granted · 13 granted · 45 denied
- Alcohol incident (unspecified)
30% granted · 12 granted · 28 denied
- Alcohol use disorder diagnosed
27% granted · 8 granted · 22 denied
- Continued use after treatment
8% granted · 2 granted · 24 denied
- Treatment non compliance
13% granted · 3 granted · 21 denied
- DUI / DWI (alcohol)
- H · Drug Involvement and Substance Misuse
21% granted · 15 granted · 58 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 34% of 73 cases decided on it (25 for, 48 against).
- Marijuana
22% granted · 14 granted · 50 denied
- Drug involvement (unspecified)
18% granted · 8 granted · 36 denied
- Marijuana
- D · Sexual Behavior
29% granted · 6 granted · 15 denied
On the concern itself the judge ruled for the applicant in 43% of 21 cases decided on it (9 for, 10 against, 2 not recorded).
Too few cases to break this concern into specific issues.
- L · Outside Activities
33% granted · 2 granted · 4 denied
Too few cases to break this concern into specific issues.
- K · Handling Protected Information
40% granted · 2 granted · 3 denied
Too few cases to break this concern into specific issues.
- M · Use of Information Technology
40% granted · 2 granted · 3 denied
Too few cases to break this concern into specific issues.
- I · Psychological Conditions
0% granted · 0 granted · 3 denied
Too few cases to break this concern into specific issues.
† marks fewer than 20 cases, too few to be reliable. A case can raise several concerns, so the rows overlap.
Mitigations judges credited most
How often each mitigation was expressly accepted by the judge, not merely claimed, across the cases in this view. This is a count of how often something was credited, so the bars are neutral: they carry no outcome.
Outcomes by representation
Whether represented and self-represented applicants were granted at different rates.
Represented by a lawyer
33% granted · 3 granted · 6 denied
Self-represented
25% granted · 3 granted · 9 denied
Difference
1.3 times
the grant rate with a lawyer
| Representation | Cases | Granted | Denied | Grant rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-represented | 12 | 3 | 9 | |
| Represented by a lawyer | 9 | 3 | 6 |
- Cases
- 12
- Granted
- 3
- Denied
- 9
- Grant rate
- Cases
- 9
- Granted
- 3
- Denied
- 6
- Grant rate
An association, not proof of cause: the groups being compared differ in many ways. Select a row to filter the page.
Outcomes by judge
How the cases each judge decided were resolved.
| Administrative Judge | Cases | Granted | Denied | Grant rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wilford H. Ross | 3 | 1 | 2 | Filter |
| Paul J. Mason | 2 | 1 | 1 | Filter |
| Philip S. Howe | 2 | 0 | 2 | Filter |
| John Grattan Metz, Jr. | 2 | 0 | 2 | Filter |
| Elizabeth M. Matchinski | 2 | 0 | 2 | Filter |
| Barry M. Sax | 1 | 0 | 1 | Filter |
| Kathryn Moen Braeman | 1 | 0 | 1 | Filter |
| Matthew E. Malone | 1 | 0 | 1 | Filter |
| Richard A. Cefola | 1 | 0 | 1 | Filter |
| Roger E. Willmeth | 1 | 0 | 1 | Filter |
| Joseph Testan | 1 | 1 | 0 | Filter |
| Burt Smith | 1 | 1 | 0 | Filter |
| Claude R. Heiny II | 1 | 1 | 0 | Filter |
| Darlene Lokey Anderson | 1 | 0 | 1 | Filter |
| James A. Young | 1 | 1 | 0 | Filter |
- Cases
- 3
- Granted
- 1
- Denied
- 2
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 2
- Granted
- 1
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 2
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 2
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 2
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 2
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 2
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 2
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 1
- Denied
- 0
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 1
- Denied
- 0
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 1
- Denied
- 0
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 0
- Denied
- 1
- Grant rate
- Filter
- Cases
- 1
- Granted
- 1
- Denied
- 0
- Grant rate
- Filter
† marks judges with fewer than 20 decided cases in this window. Judges hear different mixes of cases, so these rates describe the decided record, not the judges.
Appeal outcomes
How appealed decisions were treated by the Appeal Board.
No appeal decisions match this selection.
Questions about these statistics
The statistics assistant is part of Professional.
The statistics on this page are free, with or without a subscription.
It answers questions about the figures on this page, inside the filters you have set, with the denominator behind every number.
Professional plan detailsPublications and measured series
Ongoing analyses computed from the decided record, each on its own page, with its method and the counts behind every rate.
- Measured timelines
How long each stage took, measured from dates stated in the decisions.
- Time since the conduct
How long before the decision the last incident occurred.
- Candor in the record
How falsification and omission allegations were resolved.
- Veterans in the record
Decisions that state United States military service, counted by branch.
- Decisions by country
Foreign-influence decisions arranged by the country involved.
- The Issue Encyclopedia
Every specific issue inside each guideline, with its decided record.
- The statutory bars
The bars set by statute, and how they appear in decided cases.
- Docket reports
The decided record summarized the same way every quarter and every year.
Granted ÷ decided; † marks groups under 20 cases. Full methodology
Reading the statistics
- Granted = access granted or continued; Denied = denied or revoked.
- Grant rate = granted ÷ (granted + denied).
- † marks figures based on fewer than 20 cases, too few to be reliable.
- Hovering any rate shows its statistical range (a 95% confidence interval).
- Figures are descriptive counts over decided, public DOHA ISCR decisions, never predictions or assessments of any pending case.
Decided public cases: descriptive, never a prediction.