Skip to content

Statistics

Outcome patterns across decided public DOHA cases. The filters below narrow the view by concern, time period, representation, and judge. Descriptive statistics, not predictions. Data through October 2026.

Years
to
Concern
Representation

Reference dates for comparisons: the current adjudicative guidelines took effect in June 2017, and updated marijuana guidance was issued in December 2021.

Key findings

Cases in view

332

decided public DOHA cases

Hearing decisions

322

decided after a hearing or on the written record

Appeal decisions

10

Appeal Board decisions, counted separately

Granted overall

14%

44 granted of 322 decided

Granted with counsel

23%

20 granted of 86 decided

Granted self-represented

10%

24 granted of 236 decided

Range across judges

5 to 56%

grant rate across the 42 busiest judges, 2017 to 2026

Most common concern

Guideline F

Financial Considerations · 24% granted of 430 decided

Decisions span 1996 to 2022

View these cases

Using this page: the filters above narrow every section, selecting a chart row opens the cases underneath it, and each section downloads as a CSV file.

Grant rates over time

How often clearances were granted, by year.

14% granted overall (44 of 322). Yearly rates ranged 10 to 19% where the yearly sample is large enough.

Swipe the chart for earlier years. Select any year to filter the page to it.

How to read this chart

Grey bars count the decisions published in each year, read against the left axis. The blue line is the grant rate for that year, read against the right axis, and it is drawn only for years with 20 or more decided cases. The shaded band over 1999 and 2000 marks two years when very few decisions were published: DOHA published few decisions online before 2002, and almost none survive for those two years. The dashed lines mark the June 2017 adjudicative guidelines and the December 2021 marijuana guidance taking effect. They do not claim that either change caused what the chart shows.

Outcomes by concern

How the cases raising each concern ended, and how the judge ruled on the concern itself.

Each bar is granted against denied for the whole case, counted per concern: a case raising more than one concern appears under each of them, so these rows add up to more than the number of cases in this view. A case can be denied on a different concern, so the line under each bar gives the judge’s formal finding on that concern itself. Case-level totals are in the section above. Open a row for the specific issues inside it; their bars are whole-case outcomes too. The concern filter narrows the other sections. In this section it highlights the row instead, so that concerns stay comparable with each other.

† marks fewer than 20 cases, too few to be reliable. A case can raise several concerns, so the rows overlap.

Mitigations judges credited most

How often each mitigation was expressly accepted by the judge, not merely claimed, across the cases in this view. This is a count of how often something was credited, so the bars are neutral: they carry no outcome.

Promptly corrected the falsification6
Acknowledgment & remorse6
Debt paid in full4
No subsequent offenses2
Documented abstinence period1
Passage of time1
Rehabilitation evidence1

Outcomes by representation

Whether represented and self-represented applicants were granted at different rates.

Represented by a lawyer

23% granted · 20 granted · 66 denied

Self-represented

10% granted · 24 granted · 212 denied

Difference

2.3 times

the grant rate with a lawyer

An association, not proof of cause: the groups being compared differ in many ways. Select a row to filter the page.

Outcomes by judge

How the cases each judge decided were resolved.

Window: 2017 to 2026, chosen so that changes over time are not mistaken for differences between judges. Adjust the time range above to change it.

† marks judges with fewer than 20 decided cases in this window. Judges hear different mixes of cases, so these rates describe the decided record, not the judges.

Appeal outcomes

How appealed decisions were treated by the Appeal Board.

The Appeal Board reviews the specific errors a party claims. It can affirm a decision, leaving it in place; reverse it, replacing the outcome; or remand it, sending it back to the judge. It does not rehear the case. Based on 1,311 appeal decisions with a verified outcome. Year and concern filters apply here; judge and representation filters do not.

  • affirmed · 1,161 of 1,311 (89%)
  • reversed · 98 of 1,311 (7%)
  • remanded · 52 of 1,311 (4%)

Most appeals do not change the outcome: the Board overturned about 7% of the decisions brought to it.

Appeals by party, with outcomes

Applicants appeal denials; the Government appeals grants it disagrees with. Whether an outcome helped the applicant therefore depends on who appealed.

  • The applicant

    Appeals
    1,174
    Affirmed
    1,136 (97%)
    Reversed
    5 (0%)
    Remanded
    33 (3%)
  • The Government (Department Counsel)

    Appeals
    131
    Affirmed
    20 (15%)
    Reversed
    93 (71%)
    Remanded
    18 (14%)
  • Both parties

    Appeals
    6
    Affirmed
    5 (83%)
    Reversed
    0 (0%)
    Remanded
    1 (17%)

Grounds for reversal or remand

The grounds the Board gave. A case can have more than one.

No rational connection from the facts to the conclusion115
Ignored material evidence108
Second-guessed credibility without a basis28
Missing findings13
Misapplied mitigation8
Other5
Lack of jurisdiction1
Incomplete record1

Errors alleged on appeal

The errors the parties raised, across every appeal in this selection.

Arbitrary, capricious, or contrary to law1,020
The judge mis-weighed or ignored evidence412
Erroneous finding of fact266
No specific harmful error alleged263
Mitigation wrongly applied140
Whole-person analysis79
Due process or fairness61
Credibility determination50
Judge bias or partiality42
Legal error33

Error found, but harmless

15%

of affirmances · 173 of 1,161

The Board agreed the judge erred but left the outcome in place, because the error did not change the result.

Most-cited authorities

  • Department of the Navy v. Egan867
  • Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n of the United States v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.386
  • Dorfmont v. Brown92
  • ISCR Case No. 06-17409 at 3 (App. Bd. Oct. 1283
  • ISCR Case No. 06-1740967
  • ISCR Case No. 06-10320 at 2 (App. Bd. Nov. 750
  • Consolo v. Federal Maritime Comm’n43
  • ISCR Case No. 06-1032041
Appeal Board judges by number of appeals

Appeals are decided by three-member panels, so an outcome belongs to the panel and not to any single judge. There is no per-judge rate for that reason.

James E. Moody · 811 appealsMichael Y. Ra'anan · 766 appealsWilliam S. Fields · 487 appealsJeffrey D. Billett · 385 appealsJames F. Duffy · 380 appealsJean E. Smallin · 325 appealsMoira D. Modzelewski · 209 appealsAllison Marie · 129 appealsMichael D. Hipple · 91 appealsJennifer I. Goldstein · 79 appealsEmilio Jaksetic · 70 appealsGregg A. Cervi · 56 appealsCharles C. Hale · 52 appealsJames B. Norman · 43 appeals

A structured reading of the decided public Appeal Board record. The outcome the Board stated matched our independent read in 100% of cases.

Browse appeal decisions

Questions about these statistics

The statistics assistant is part of Professional.

The statistics on this page are free, with or without a subscription.

It answers questions about the figures on this page, inside the filters you have set, with the denominator behind every number.

Professional plan details

Publications and measured series

Ongoing analyses computed from the decided record, each on its own page, with its method and the counts behind every rate.

Granted ÷ decided; † marks groups under 20 cases. Full methodology

Reading the statistics

  • Granted = access granted or continued; Denied = denied or revoked.
  • Grant rate = granted ÷ (granted + denied).
  • † marks figures based on fewer than 20 cases, too few to be reliable.
  • Hovering any rate shows its statistical range (a 95% confidence interval).
  • Figures are descriptive counts over decided, public DOHA ISCR decisions, never predictions or assessments of any pending case.

Decided public cases: descriptive, never a prediction.